ALE Property Group Overview
ALE Property Group was Australia's largest owner of freehold pub properties and one of the most distinctive single-tenant REITs on the ASX. It was formed in November 2003 when Foster's Group exited hotels. ALE took the freehold real estate, and Australian Leisure and Hospitality Group (ALH), later part of Endeavour Group, took the operating businesses under 25-year triple-net leases. At 30 June 2021 ALE owned 82 pubs in all five mainland states, valued at A$1.29 billion. Roughly 87% of value sat in metropolitan Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane, and every asset was leased to ALH. The investment case rested on three things: uncapped annual CPI escalators with a floor, a material under-renting gap that independent valuers put at about 33–37%, and an uncapped, uncollared market rent review in November 2028. That embedded reversion, plus scarce well-located land, ultimately attracted a A$1.68 billion takeover by Charter Hall and Hostplus in 2021.
Company's own description (FY2021 Annual Report, paraphrased). ALE described itself as the owner of Australia's largest portfolio of freehold pub properties. It was established in November 2003 and owned 82 pubs across the five mainland states, all leased to ALH, a wholly owned subsidiary of Endeavour Group Limited. The average remaining initial lease term was 7.3 years, plus tenant extension options [S1].
Business model. ALE was a pure-play, internally managed landlord. It owned land, buildings and fixed improvements. The tenant held the plant and equipment, the liquor and gaming licences, the leasehold improvements and certain development rights [S1]. ALE did not operate any venue. Its income was almost entirely rent from one counterparty.
Revenue model. Revenue was effectively 100% contractual lease income. In FY2021, rent from investment properties was A$62.47 million of A$62.57 million total revenue, and the rest was interest on cash deposits [S1]. There was no product, subscription or licensing revenue.
Value chain position. ALE sat at the real-estate ownership layer of the on-premise hospitality and off-premise liquor retail chain. ALH ran pubs, gaming rooms and accommodation on the sites, and also traded BWS and Dan Murphy's stores from many of them. In 2020, ALH was trading from 66 BWS and 23 Dan Murphy's stores located on ALE-owned land [S6].
Customers and end-markets. There was one customer, ALH (Endeavour Group). The underlying end-markets were Australian pub hospitality (food, beverage, gaming and accommodation) and packaged liquor retail.
Independent characterisation. ALE was best understood as a long-duration, inflation-linked bond with an embedded real option. The bond was the CPI-escalating rent stream backed by a top-50 ASX tenant. The option was the 2028 uncapped review plus land value and redevelopment potential on low-site-coverage, mostly metropolitan sites. Its main weaknesses were total single-tenant concentration, high gearing in its early years, and a lease structure that produced repeated, costly disputes with its tenant.
Strategy
Stated strategy (FY2021 report, paraphrased). ALE's strategy was to preserve and enhance the profitability and value of its portfolio for securityholders [S1]. In practice it had five pillars:
-
Protect and maximise rent reversion. This covered pursuing the 2018 review and contesting determinations it believed misapplied the lease methodology, with the 2028 uncapped review as the main value event.
-
Recycle non-core assets. After the September 2020 determinations, ALE analysed long-run total returns by asset, designated non-core properties and sold six at a 24.2% premium to book [S1].
-
Optimise capital and hedging. Steps included the A$250 million refinancing in March 2021, diversifying into bilateral bank debt, and restructuring hedges to cut the cost of debt [S1].
-
Distribution policy. Guidance was 21.5 cents for FY2021, with distributions after FY2021 expected to grow by at least CPI. FY2022 guidance was about 22.0 cents, paid quarterly [S1][S12].
-
Unlock surplus land. ALE had long pursued work with ALH to monetise or develop under-used land [S6].
Initiatives in the final 24 months (FY2020–FY2021): CEO succession (October 2020); the Supreme Court proceedings (October 2020); the full portfolio revaluation at December 2020; the A$250 million refinancing (March 2021); hedge restructures (August 2020 and June 2021); six asset sales; suspension of the DRP; the move to quarterly distributions from FY2022; and the strategic review and recommendation of the Charter Hall proposal (July–September 2021) [S1][S2].
ESG commitments. No formal targets were disclosed.
Medium-term targets. ALE published no formal medium-term financial targets beyond its distribution guidance. Current owner targets are not applicable to ALE as a standalone entity.
Products & Services
ALE's "products" were its individual freehold properties. All were leased to ALH, and most combined a pub, a gaming room and a BWS or Dan Murphy's bottle shop. The full register at 30 June 2021 (A$ thousand, fair value) is below [S1]. "IV" means independent valuation at 30 June 2021 and "DV" means directors' valuation. Acquisition is November 2003 unless shown otherwise.
New South Wales (10 properties)
Queensland (27 continuing plus 2 held for sale; 3 sold in FY2021)
Note: the FY2021 report gives both A$11.3 million (sale price) and A$13.647 million (carrying value) for Noosa Reef. The two figures are reproduced as published and this discrepancy is unreconciled.
South Australia (7)
Note: the column order in the SA and WA sections of the source extraction was partly ambiguous. Values follow the order that reconciles to the state totals (SA A$41.6 million in FY2020 and A$44.2 million in FY2021).
Western Australia (4)
Victoria (30 continuing plus 2 held for sale; 1 sold)
Note: some IV/DV-era Victorian figures appear in a different order in the source extraction (for example, Bayswater appears as both 21,800 and 24,650). Where the column order is ambiguous, the higher figure is assumed to be FY2021, consistent with the reported Victorian total of A$574.67 million (continuing, excluding held for sale) [S1].
Flagship assets named by management and the acquirer included the Young & Jackson (Melbourne), the Crows Nest Hotel (Sydney), the Breakfast Creek Hotel (Brisbane) and the New Brighton Hotel (Manly) [S4][S10].
Pricing model: rent set under the leases, with CPI escalators and market reviews in 2018 (±10%) and 2028 (uncapped). Gross rent per property ranged from about A$84,000 to A$1.89 million a year in FY2021 [S1].
Product Portfolio
| Property | Location | FV Jun-2020 | FV Jun-2021 | Valuation basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Blacktown Inn | Blacktown | 14,300 | 17,130 | DV |
Brown Jug Hotel | Fairfield Heights | 15,000 | 17,200 | IV |
Colyton Hotel | Colyton | 21,700 | 24,700 | IV |
Crows Nest Hotel | Crows Nest | 23,800 | 29,630 | DV |
Melton Hotel | Auburn | 8,400 | 9,900 | IV |
Narrabeen Sands Hotel (acq. Mar-2009) | Narrabeen | 16,000 | 17,900 | IV |
New Brighton Hotel | Manly | 11,600 | 13,470 | DV |
Pioneer Tavern | Penrith | 15,400 | 17,900 | IV |
Pritchard's Hotel (acq. Oct-2007) | Mount Pritchard | 31,300 | 37,900 | IV |
Smithfield Tavern | Smithfield | 10,400 | 12,700 | IV |
| Property | Location | FV Jun-2020 | FV Jun-2021 | Basis / status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Albany Creek Tavern | Albany Creek | 18,800 | 22,300 | DV |
Alderley Arms Hotel | Alderley | 7,500 | 7,850 | DV |
Anglers Arms Hotel | Southport | 11,700 | 13,000 | IV |
Balaclava Hotel | Cairns | 13,000 | 15,300 | IV |
Breakfast Creek Hotel | Breakfast Creek | 23,800 | 27,100 | IV (flagship) |
Burleigh Heads Hotel (acq. Nov-2008) | Burleigh Heads | 15,200 | 18,200 | DV |
Camp Hill Hotel | Camp Hill | 6,400 | 7,050 | DV |
Chardons Corner Hotel | Annerley | 3,800 | 4,300 | IV |
Dalrymple Hotel | Townsville | 13,100 | 15,550 | DV |
Edge Hill Tavern | Manoora | 6,300 | 7,500 | IV |
Four Mile Creek (acq. Jun-2004) | Strathpine | 9,600 | 10,900 | DV |
Hamilton Hotel | Hamilton | 17,000 | 18,750 | DV |
Holland Park Hotel | Holland Park | 15,400 | 17,000 | IV |
Kirwan Tavern | Townsville | 12,300 | 14,200 | IV |
Lawnton Tavern | Lawnton | 9,800 | 9,300 | IV |
Miami Tavern (incl. adjacent lot, Apr-2018) | Miami | 15,770 | 19,720 | IV |
Mount Gravatt Hotel | Mount Gravatt | 7,500 | 8,800 | DV |
Mount Pleasant Tavern | Mackay | 10,900 | 13,000 | IV |
Nudgee Beach Hotel | Nudgee | 7,000 | 8,050 | DV |
Palm Beach Hotel | Palm Beach | 14,900 | 16,500 | IV |
Prince of Wales Hotel | Nundah | 9,600 | 10,800 | DV |
Racehorse Hotel | Booval | 6,900 | 9,700 | IV |
Redland Bay Hotel | Redland Bay | 10,500 | 11,100 | DV |
Springwood Hotel | Springwood | 21,500 | 26,100 | DV |
Stones Corner Hotel | Stones Corner | 11,000 | 11,650 | DV |
Vale Hotel | Townsville | 13,600 | 16,650 | DV |
Wilsonton Hotel | Toowoomba | 13,400 | 15,225 | DV |
Royal Exchange Hotel | Toowong | 10,100 | 10,700 | Held for sale |
Noosa Reef Hotel (acq. Jun-2004) | Noosa Heads | 11,500 | 13,647 | Sold, settled 26-Jul-2021 for A$11.3M per FY21 report (figures as reported) |
Edinburgh Castle Hotel | Kedron | 7,700 | 0 | Sold Jun-2021 |
Kedron Park Hotel | Kedron Park | 4,800 | 0 | Sold Apr-2021 |
Pelican Waters | Caloundra | 7,600 | 0 | Sold Apr-2021 |
| Property | Location | FV Jun-2020 | FV Jun-2021 | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Aberfoyle Hub Tavern | Aberfoyle Park | 7,200 | 7,900 | DV |
Eureka Tavern | Salisbury | 6,350 | 6,200 | DV |
Exeter Hotel | Exeter | 5,000 | 5,550 | DV |
Finsbury Hotel | Woodville North | 4,700 | 4,900 | DV |
Gepps Cross Hotel | Blair Athol | 8,500 | 8,000 | IV |
Hendon Hotel | Royal Park | 4,950 | 4,200 | IV |
Stockade Tavern | Salisbury | 6,200 | 6,150 | IV |
| Property | Location | FV Jun-2020 | FV Jun-2021 | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Queens Tavern | Highgate | 10,090 | 10,450 | DV |
Sail & Anchor Hotel | Fremantle | 4,700 | 5,180 | DV |
The Brass Monkey Hotel (acq. Nov-2007) | Northbridge | 9,550 | 9,500 | DV |
Balmoral Hotel (acq. Jul-2007) | East Victoria Park | 7,450 | 7,350 | DV |
| Property | Location | FV Jun-2020 | FV Jun-2021 | Basis / status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Ashley Hotel | Braybrook | 11,300 | 11,740 | DV |
Bayswater Hotel | Bayswater | 21,800 | 24,650 | IV |
Berwick Inn (acq. Feb-2006) | Berwick | 20,800 | 21,310 | DV |
Blackburn Hotel | Blackburn | 19,200 | 19,450 | IV |
Blue Bell Hotel | Wendouree | 5,500 | 6,030 | DV |
Burvale Hotel | Nunawading | 25,000 | 29,610 | DV |
Club Hotel | Ferntree Gully | 11,500 | 11,450 | IV |
Cramers Hotel | Preston | 18,300 | 21,170 | DV |
Deer Park Hotel | Deer Park | 17,500 | 19,150 | IV |
Doncaster Inn | Doncaster | 26,600 | 33,010 | DV |
Ferntree Gully Hotel/Motel | Ferntree Gully | 9,400 | 9,300 | IV |
Gateway Hotel | Corio | 9,800 | 10,250 | DV |
Keysborough Hotel | Keysborough | 26,500 | 26,650 | IV |
Mac's Melton Hotel | Melton | 17,000 | 18,300 | IV |
Meadow Inn Hotel/Motel | Fawkner | 20,000 | 22,950 | DV |
Mitcham Hotel | Mitcham | 17,800 | 19,640 | DV |
Olinda Creek Hotel | Lilydale | 8,900 | 8,800 | IV |
Pier Hotel | Frankston | 16,700 | 16,720 | DV |
Plough Hotel | Mill Park | 19,550 | 21,420 | DV |
Prince Mark Hotel | Doveton | 22,000 | 26,210 | DV |
Royal Exchange | Traralgon | 7,000 | 7,280 | DV |
Sandbelt Club Hotel | Moorabbin | 24,350 | 29,960 | DV |
Sandown Park Hotel/Motel | Noble Park | 16,000 | 16,640 | DV |
Sandringham Hotel | Sandringham | 13,000 | 16,720 | DV |
Somerville Hotel | Somerville | 8,500 | 8,900 | IV |
Stamford Inn | Rowville | 30,100 | 31,800 | IV |
Sylvania Hotel | Campbellfield | 13,350 | 14,100 | IV |
The Vale Hotel | Mulgrave | 16,000 | 16,850 | IV |
Village Green Hotel | Mulgrave | 25,550 | 28,260 | DV |
Young & Jackson | Melbourne CBD | 23,400 | 26,350 | IV (flagship) |
Boundary Hotel (acq. Jun-2008) | East Bentleigh | 27,500 | 32,689 | Sold, settlement 10-Sep-2021 |
Tudor Inn | Cheltenham | 11,850 | 11,900 | Held for sale |
Morwell Hotel | Morwell | 3,100 | 0 | Sold Apr-2021 |
Financial Narrative
All figures are A$, fiscal years ending 30 June, from ALE's FY2021 Annual Report [S1] unless stated otherwise. ALE's management measure was "Distributable Income", a non-IFRS figure that excludes fair value movements and non-cash items. ALE never published any FY2022+ accounts.
Five-year key metrics (management-reported)
Analyst-derived CAGRs (FY2017–FY2021): distributable income about 4.3% a year; distribution per security about 1.3% a year; property value about 4.6% a year.
Income statement (statutory)
FY2019 statutory profit is from [S7].
Gross profit and operating income are not meaningful for a net-lease landlord. EBITDA here means total revenue less management/admin expenses and land tax, before fair value items; it is an analyst calculation, not a company disclosure.
Distributable income bridge, FY2021 vs FY2020 [S1]: distributable income rose A$4.0 million. The drivers were CPI rent increases, backdated rent increases from November 2018 on 36 properties after the September 2020 determinations, and lower cash finance costs (A$17.2 million vs A$22.0 million). Higher management expenses offset part of this, reflecting CEO transition, legal and insurance costs. Directors' and officers' insurance premiums rose from about A$0.39 million to A$1.04 million.
Payout dynamics. ALE paid distributions above distributable income in every year shown. In FY2021, A$42.8 million was distributed against A$34.4 million of distributable income. The gap was funded by DRP issuance (A$12.2 million attributable to FY2021 distributions) and capital and surplus cash. This deliberate policy rested on the board's confidence in under-renting and the 2028 review [S1].
Balance sheet
FY2020 working capital is an analyst calculation (current assets less current liabilities). The FY2021 figure is company-reported and inflated by A$68.9 million of property held for sale. ALE had no short-term debt at either balance date; all borrowings were non-current, with the first maturity in August 2022.
Cash flow
Note: the FY2021 cash flow statement columns were partly transposed in the extracted source. The figures above are the allocation that reconciles to the reported net change in cash (+A$6.457 million in FY2020 and +A$4.053 million in FY2021). Capital works were the tenant's responsibility for 79 of the 82 properties, and no property additions were recorded in either year.
Ratios (analyst-derived from [S1])
ROIC and the cash conversion cycle are not meaningful for a single-tenant landlord with no inventory, and are not reported. The company reported an interest cover ratio of 2.6x at June 2018 and 2.5x at June 2019 [S7].
Commentary. Three findings stand out across five years. First, earnings were flat to slightly down from FY2017 to FY2019 (A$29.1 million to A$28.3 million), even as CPI lifted rents. Heavy legacy hedging costs and A$3.1 million of FY2019 rent-review expenses absorbed the growth [S6]. Second, FY2020–FY2021 marked an inflection. The determinations ended review costs and delivered backdated rent, and the August 2020 and June 2021 hedge restructures cut average hedge rates from 3.53% to 2.22% for a A$16.9 million upfront payment. Cost of debt fell 63 basis points, which lifted FY2021 distributable income 13% [S1]. Third, statutory earnings were dominated by revaluations. Cap-rate compression of 49 basis points (5.08% to 4.59%) produced a A$141.3 million gain, taking NTA up 24% to A$3.71. Valuers' DCF work implied an even lower 4.24% yield on the sample [S1]. Leverage improved steadily, from 68.3% gearing in FY2009 to 36.4% in FY2021, although net debt to EBITDA of about 9.7x stayed high by REIT standards. That was tolerable only because of the tenant's credit quality and the long-dated, hedged debt book.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansFinancial Detail
Group Entities
| Entity | Role |
|---|---|
Australian Leisure and Entertainment Property Trust | Parent entity and deemed acquirer of the stapled group |
Australian Leisure and Entertainment Property Management Limited | Stapled company. Responsible Entity of the Trust and holder of the AFSL |
ALE Direct Property Trust | Sub-trust and the AMTN-issuing entity. Covenant gearing is measured at this level |
ALE Finance Company Pty Limited | Finance company, associated with the Capital Indexed Bonds |
Revenue by Segment
| Metric | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|
Rent from investment properties (AUD Mn) | 61.41 | 62.47 |
Interest from cash deposits (AUD Mn) | 0.30 | 0.10 |
Total revenue (AUD Mn) | 61.71 | 62.57 |
Distributable income (AUD Mn) | 30.41 | 34.37 |
Profit before income tax (AUD Mn) | 20.02 | 179.44 |
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansKey Financials and Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2017 | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Distributable income (AUD Mn) | 29.1 | 29.0 | 28.3 | 30.4 | 34.4 |
Distribution per security (AUD cents) | 20.40 | 20.80 | 20.90 | 20.90 | 21.50 |
Investment property value (AUD Mn) | 1,080.2 | 1,136.3 | 1,163.2 | 1,174.2 | 1,294.3 |
Covenant gearing (%) | 42.7 | 41.6 | 41.5 | 41.3 | 36.4 |
Income Statement
| Metric | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|---|
Statutory profit after tax (AUD Mn) | 26.6 | 20.0 | 179.2 |
Distributable income (AUD Mn) | 28.3 | 30.4 | 34.4 |
Income Statement and Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|
Rental income (AUD Mn) | 61.41 | 62.47 |
Total revenue (AUD Mn) | 61.71 | 62.57 |
Fair value gain on investment property (AUD Mn) | 10.93 | 141.30 |
Fair value gain/(loss) on derivatives (AUD Mn) | -17.31 | 6.09 |
Profit on sale of properties (AUD Mn) | 0.00 | 4.23 |
Management and administration expenses (AUD Mn) | 6.15 | 7.89 |
Queensland land tax (AUD Mn) | 3.33 | 3.31 |
Finance costs, cash and non-cash (AUD Mn) | 25.86 | 23.54 |
Profit before tax (AUD Mn) | 20.02 | 179.44 |
Income tax expense (AUD Mn) | -0.01 | 0.27 |
Net profit after tax (AUD Mn) | 20.02 | 179.17 |
Basic EPS (AUD cents) | 10.23 | 90.37 |
Diluted EPS (AUD cents) | 10.22 | 90.14 |
Distributable income per security (AUD cents) | 15.53 | 17.15 |
Distribution per security (AUD cents) | 20.90 | 21.50 |
EBITDA, analyst-derived (AUD Mn) | 52.23 | 51.37 |
EBITDA margin, analyst-derived (%) | 84.6 | 82.1 |
Distributable income margin (%) | 49.3 | 54.9 |
Statutory net margin (%) | 32.4 | 286.3 |
Balance Sheet and Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|
Total assets (AUD Mn) | 1,214.88 | 1,339.98 |
Investment properties incl. held for sale (AUD Mn) | 1,174.16 | 1,294.26 |
Cash and cash equivalents (AUD Mn) | 39.57 | 43.62 |
Borrowings, carrying value (AUD Mn) | 551.41 | 540.89 |
Gross debt incl. CIB indexation (AUD Mn) | 556.74 | 543.14 |
Net debt, carrying basis (AUD Mn) | 511.84 | 497.27 |
Derivative liabilities (AUD Mn) | 52.03 | 29.02 |
Total liabilities (AUD Mn) | 630.28 | 596.99 |
Total equity (AUD Mn) | 584.60 | 742.98 |
Contributed equity (AUD Mn) | 258.12 | 280.19 |
Goodwill and intangibles (AUD Mn) | 0 | 0 |
NTA per security (AUD) | 2.98 | 3.71 |
Net working capital, company-reported (AUD Mn) | 13.52 | 87.40 |
Capital Instruments
| Instrument | Rate (incl. hedging) | Issued | Maturity | Face value (AUD Mn) | Carrying incl. indexation (AUD Mn) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AMTN (fixed) | 4.00% | Mar-2017 | 20-Aug-2022 | 150.0 | 150.0 |
Capital Indexed Bond | 3.40% real | May-2006 | 20-Nov-2023 | 111.9 | 158.1 |
AMTN (floating) | 2.39% | Mar-2021 | 20-Aug-2024 | 150.0 | 150.0 |
Bank loan | 2.04% | Mar-2021 | 29-Mar-2023 | 25.0 | 25.0 |
Bank loan | 2.74% | Mar-2021 | 29-Mar-2024 | 10.0 | 10.0 |
Bank loan | 3.19% | Mar-2021 | 29-Mar-2025 | 50.0 | 50.0 |
Total | — | — | — | 496.9 | 543.1 |
Cash Flow
| Metric | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|
Net operating cash flow (AUD Mn) | 27.42 | 32.17 |
Capital expenditure on properties (AUD Mn) | 0 | 0 |
Free cash flow, OCF less capex (AUD Mn) | 27.42 | 32.17 |
Property disposal proceeds (AUD Mn) | 0 | 25.43 |
Hedge restructure/termination payments (AUD Mn) | 0 | 16.92 |
Cash distributions paid (AUD Mn) | 40.92 | 19.66 |
Distributions satisfied via DRP, non-cash (AUD Mn) | 0 | 22.07 |
Proceeds from borrowings (AUD Mn) | 250.00 | 250.00 |
Repayment of borrowings (AUD Mn) | 225.00 | 265.00 |
Security buybacks (AUD Mn) | 0 | 0 |
Returns & Leverage Ratios (%) and Financial Ratios (x)
| Metric | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|
ROE on closing equity (%) | 3.4 | 24.1 |
ROA on closing assets (%) | 1.6 | 13.4 |
Distributable ROE on closing equity (%) | 5.2 | 4.6 |
Current ratio (x) | 1.50 | 4.23 |
Debt to equity (x) | 0.94 | 0.73 |
Net debt to EBITDA (x) | 9.8 | 9.7 |
EBITDA interest cover on cash finance costs (x) | 2.37 | 2.99 |
Asset turnover (x) | 0.051 | 0.047 |
Weighted average cost of debt (%) | 4.11 | 3.48 |
Weighted average cap rate (%) | 5.08 | 4.59 |
WALE (years) | 8.3 | 7.3 |
Revenue by Region
| Metric | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|
Victoria portfolio value (AUD Mn) | 564.85 | 619.26 |
Queensland portfolio value (AUD Mn) | 367.97 | 399.94 |
New South Wales portfolio value (AUD Mn) | 167.90 | 198.43 |
South Australia portfolio value (AUD Mn) | 41.60 | 44.20 |
Western Australia portfolio value (AUD Mn) | 31.79 | 32.48 |
Total (AUD Mn) | 1,174.11 | 1,294.31 |
Valuation Snapshot
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
LEP close after the September 2020 determinations | About A$4.30 |
LEP price on the deal announcement (20-Sep-2021) | About A$5.66 (+20.4% intraday) |
Implied undisturbed price | About A$4.70 (analyst-derived) |
Scheme consideration | A$5.68 headline; CLW securities valued at A$5.1754 on implementation |
Total return, listing to 30-Jun-2019 | 20.1% a year (A$1.00 grew to A$17.44 with distributions reinvested) |
FY2018 total securityholder return | 24.5% |
Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2017 | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Distribution per security (AUD cents) | 20.40 | 20.80 | 20.90 | 20.90 | 21.50 |
Capital Markets Data
| Metric | FY2023 | FY2024 | FY2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
Debt maturing (AUD Mn) | 175.0 | 168.1 | 200.0 |
Analyst Conclusions
Management guidance (last issued): FY2022 distributions of about 22.0 cents, growing by at least CPI thereafter [S1][S12]. It was superseded by the takeover. No standalone guidance or consensus exists for ALE today.
Bull case (as it stood in 2021, and for current owners):
-
Under-renting of 35.6–43.5% [S1] implied passing income of A$57.7m against market rent of A$78.8m (Charter Hall estimate) [S4]. The uncapped 2028 review could lift rent by about 37% if ALH renews.
-
The October 2021 court win removed tenant-influenced methodology from future determinations, strengthening the landlord's hand going into 2028 [S6].
-
With site coverage of about 25% on 91.5 hectares of metropolitan land, the portfolio offers long-dated mixed-use upside [S4].
Bear case:
-
ALH can decline to renew in 2028. That would avoid the uncapped review and could trigger put options requiring the landlord to buy the operating businesses at market value [S1].
-
Rising rates since 2022 lifted cap rates. CLW reported about 100 basis points of expansion over 2.5 years to December 2024 [S13], eroding the 4.59% valuation base.
-
Gaming and liquor reform, along with ESG exclusions, could compress tenant EBITDAR and the pool of buyers [S1][S5].
Analyst verdict. ALE Property Group's 18 years as a listed company are a case study in how lease design can matter more than asset quality. The portfolio was always excellent: well-located metropolitan pubs with large land holdings, operated by the country's dominant publican and leased on triple-net, inflation-protected terms. Yet for most of its life ALE traded as a bond proxy. Securityholders did well on long-run total return, reported at 20.1% a year to 2019, but annual distributable earnings barely moved between FY2017 and FY2019. Heavy legacy debt, expensive hedging and costly disputes with its only tenant absorbed CPI growth. The September 2020 rent determinations showed the central weakness of a single-tenant landlord: when the counterparty pushes back, there is no diversification to absorb it.
Management's FY2021 response was effective. Non-core assets sold at a 24% premium to book, a cheaper and more diversified debt stack replaced the old one, hedges were reset, and ALE took on the determinations in court and won. These steps lifted NTA by 24% and made visible the embedded reversion that private capital had long noticed. The Charter Hall–Hostplus offer at A$5.68 captured much of that value for securityholders, at about a 38% premium to the revised NTA, before the 2028 review and the court ruling could fully prove it.
From today's vantage point, the takeover looks well-timed for sellers. It closed at the tail end of the low-rate era, before cap rates expanded from 2022. The buyers acquired a long-dated real option whose value depends on ALH's 2028 renewal decisions and on Endeavour's ability to sustain hotel earnings under tighter gaming regulation. For an analyst tracking this asset class today, the former ALE portfolio is now best monitored through CLW's disclosures. Its 2028 rent review remains one of the more significant, if binary, events in Australian net-lease real estate.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansExecutive Leadership
Executive Leadership Team
| Name | Title | Tenure | Background / education |
|---|---|---|---|
Guy Farrands | Managing Director and CEO | From 1 Oct 2020 | 30+ years in direct and listed property. Formerly MD/CEO of GEO Property Group (later Villa World), CEO of Valad Property Group, CFO of Viva Energy REIT, and Division Director in Macquarie's real estate investment banking group. NED of Aspen Group. Grad Dip Man, FAPI, MAICD |
Andrew Wilkinson | Former MD and CEO | CEO from Nov 2003; MD 16 Nov 2004 – 30 Sep 2020 | About 35 years in banking, corporate finance and funds management. Former corporate finance partner at PwC, with 15 years at ANZ Capel Court and Schroders. B.Bus, CFTP, MAICD |
Michael Clarke | CFO and Company Secretary | Joined Oct 2006; Company Secretary from 30 Jun 2016 | 35+ years in accounting, tax and finance, including 12 years at Grant Thornton. B.Com (UNSW), MMan (Macquarie GSM), CA, ACIS |
Andrew Slade | Capital Manager | Role redundant from 1 Jul 2021 | Not detailed |
Directors' Remuneration
| Executive | Salary and fees | STI cash | Super | Leave | Termination | ESSS (deferred equity) | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Guy Farrands (from 1 Oct 2020) | 346,575 | 145,500 | 17,175 | 122 | 0 | 145,500 | 654,872 |
Andrew Wilkinson (to 30 Sep 2020; employment ended 31 Mar 2021) | 355,074 | 63,129 | 16,270 | 145,355 | 0 | 0 | 579,828 |
Andrew Slade | 257,923 | 118,837 | 21,694 | 2,345 | 193,961 | 0 | 594,760 |
Michael Clarke | 278,306 | 40,000 | 21,694 | 1,806 | 0 | 40,000 | 381,806 |
Board of Directors
| Director | Role | Appointed | Committees | Background |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Robert Mactier | Independent Non-Executive Chair | Director 28 Nov 2016; Chair 23 May 2017 | Remuneration & Nominations (member); ACRMC (member) | UBS consultant since 2007. Former Chair of WPP AUNZ (2006–May 2021) and NED of Melco Resorts. Earlier career at KPMG, Ord Minnett, E.L. & C. Baillieu and Citigroup. B Ec, MAICD |
Pippa Downes | Independent NED | 26 Nov 2013 | ACRMC (Chair from 26 Oct 2015); Rem & Nom (member) | Former MD and Equity Partner at Goldman Sachs Australia. NED of Zip Co and Ingenia Communities; Commissioner of Sport Australia |
Paul Say | Independent NED | 24 Sep 2014 | Rem & Nom (Chair from 4 Aug 2015); ACRMC (member) | Former Dexus CIO (2007–2012) and Lend Lease Head of Corporate Finance. NED of Frasers Logistics & Industrial Trust and Cedar Woods. FRICS, FAPI |
Nancy Milne OAM | Independent NED | 6 Feb 2015 | Rem & Nom; ACRMC | Former Clayton Utz partner. Chair of Securities Exchanges Guarantee Corporation and of the Accounting Professional and Ethical Standards Board |
Michael Triguboff | NED (nominee of Caledonia (Private) Investments) | 15 Feb 2018 | — | Founding director of Adexum Capital. Former global partner at Lazard Frères |
Bernard Stanton | NED (nominee of Caledonia (Private) Investments) | 13 Sep 2019 | ACRMC (from Aug 2020) | Executive Director at Caledonia funds management (2005–2019). B Ec, MBA |
Guy Farrands | Managing Director | 1 Oct 2020 | — | See above |
Major Shareholders
| Holder | Stake | Notes |
|---|---|---|
Directors' direct holdings (30 Jun 2021) | About 172,313 securities, under 0.1% | Mactier 50,000; Downes 77,313; Say 25,000; Milne 20,000 [S1] |
Executives | Slade 105,956; Clarke 34,471 securities plus ESSS rights | [S1] |
Competitive Landscape
Key Competitors
| Competitor / peer | Type | Relevance | Scale (as available) |
|---|---|---|---|
Hotel Property Investments (HPI) | Formerly ASX-listed pub REIT; mainly Queensland pubs leased to Queensland Venue Co | Closest listed pure-play peer | — |
Charter Hall Long WALE Investment Partnership (LWIP) | Unlisted Charter Hall/Hostplus vehicle | Rival Endeavour-leased pub landlord before 2021; now a co-owner affiliate | 62 Endeavour-leased assets at 2021 [S2] |
Charter Hall Long WALE REIT (CLW) | ASX-listed diversified long-lease REIT | Acquirer; now co-owns ALE | About A$5.5bn portfolio, WALE 9.7 years, NTA A$4.62 (31-Dec-2024) [S13] |
Endeavour Group / ALH | Operator with owned freeholds | Competes for pub freeholds and expands through acquisitions | About 330 pubs, FY18 turnover about A$4.3bn [S10][S11] |
Laundy Hotels | Private pub owner-operator | Major Sydney pub buyer | Reported as Australia's largest hotel owner outside Woolworths [S5]; financials not disclosed |
Australian Venue Co | Private operator/owner (PE-backed) | Competing buyer | — |
Redcape Hotel Group | Pub owner-operator vehicle | Competing pub investment vehicle | — |
Waypoint REIT (ASX: WPR) | Fuel and convenience long-lease REIT | Competes for long-WALE investor capital | — |
Charter Hall Retail REIT (ASX: CQR) | Convenience retail REIT | Competes for long-lease capital; Charter Hall pub co-investments | — |
Arena REIT (ASX: ARF) | Social infrastructure long-lease REIT | Competes for long-WALE capital | — |
“—” = not publicly disclosed.
Peer Comparison FY2021
| Metric | ALE (FY2021) | CLW (Dec-2024) |
|---|---|---|
Portfolio value | A$1.29bn | About A$5.5bn |
WALE | 7.3 years | 9.7 years |
Gearing | 36.4% (covenant basis) | 31.8% (balance sheet) |
Cap rate | 4.59% | 5.4% |
Recent Developments
ALE has generated no corporate newsflow since delisting in December 2021. This register covers the final 18 months of its listed life plus later events relevant to the portfolio.



