Company ProfilePremium

Carbon Minerals Limited

Company Profile Analysis

Ticker: CRM.AX

ESOMAR 23 Corporate BadgeISO Certifications Badge
Carbon Minerals Limited - Company showcase

Year Founded & Workforce

1980

Carbon Minerals Limited logo

Carbon Minerals Limited Employee Contacts

We don't hold contact details for this company yet — you can request them.

Request Employee Contacts

Carbon Minerals Limited Overview

FieldSupplied in requestVerified / current positionComment
Legal nameCarbon Minerals LimitedCarbon Minerals Limited (ABN 29 001 836 586)Confirmed (FY2011 Annual Report)
CountryAustraliaAustralia (incorporated and domiciled in NSW)Confirmed
ExchangeAustralian Securities ExchangeFormerly ASX; removed from Official List 14 Feb 2024Delisted, now unlisted public company
TickerCRM.AXASX: CRM (inactive since delisting)Ticker no longer trades
ISINCA79467F1062—The "CA" prefix denotes a Canadian-issued security and cannot belong to an Australian-incorporated company. Australian ISINs begin with "AU". The supplied ISIN appears to be a data error in the source list. The correct AU ISIN is not publicly disclosed in sources reviewed.
Websitehttp://www.carbonminerals.com.auDomain cited in company filings; Market Index lists website as "-"Site status not confirmed; likely inactive or unmaintained

Entity profiled: Carbon Minerals Limited, the same legal entity that was ASX-listed. It has not changed its name since converting from a no-liability company. No successor listed entity exists.

Core corporate data

ItemDetailSource
Legal nameCarbon Minerals LimitedFY2011 Annual Report
Former namesCarbon Minerals NL (ASX codes CRMCA from 20/06/2007, CRM from 06/10/2008)Market Index corporate record
Founding year1980. Formation sponsored via Magnum Explorations Limited; chairman's tenure dates from 25 January 1980FY2011 Annual Report (Chairman's address)
Incorporation jurisdictionNew South Wales, AustraliaFY2011 Annual Report
Registered office (last disclosed in primary filing)Level 7, 10 Barrack Street, Sydney NSW 2000FY2011 Annual Report; 2012 quarterlies
Operations / technical office (historic)Suite 2.06, 56 Delhi Road, North Ryde NSW 2113 (office of technical adviser Earth Resources Australia Pty Ltd)2012 quarterly reports
Exchange / tickerASX: CRM (suspended 9 Feb 2022; delisted 14 Feb 2024)InvestSMART, BusinessNews
Date listed per Market Index18 Aug 2008Market Index. This reflects re-coding after the NL-to-Limited conversion; the company was listed well before 2008, as it traded via 1980s–1990s capital events.
ISIN / CUSIPNot publicly disclosed in sources reviewed (supplied ISIN invalid for this entity)—
Fiscal year end31 DecemberAll annual reports
EmployeesNil. The company disclosed that it had no employees; the board performed management functions.FY2011 Corporate Governance Statement
Employee trend (3-year)Nil throughout (no evidence of change)—
AuditorPricewaterhouseCoopers (Sydney)FY2011 Annual Report; Market Index (current record)
Share registryMitchell & Partners (2011). Market Index currently lists Computershare. A "Details of Share Registry address" notice was lodged 7 Feb 2022.Discrepancy noted
Shares on issue18,803,498 ordinary shares (unchanged FY2010–FY2022)FY2011 AR; Market Index FY2022
Market capitalisationLast indicative: AUD 5.83M at AUD 0.31/share (FY2021–FY2022 per Morningstar). No current market value exists post-delisting.Market Index
Ultimate controlling entity (2011)Malewi Investments Pty Limited (Lincoln Smith family)FY2011 AR Note 20
Majority shareholder groupLincoln Smith interests: 80.81% (15,195,997 shares) as at 21 Mar 2023Market Index substantial holder data

Carbon Minerals Limited is a family-controlled Sydney exploration holding company. Its value rests on one asset: a 35% carried and participating interest, held through wholly owned subsidiary Australian Coalbed Methane Pty Limited (ACM), in Petroleum Exploration Licences 1 and 12 in the Gunnedah Basin of northern NSW. Santos QNT Pty Ltd holds the other 65% and operates. The company pioneered CSG exploration in the basin from 1992 and identified a biogenic gas fairway in 2004. It brought in Santos through a 2007 farm-in, then monetised 40% of the project for AUD 15 million in 2011.

The licences were renewed in April 2022 for six years, to April 2028. With no revenue, a treasury of roughly AUD 2.7 million and an 81% controlling holder, the company chose not to remediate its suspension and accepted ASX delisting in February 2024. Its residual value is effectively an option on Santos advancing Gunnedah Basin gas, adjacent to the Narrabri Gas Project.


What the company does

Carbon Minerals Limited is a natural resources exploration holding company. Its activities have three parts:

  1. Holding a minority non-operated interest in CSG exploration tenements. ACM holds 35% of PEL 1 and PEL 12. Santos QNT Pty Ltd holds 65% and is operator under a joint venture.

  2. Funding its share of joint-venture expenditure and administering the listed or unlisted corporate shell.

  3. Minor primary production. It grew crops on vacant freehold land, the "Glasserton" property south-south-east of Gunnedah, which the company owns. This was reported as a separate "Primary production" segment.

The company describes its principal continuing activity as exploration for natural resources in the Commonwealth of Australia (FY2011 Annual Report, Directors' Report). Data aggregators summarise it as a seam gas exploration and development company with its interest in the Gunnedah Basin CSG project (AnnualReports.com and Market Index company descriptions).

Business model and revenue model

Revenue elementNatureMateriality
Interest income on cash and term depositsPassive treasury incomeMain recurring income; AUD 253,413 in FY2011, about AUD 0.02M in FY2022
Technical and administration feesRecoveries from JV activityAUD 78,000 in FY2011
Access compensationLand access paymentsAUD 3,000 in FY2011
Crop sales (primary production)Agricultural use of owned landImmaterial; segment result was a loss
Asset monetisation (non-recurring)Sale of tenement equityAUD 15M cash received in FY2011 (gain AUD 12.86M)

Mix: There are no product, service, subscription or licensing revenues. The model is "exploration-and-farm-out." Value is created by de-risking acreage and sold or carried through farm-ins, rather than through operating revenue.

Value-chain position and end-markets

Value-chain position: Upstream, pre-development exploration. Non-operator, minority equity holder.

Ultimate end-market (if developed): East Australian domestic gas market, NSW in particular. NSW imports most of its gas from other states.

Customers: None at present. A future buyer of any produced gas would most plausibly be Santos itself or NSW domestic gas buyers via Santos marketing.

Independent characterisation: The company functions as a royalty-like option on Santos' Gunnedah Basin programme. Its economics are hostage to three things: Santos' capital allocation, NSW CSG policy, and native title and community licence-to-operate. It has no operational control and no operating cash flows. The controlling shareholder appears comfortable holding the asset privately rather than funding listed-company compliance.

Strategy

Stated strategy (paraphrased from filings)

Patience and persistence: The founder framed the strategy as long-horizon persistence in the Gunnedah Basin, modelled on the Vickery coal success, until exploration converts to value (FY2011 Chairman's address).

  • Convert contingent resources to reserves through the operator. Rely on Santos' agreed work programme to convert contingent resources to reserves and grow the resource base (FY2011 AR).

Local gas for NSW: Position Gunnedah CSG as a local, comparatively clean energy source for gas-short NSW (FY2011 AR).

Opportunistic monitoring: Watch for exploration opportunities in current areas and elsewhere in Australia (FY2011 AR, Other Activities).

Likely developments: Directors declined to give detail, citing unreasonable prejudice (FY2011 AR).

Initiatives in the last 24 months (Oct 2024–Oct 2026)

No company-level strategic initiatives, partnerships, ESG commitments, cost programmes or financial targets have been publicly disclosed. As a delisted company it no longer lodges announcements on the ASX. The effective strategic posture since 2022 appears to be:

  1. Retain the 35% interest following the April 2022 licence renewals.

  2. Minimise corporate costs by exiting the listing.

  3. Allow Santos to advance PEL 1 activity, such as the Kahlua-area works notified in 2023.

Medium-term guidance

None. Not publicly disclosed.

Products & Services

The company sells no products or services. Its "portfolio" is a set of tenement and land assets, catalogued below.

Pricing model: not applicable. Any gas would be sold under Santos-negotiated contracts, which are not publicly disclosed.

Product Portfolio

AssetSegmentDescriptionKey specificationsStatus / latest dateSource

PEL 1 (Gunnedah Basin, NSW)

Exploration

Petroleum Exploration Licence prospective for CSG (biogenic fairway plus Early Permian coals)

72 graticular blocks (2012). Runs from near Murrurundi north-west past Gunnedah toward Boggabri. ACM 35%, Santos 65% (operator)

Renewed 12 Apr 2022 to 12 Apr 2028

FY2011 AR tenement schedule; Namoi Valley Independent; Santos reports

PEL 12 (Gunnedah Basin, NSW)

Exploration

Adjoins PEL 1 to the west

31 blocks (2012). Granted 27 Sep 1995

Renewed 12 Apr 2022 to 12 Apr 2028

FY2011 AR; Santos PEL 12 report

Combined PEL 1 and 12 area

Exploration

Joint acreage

About 7,000 sq km (per 2007 company statement)

—

Energy News Bulletin

Contingent resource

Exploration

Total 3C contingent resource (gross, both PELs)

5,459 PJ (announced 2010). Net to ACM at 35% would be roughly 1,911 PJ (analyst arithmetic)

Not updated in sources reviewed

FY2011 AR

Kahlua pilot (PEL 1)

Exploration

Multi-well CSG pilot: production well Kahlua 2 plus monitor bores Kahlua 3, 4, 5

About 23 km west of Gunnedah. Operated Sep–Nov 2011

Santos notified further activities in the Kahlua area in 2023

FY2011 AR; Santos Kahlua factsheet 2023

Glasserton property / pilot site

Exploration and Primary production

Freehold farmland owned by the company. Proposed pilot location

About 44 km SSE of Gunnedah. Freehold land carried at AUD 736,080 (FY2011)

Pilot deferred (2011). Land retained (PP&E AUD 0.75M in FY2022)

FY2011 AR; Morningstar via Market Index

Cana corehole and Collygra chiphole (PEL 1)

Exploration

2011 exploration wells

Confirmed biogenic fairway resources

Completed 2011

FY2011 AR

Financial Narrative

Data sources: FY2010–FY2011 from the audited FY2011 Annual Report (ASX, 20 Apr 2012). FY2021–FY2022 from Morningstar via Market Index, in AUD millions. FY2018–FY2020 primary statements could not be retrieved; cells left blank. Figures labelled "derived" are analyst arithmetic from disclosed ratios and are flagged as such.

Income statement — latest five fiscal years

Gross, operating, EBITDA and net margins are not meaningful (nil revenue). Revenue CAGR is not meaningful.

Balance sheet

Derivation notes: Equity is book value per share (AUD 0.19 for FY2021, 0.18 for FY2022) times 18.80M shares. Current liabilities are total current assets divided by the reported current ratio (12.31 and 3.85). Enterprise value (Morningstar) of AUD 2.88M (FY2021) and AUD 3.13M (FY2022) equals market cap minus cash exactly, confirming zero debt.

FY2011 audited balance sheet (AUD): cash 15,077,549; total assets 17,898,774; exploration and evaluation asset 1,906,856; freehold land 736,080; total liabilities 2,735,707 (mainly income tax payable 2,552,257); equity 15,163,067; no borrowings. FY2010: total assets 4,948,495; equity 4,758,565.

Cash flow

Operating cash flow, capex (exploration spend) and free cash flow for FY2018–FY2022 are not publicly disclosed in retrievable form. Morningstar's price-to-cash-flow ratios of -22.60 (FY2021) and -33.58 (FY2022) imply operating outflows of about AUD 0.26M and 0.17M (analyst arithmetic: market cap divided by P/CF). FY2022 net change in cash is derived from the balance sheet.

FY2011 audited cash flow (AUD): operating outflow -121,229; investing inflow 14,968,432 (AUD 15.0M sale proceeds less AUD 31,568 costs); net increase in cash 14,847,203. FY2010: operating outflow -303,572.

Ratios

ROIC, net debt/EBITDA, interest coverage and cash conversion cycle are not meaningful: no debt, negative EBITDA, no working-capital cycle.

Commentary on trends, inflections and drivers

The 2011 inflection. The company's financial history has one defining event: the September 2011 renegotiation with Santos. Santos accelerated its earn-in to 65% and paid ACM AUD 15M cash. The deal turned an equity base of AUD 4.76M into AUD 15.16M and produced the only material profit in the disclosed record, NPAT of AUD 10.40M. It also brought a AUD 2.55M tax liability and an obligation to fund ACM's share of an agreed work programme. The FY2011 commitments note recorded AUD 13M of work-programme expenditure due within a year.

Cash erosion, 2012–2022. Cash fell from AUD 15.08M (Dec 2011) to AUD 2.95M (Dec 2021) and AUD 2.70M (Dec 2022). The year-by-year bridge is not verifiable from retrieved sources. It is consistent with three outflows: payment of the FY2011 tax liability in 2012; ACM's 35% share of JV exploration costs during the 2012–2014 programme; and annual corporate overheads of roughly AUD 0.2–0.4M. Any write-down of the exploration asset is not verifiable.

Steady-state burn. By FY2021–FY2022 the company was a cash shell. Annual losses were AUD 0.22–0.36M, interest income was negligible, and the CSG work programme was in abeyance under NSW policy. The FY2022 fall in the loss reflects slightly higher interest and other income (AUD 0.06M against 0.01M) and lower expenses (AUD 0.28M against 0.37M).

Liquidity shift. The drop in the current ratio from 12.3x to 3.9x implies current liabilities roughly tripled in FY2022, to an estimated AUD 0.73M. The cause is not disclosed in sources reviewed; candidates include accrued JV cash calls following licence renewal, or related-party payables.

Runway. At about AUD 0.25M per year of burn and no JV cash calls, the AUD 2.7M treasury would last roughly a decade. Any resumption of Santos-operated exploration would require ACM to fund 35% of costs or accept dilution, which changes the calculus sharply.

Unlock Company Financials

Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.

View Subscription Plans

Financial Detail

Group Entities

EntityCountryOwnershipFunctionSource

Carbon Minerals Limited

Australia

Parent

Holding company

FY2011 AR

Australian Coalbed Methane Pty Limited (ACM)

Australia

100%

Holder of the 35% interest in PEL 1 and PEL 12

FY2011 AR Note 25

Linger & Die Gold Pty Limited

Australia

100%

Dormant legacy gold vehicle (inferred from name; activity not disclosed)

FY2011 AR Note 25

Websters Find Gold Pty Limited

Australia

100%

Dormant legacy gold vehicle (inferred from name; activity not disclosed)

FY2011 AR Note 25

PEL 1 / PEL 12 Joint Venture

Unincorporated

ACM 35% / Santos QNT 65% (operator)

CSG exploration

Santos PEL 12 report; FY2011 AR

Revenue by Segment (AUD)

SegmentFY2010FY2011

Natural resources exploration revenue (AUD)

104,55813,190,524

Primary production revenue (AUD)

00

Total segment revenue (AUD)

104,55813,190,524

Revenue by Segment (AUD) — Natural resources exploration result

SegmentFY2010FY2011

Natural resources exploration result (AUD)

-192,74812,997,371

Primary production result (AUD)

-11,200-40,612

Total pre-tax result (AUD)

-203,94812,956,759

Segment Assets & Liabilities (AUD)

SegmentFY2010FY2011

Natural resources exploration assets (AUD)

4,579,78917,530,452

Primary production assets (AUD)

368,706368,322

Income Statement and Per-Share Data

MetricFY2021FY2022

Trading revenue (AUD Mn)

00

Other income (AUD Mn)

00.03

Interest income (AUD Mn)

0.010.02

Total income (AUD Mn)

0.010.06

Expenses (AUD Mn)

-0.37-0.28

EBITDA (AUD Mn)

-0.37-0.25

EBIT (AUD Mn)

-0.37-0.25

Pre-tax profit (AUD Mn)

-0.36-0.22

Net profit after tax (AUD Mn)

-0.36-0.22

EPS basic (AUD cents)

-1.90-1.19

EPS diluted (AUD cents)

-1.90-1.19

Dividends per share (AUD cents)

00

Income Statement (AUD) and Per-Share Data

MetricFY2010FY2011

Revenue from continuing operations (AUD)

48,991334,413

Net gain on sale of PEL interests (AUD)

012,856,111

Administration expenses (AUD)

-233,225-192,293

Profit before tax (AUD)

-203,94812,956,759

Income tax expense (AUD)

0-2,552,257

Net profit after tax (AUD)

-203,94810,404,502

EPS basic and diluted (AUD cents)

-1.0855.33

Dividends per share (AUD cents)

00

Liquidity & Coverage Ratios

MetricFY2021FY2022

Cash and equivalents (AUD Mn)

2.952.70

Receivables (AUD Mn)

0.010.04

Term deposits / investments (AUD Mn)

0.080.08

Total current assets (AUD Mn)

3.042.82

Net PP&E (freehold land) (AUD Mn)

0.750.75

Total debt (AUD Mn)

00

Net debt (AUD Mn, negative = net cash)

-2.95-2.70

Shareholders' equity, derived from book value per share (AUD Mn)

3.573.38

Current liabilities, derived from current ratio (AUD Mn)

0.250.73

Working capital, derived (AUD Mn)

2.792.09

Goodwill and intangibles (AUD Mn)

00

Cash Flow

MetricFY2021FY2022

Net change in cash (AUD Mn)

—-0.25

Dividends paid (AUD Mn)

00

Buybacks (AUD Mn)

00

Returns & Leverage Ratios (%) and Valuation Multiples (x)

RatioFY2021FY2022

ROE (%)

-10.12-6.73

ROA (%)

-9.46-5.52

Current ratio (x)

12.313.85

Quick ratio (x)

12.313.85

Debt to equity (x)

00

Asset turnover (x)

00

Price to book (x)

1.651.76

P/E (x)

-16.32-26.05

Geographic Revenue

RegionFY2020FY2021FY2022

Australia trading revenue (AUD Mn)

—00

International trading revenue (AUD Mn)

000

Share Price

MetricFY2014FY2015FY2016FY2017FY2018FY2019FY2020FY2021FY2022FY2023

Share price at end of June (AUD)

0.250.180.180.120.1250.130.300.250.310.31

Share Price & Returns

Period (to last quote, AUD 0.31)Return %

1-year (vs mid-2022)

0

3-year (vs mid-2020)

3

5-year (vs mid-2018)

148

Valuation Multiples

MultipleFY2021FY2022

P/E (x)

-16.32-26.05

P/B (x)

1.651.76

EV (AUD Mn)

2.883.13

Market cap (AUD Mn)

5.835.83

Capital Markets

ItemPosition

Analyst consensus

None. Not covered by any broker (Market Index)

Dividend history

One historical dividend: 2.5c fully franked (1992). No dividends in any year since (Market Index; FY2011 AR)

Buybacks

1992 capital reduction of about AUD 1M. No current buy-back (2012 shareholder information)

Credit ratings (Moody's / S&P / Fitch)

Not rated

Debt maturity profile

No borrowings

Analyst Conclusions

Management guidance and consensus

None issued. No consensus exists.

Bull case

  1. Basin catalyst. If Santos takes FID on Narrabri, reported as expected in 2026, and the Hunter Gas Pipeline proceeds, adjacent Gunnedah acreage including PEL 1 and 12 gains a credible commercialisation pathway. A 35% interest in a 5,459 PJ (3C, gross) resource could then command value far above the last-quoted AUD 3M EV.

  2. Precedent valuation. Santos paid AUD 15M for 40% in 2011. Even a heavy discount to that implied AUD 37.5M project valuation would exceed the company's last market value several times over.

  3. Optionality at low cost. With no debt, about AUD 2.7M of cash and roughly AUD 0.25M of annual overhead, the company can hold the option through the licence term to April 2028 without raising capital, provided JV cash calls remain modest.

Bear case

  1. Regulatory and native-title deadlock. The March 2025 Federal Court decision and persistent Gomeroi opposition may keep Gunnedah Basin development stalled well beyond 2028. That raises renewal risk again under NSW's "use it or lose it" regime.

  2. Dilution on reactivation. Any serious Santos work programme requires ACM to fund 35%. The company's cash would cover only a small programme; the AUD 13M commitment of 2011 is an example of scale. Non-consent or dilution could erode the interest.

  3. Minority-holder value trap. Delisted, about 81% family-controlled, no independent directors, and no market to exit. Minority holders have little ability to realise value or influence decisions; any transaction is likely to occur on the controlling holder's or Santos' terms.

Catalysts and monitorables (next 12 months)

MonitorableWhy it matters
Santos FID on Narrabri and outcome of native-title appealsGating item for basin development
Santos field activity in PEL 1 (Kahlua) and PEL 12 consultation reportsDirect asset progress and potential cash calls
NSW Government gas-supply policy and any further PEL actionsTenure and regulatory risk
Any approach by Santos to acquire ACM's 35%Most plausible value-realisation route
Company communications to shareholders (Corporations Act obligations continue post-delisting)Only remaining disclosure channel
Approach of the April 2028 licence expiryRenewal requires demonstrated work commitments

Concluding analyst verdict

Carbon Minerals Limited is best understood not as an operating company but as a family-held wrapper around one minority interest: 35% of PELs 1 and 12 in the Gunnedah Basin, operated by Santos.

Its corporate story is unusually long and, in places, impressive. The founder's persistence produced the Vickery coal sale in 1987, an early entry into Australian CSG in 1992, the biogenic fairway discovery in 2004, and a AUD 15M monetisation in 2011. That 2011 cash payment, however, was the high-water mark. The decade since has been defined by NSW's restrictive CSG policy, the licences sitting in renewal limbo, steady overhead consumption, and finally the abandonment of the listing. Shares were suspended in February 2022 and removed in February 2024.

The renewal of both licences to April 2028 preserved the option, and Santos has shown some renewed activity at Kahlua. The real determinant of value, though, is external: whether Santos can unlock Narrabri through native title, pipeline approvals and FID, and then choose to extend development into PEL 1 and 12. Even in that favourable scenario, Carbon Minerals faces a funding problem. Its roughly AUD 2.7M treasury cannot carry a 35% share of a meaningful appraisal programme. The most rational endgame is therefore a sale of ACM's interest to Santos or another party, at a price set largely by the controlling Lincoln Smith family and the operator.

For outside investors the instrument is effectively uninvestable: unlisted, illiquid, minority-unprotected and with sparse disclosure. For industry analysts it remains a useful bellwether for the Gunnedah Basin beyond Narrabri. The overall assessment is a dormant, debt-free, single-asset option with high regulatory and dilution risk. Value can be realised only through a transaction, not through trading.

Unlock Company Financials

Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.

View Subscription Plans

Executive Leadership

Executive Leadership Team

NameRoleTenure / appointmentBackgroundShareholding (latest notice)Source

Dr Marcus Paul Lincoln Smith

Executive Chair and CEO (recorded 3 Nov 2020)

Director since 6 Dec 1996; executive from 1 Jan 2010

BA, BSc (Hons), MSc, PhD (University of Sydney). Environmental scientist with about 30 years in environmental consulting (as at 2012). Age 57 in 2012

1,500 direct; 15,143,247 indirect (31 Dec 2022)

FY2011 AR; BusinessNews; Market Index

Raphael Lincoln Smith

Executive Director (recorded 3 Nov 2020)

From c. Nov 2020

A director profile on aggregators describes a former solicitor of the NSW Supreme Court (from 1994), Fellow of the College of Law (from July 2015) and director of land-development entities. Attribution to this director is probable but unconfirmed

100 direct; 6,000 indirect (31 Dec 2022)

BusinessNews; Market Index; Motley Fool profile

Wayne Vincent Annis-Brown

Non-executive director

Director since 4 Aug 1988; non-executive from 1 Jan 2010

LLB, LLM (University of Sydney). Practising solicitor (38 years as at 2012). Age 61 in 2012

1,000 direct; 40,000 indirect (31 Dec 2022)

FY2011 AR; Market Index

Kenneth Fung

Non-executive director and CFO

Appointed Apr 2022

—

0 (6 Apr 2022)

BusinessNews; Market Index

Bun Kiem Lee

Alternate director (for Danielson, then for Fung from 12 Apr 2022)

Alternate since 5 Apr 2006; resigned 11 Jul 2023

FCA, BCom; chartered accountant; principal of Mitchell & Partners

10,000 (2011)

FY2011 AR; InvestSMART

Rachel Lee Thorn

Joint company secretary

Since 26 Sep 1994

Office management and secretarial

—

FY2011 AR; BusinessNews

Steven John Danielson

Former NED, CFO and joint company secretary

NED from 23 Jun 1993; secretary from 20 Sep 1988; departed around the Apr 2022 board changes (inferred from announcement title)

FCA, BBS; chartered accountant

100 (2011)

FY2011 AR; InvestSMART

Paul Aurius Lincoln Smith

Founder and former Executive Chairman, CEO and CFO

Chairman from 25 Jan 1980

LLB (Sydney); solicitor and natural-resources entrepreneur. Age 84 in 2012

Family interests about 80%

FY2011 AR. The 2020 succession context is not publicly disclosed in sources reviewed

“—” = not publicly disclosed.

Directors' Remuneration

DirectorCash fee FY2010 (AUD)Cash fee FY2011 (AUD)

P.A. Lincoln Smith (Chairman)

8,0008,000

M.P. Lincoln Smith

4,0004,000

W.V. Annis-Brown

4,0004,000

S.J. Danielson

00

B.K. Lee

00

Total

16,00016,000

Major Shareholders

HolderShares%

Lincoln Smith interests (aggregate)

15,195,99780.81

John Barry interests (aggregate)

1,501,8157.99

Major Shareholders by Rank

RankHolderShares%
1

Magnum Resources Pty Limited

10,763,39257.24
2

Pada Pty Limited (i)

1,495,0007.95
3

Scylla Pty Limited (i)

1,454,3007.73
4

Probex Proprietary Limited

1,143,9666.08
5

Pali Pty Limited

722,0003.84
6

Scylla Pty Limited (ii)

655,5553.49
7

Probex Pty Limited

345,4151.84
8

Altex Holdings Pty Limited

156,0000.83
9

Bond Street Custodians Limited

140,0000.74
10

Invia Custodian Pty Limited

94,6000.50

Competitive Landscape

Key Competitors

Competitor / comparableRelationshipRelevance

Santos Limited

JV partner and operator; also the dominant Gunnedah Basin acreage holder (Narrabri, acquired via Eastern Star Gas in 2011)

Controls pace and capital allocation; its priorities are the key variable

Eastern Star Gas (acquired by Santos 2011)

Former neighbouring CSG explorer

Its near-AUD 1bn takeover valuation was cited by the company as a valuation benchmark (FY2011 AR)

Comet Ridge Limited (ASX: COI)

Junior CSG and gas explorer (Queensland)

Peer for east coast gas exposure

Blue Energy Limited (ASX: BLU)

Junior gas explorer (Bowen/Galilee)

Peer

Galilee Energy Limited (ASX: GLL)

Junior CSG explorer

Peer

Elixir Energy Limited (ASX: EXR)

Junior gas explorer (Taroom Trough)

Peer

Metgasco Limited (ASX: MEL)

Former NSW CSG explorer whose licence was bought back by NSW

NSW policy-risk precedent

Arrow Energy (Shell/PetroChina)

Major Queensland CSG producer

Competing east coast supply

Senex Energy (unlisted since 2022)

Surat CSG producer

Competing east coast supply

AGL Energy (Gloucester exit, 2016)

Former NSW CSG proponent

NSW CSG abandonment precedent

Competitor Detail

MetricCarbon Minerals

Revenue FY2022 (AUD Mn)

0

Net profit FY2022 (AUD Mn)

-0.22

R&D intensity (%)

0

Recent Developments

Disclosure constraint: * Since delisting on 14 February 2024 the company lodges nothing on the ASX, and no company-specific press coverage was found for April 2025 to October 2026.

Company Snapshot

1980

Founded

Sydney, Australia

Headquarters

SWOT Analysis

Strengths

  • Licence tenure secured: PEL 1 and 12 renewed 12 Apr 2022 for 6 years to 12 Apr 2028 (Santos PEL 12 report)
  • Tier-1 operator partner: Santos holds 65% and operates (FY2011 AR)
  • Large resource base: 3C contingent resource of 5,459 PJ announced 2010 (FY2011 AR)
  • Debt-free balance sheet: EV equals market cap minus cash in FY2021–FY2022 (Morningstar)
  • Proven value crystallisation: AUD 15M cash from Santos in 2011 for 40% equity (FY2011 AR)
  • Very low overhead: Director fees capped at AUD 20,000; FY2022 expenses AUD 0.28M (FY2011 AR; Morningstar)
  • Hard asset backing: Freehold land carried at about AUD 0.75M (Morningstar FY2022)

Weaknesses

  • No revenue: Nil trading revenue FY2021–FY2022 (Morningstar)
  • Persistent losses: NPAT -AUD 0.36M (FY2021) and -AUD 0.22M (FY2022)
  • Weak governance: No independent directors and no committees (FY2011 governance statement)
  • Shrinking treasury: Cash fell from AUD 15.08M (2011) to AUD 2.70M (2022)
  • No operational control: Santos controls the work programme as operator
  • Illiquidity: Delisted 14 Feb 2024; free float below 20%
  • Weakening liquidity ratio: Current ratio fell from 12.31x to 3.85x (FY2021 to FY2022)

Opportunities

  • Narrabri FID could re-rate basin acreage: FID reported as expected in 2026 (Feb 2026 press)
  • Renewed operator activity: Santos' approved Kahlua-area activities in PEL 1 (2023 factsheet)
  • Pipeline infrastructure: Hunter Gas Pipeline and Narrabri Lateral declared critical state infrastructure (CCC report)
  • NSW gas shortfall narrative: Santos frames Narrabri as meeting up to half of NSW demand
  • Potential takeout of minority: Santos bought out the neighbouring Eastern Star Gas in 2011
  • Further farm-down or sale: Precedent 2011 transaction

Threats

  • Native title litigation: Federal Court (Mar 2025) found the NNTT erred on climate considerations
  • Community opposition: "Zombie PELs" concern near Gunnedah; Lock the Gate campaigning
  • Operator deprioritisation: Santos CEO said no significant Narrabri capital before FID (The Land)
  • NSW "use it or lose it" licence regime: Licence conditions require work programmes (Northern Daily Leader)
  • Funding-call dilution risk: 35% share of any work programme; a AUD 13M commitment existed in 2011
  • Energy transition risk: Long-dated CSG demand uncertainty for an asset unlikely to produce before the 2030s

Unlock Company Financials

Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.

View Subscription Plans

Key Developments

DateEventSignificance
31 Mar 2021Annual report (FY2020) released InvestSMARTRoutine
6 Apr 2021Notice of AGM and letter to shareholders InvestSMARTRoutine
c. 2021Local press reports Santos negotiating with NSW to revive about 12 expired "zombie" PELs including PEL 1 and 12 Northern Daily Leader; Namoi Valley IndependentPathway to renewal of the company's only asset
31 Jan 2022Quarterly activities / Appendix 5B InvestSMARTRoutine
7 Feb 2022Share registry address notice InvestSMARTAdministrative
8 Feb 2022Letter to shareholders InvestSMART–
9 Feb 2022ASX suspension InvestSMARTStart of 2-year suspension
14 Feb 2022Suspension from Official Quotation InvestSMARTFormalised
31 Mar 2022FY2021 annual report and Appendix 4G InvestSMART; MorningstarNPAT -AUD 0.36M
6 Apr 2022Board changes and company secretary resignation; director interest notices InvestSMARTGovernance change
12 Apr 2022NSW renews PEL 1 and PEL 12 for 6 years (to 12 Apr 2028); Fung appointed NED and CFO Santos PEL 12 report; BusinessNewsAsset tenure secured
22 Apr 2022Notice of AGM InvestSMARTRoutine
28 Apr 2022Renewal of Petroleum Exploration Licences announced; quarterly InvestSMARTMaterial positive
31 May 2022AGM results; amended constitution InvestSMARTGovernance
5 Sep 2022Half-year accounts InvestSMARTRoutine
26 Oct 2022Santos annual community consultation report for PEL 12 published Santos / Narrabri Gas Project siteOperator signals broader engagement across PELs 1 and 12
30 Mar 2023FY2022 annual report InvestSMART; MorningstarNPAT -AUD 0.22M; cash AUD 2.70M
30 May 2023AGM results InvestSMARTRoutine
11 Jul 2023Alternate director B.K. Lee resigns InvestSMARTGovernance
14 Sep 2023Half-year report InvestSMARTRoutine
2023 (Nov)Santos factsheet: approved activities in the Kahlua area of PEL 1 (four existing wells) Santos Kahlua factsheetFirst field activity on the asset in years
31 Jan 2024Final quarterly report InvestSMARTRoutine
9 Feb 2024Suspension update InvestSMARTPre-delisting
12 Feb 2024ASX notice: CRM to be delisted 14 Feb 2024 Market IndexDelisting confirmed
14 Feb 2024Removal from Official List InvestSMARTEnd of listed status
Mar 2025Federal Court rules the National Native Title Tribunal erred in granting Santos Narrabri leases, by not considering climate change Narrabri CourierAdjacent-project setback for Gunnedah Basin development
5 Jan 2026Narrabri Gas Project CCC annual report: appraisal continuing ahead of FID; native title appeals ongoing NSW PlanningAdjacent-project status
7 Feb 2026Local press: Santos hopes for Narrabri FID soon, expected in 2026, pending approvals Northern Eastern TimesPotential basin catalyst

Financial Performance

Explore key financial metrics, segmented revenue, balance sheet health, and performance trends.

Revenue

1 chart
Revenue by Segment (AUD): Total segment revenue rose from AUD 0.1 Mn in FY2010 to AUD 13.2 Mn in FY2011.
Carbon Minerals Limited — Revenue by Segment (AUD)
Series (AUD Mn)FY2010FY2011
Total segment revenue0.113.2
Natural resources exploration revenue0.113.2
Total pre-tax result-0.213
Natural resources exploration result-0.213
Primary production result-0-0

Unlock Company Financials

Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.

View Subscription Plans

Unlock Company Contacts

Connect with Key Decision-Makers

Access verified employee contacts and decision-maker information from this company to support your sales, lead generation, and business development efforts.