China Energine International (Holdings) Limited Overview
China Energine International was the Hong Kong-listed renewable-energy platform of CALT, the rocket-manufacturing academy within China's state aerospace conglomerate CASC. Its original business was telecommunications (CASIL Telecom). It was reinvented in 2008 as a vertically integrated wind company: it manufactured wind turbines through Beijing Energine and Gansu Energine and held stakes in wind farms. Wind-subsidy reform, quality problems and receivable write-offs then destroyed the turbine business. Losses reached HK$1.33 billion in FY2018 and HK$0.99 billion in FY2019, and Beijing Energine entered bankruptcy liquidation in December 2020. What remained was a micro-cap shell that consolidated a single 24.65 MW wind farm in Benxi, Liaoning, held minority interests in two Longyuan-operated wind farms (200 MW Tongyu and 150 MW Rudong), and ran a small new-energy consultancy. The company carried roughly HK$1.2 billion of on-demand debt owed to CALT and had a balance-sheet deficit of about HK$0.9 billion. In 2024–25 CALT declined to extend its forbearance, the audit stalled, and the company was delisted on 4 November 2025.
Company's own description (latest annual report, FY2022)
In its FY2022 results announcement (31 March 2023), the company described itself as operating two segments:
Operation of Wind Farm: sales of electricity from the operation of wind power fields.
Development of New Energy: provision of technical services for new energy development operations. In FY2022 this segment also sold "new energy systems."
Management said the group had maintained relatively stable wind farm operations while pursuing opportunities in new-energy project development and system integration of energy-storage equipment. It also said it was exploring an integrated "Wind, Photovoltaic, Hydrogen, and Energy Storage" model. The corporate culture statement in the interim reports gives the mission as "Devoted to new energy • Contributing to Society • Benefiting mankind" (Interim Report 2022).
Independent characterization
By its final reporting periods, China Energine was a distressed holding company with a small renewable-generation asset base. Its economics had three features:
-
Very small operating core. Consolidated revenue was HK$41.2 million in FY2022, of which HK$25.8 million came from one 24.65 MW wind farm built in 2006 (29 × 850 kW turbines). Its main customer is the State Grid Corporation of China. Management itself conceded that this project's small turbine models limit its economies of scale (FY2022 results).
-
Equity-accounted associates provided a large share of earnings and cash. The group held long-term minority interests, held since 2005, in Jilin Longyuan (200 MW Tongyu wind farm) and Jiangsu Longyuan (150 MW Rudong wind farm). These were carried at HK$191.5 million at end-FY2022 and contributed a share of results of HK$5.2 million in FY2022. Their dividends (HK$4.5 million received in H1 2022 and HK$3.4 million in H1 2023) were an important cash source.
-
Liabilities dwarf the assets. The legacy of the failed turbine-manufacturing business left the company owing CALT HK$1,317.1 million at end-FY2022 and HK$1,191.9 million at 30 June 2023. This amount arose from counter-guarantees and guarantees of loans to the bankrupt former subsidiary Beijing Energine, and it was repayable on demand. Against this, the group had HK$45.0 million of cash at end-FY2022. Group net liabilities were HK$1,029.5 million at end-FY2022 and HK$912.4 million at 30 June 2023.
Business model and revenue model mix
| Revenue line (HKD K) | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales of electricity from wind farm operation | 26,151 | 0 | 25,771 |
| Technical service income (new energy development) | 0 | 9,100 | 0 |
| Sales of new energy systems (new energy development) | 0 | 0 | 15,447 |
| Total revenue | 26,151 | 9,100 | 41,218 |
Sources: Resumption announcement 7 October 2022 (FY2020–FY2021); FY2022 results announcement.
Product vs. service vs. subscription vs. licensing: In FY2022, about 62.5% of revenue was a regulated commodity product (electricity sales at a government-regulated tariff), about 37.5% was a one-off equipment/system sale, and there was no recurring service income that year. In FY2021, 100% of revenue was project-milestone consulting income. There was no subscription or licensing revenue in any year.
Revenue recognition: All revenue is recognised at a point in time. Electricity revenue is recognised on transmission to the grid. Technical service income is recognised only when the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) issues the notice of approval for the power-plant construction project. This milestone dependence explains why the segment showed nil revenue in H1 2022 and H1 2023 despite completed phased work (Interim Reports 2022 and 2023).
Value chain position
Pre-2020: The company was integrated across the wind value chain: turbine design and manufacturing (Beijing Energine, Gansu Energine), turbine maintenance services, energy-storage products (ceased 2019), and wind farm ownership and operation. It also held a non-core automotive-electronics joint venture (Beijing Delphi Wan Yuan Engine Management Systems).
Post-2020: The company became a downstream generator (independent power producer) at very small scale, plus an upstream development consultant. Its consultancy work covered site selection, resource measurement, permitting and grid-connection approvals for third-party wind and solar projects.
Customer types and end-markets
Electricity: State Grid Corporation of China ("Customer A," HK$25.8 million in FY2022, 100% of wind farm revenue).
Technical services and systems: Private and state-linked renewable developers. These were "Customer B" (HK$9.1 million in FY2021) and "Customer C" (HK$15.4 million in FY2022, new energy systems). In FY2022 the two disclosed customers together accounted for 100% of group revenue, which is extreme concentration.
End-markets: PRC onshore wind power generation, PRC wind and solar project development, and (aspirationally) energy storage and hydrogen integration.
Strategy
Stated strategy (FY2022 annual results; Interim Report 2023)
The company's stated themes, paraphrased from management's discussion, were:
-
Maintain sound wind farm operations and improve the operating quality of existing wind farms.
-
Develop new-energy projects, implementing the approval and filing conditions under the framework agreements with local governments in Sichuan and Guangdong.
-
Moderately expand operating scale, including the planned additional 15% of Longyuan Benxi and a two-stage expansion from June 2024 to December 2025, both stated in October 2022.
-
Integrate wind, PV, hydrogen and storage, while promoting and demonstrating energy-storage R&D.
-
Align with national policy, citing China's 2030 carbon-peaking and 2060 carbon-neutrality goals, the 14th Five-Year Plans for the modern energy system and renewables, the NEA's 2023 guidance of about 160 GW of new wind and PV capacity, and the NEA's June 2023 measures on wind farm renovation, upgrading and decommissioning.
Initiatives in the 24 months before delisting (Nov 2023–Nov 2025)
| Initiative | Date | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Application to CALT for debt grace period extension | 19 Mar 2024 | Rejected. CALT's finance department cited business improvement and new business expansion falling short of expectations. |
| Contingency funding measures for the HK office: pressing subsidiaries and associates for dividends, exploring HK project financing, exploring realisation of a wind farm investment (due diligence, valuation and financial adviser engaged) | Disclosed 29 Apr 2024 | Insufficient. No transaction announced. |
| Resumption plan: publish outstanding results, then apply to resume | 2024–2025 | Failed. Listing cancelled 4 Nov 2025. |
| Leadership renewal with CALT-seconded executives | Jan and Jun 2025 | Completed |
| Negotiation with CALT on debt resolution | From Mar 2025 | Outcome not publicly disclosed |
Medium-term targets and guidance
| Metric | FY2022 forecast (Oct 2022) | FY2022 actual | FY2023 forecast (Oct 2022) | FY2023 actual |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wind farm revenue (HK$'000) | 25,299 | 25,771 | 25,645 | Not published |
| New Energy revenue (HK$'000) | 0 | 15,447 | 16,754 | Not published (H1 nil) |
| Profit for year (HK$'000) | 595,153 | 608,019 | Not given | Not published |
The FY2022 profit forecast was reviewed by RSM Hong Kong (accounting policies and calculations) and by TC Capital International (financial adviser). Separately, the CALT Debt-to-Equity Swap was conditioned on "specified revenue, net profit and share price targets," but those targets were never publicly quantified.
Products & Services
Operation of Wind Farm segment
(a) Aerospace Longyuan (Benxi) Wind Farm — consolidated
Description: Onshore wind farm in Benxi, Liaoning Province, operated since 2006.
Specifications: 24,650 kW installed capacity; 29 × 850 kW wind turbines.
Customer: State Grid Corporation of China (regulated on-grid tariff plus state renewable subsidies).
Economics: FY2022 revenue of HK$25.8 million. Management's October 2022 forecast was HK$25.3 million for FY2022 and HK$25.6 million for FY2023. H1 2023 revenue was HK$12.4 million.
Plans disclosed: In October 2022 the company said it intended to acquire a further 15% equity interest in Longyuan Benxi in March 2024 and to carry out a two-stage capacity expansion between June 2024 and December 2025. No completion was disclosed. In June 2023 the NEA issued measures on wind farm renovation, upgrading and decommissioning, which management cited as supportive of repowering (Interim Report 2023).
Pricing model: Regulated per-kWh tariff set by the PRC government.
(b) Jilin Longyuan Tongyu Wind Farm — associate
- 200,000 kW; 236 × 850 kW turbines; Tongyu, Jilin Province. Equity-accounted.
(c) Jiangsu Longyuan Rudong Wind Farm — associate
- 150,000 kW; 100 × 1.5 MW turbines; Rudong, Jiangsu Province. Equity-accounted.
Combined carrying value of interests in associates: HK$212.1 million (FY2021), HK$191.5 million (FY2022) and HK$189.9 million (30 June 2023).
(d) Inner Mongolia Datang Wanyuan Xinghe Wind Farm — historical
- 49,500 kW; 55 × 900 kW direct-drive turbines (FY2019 unaudited results). It is not listed among the group's wind interests in the FY2022 results, and its current status is not publicly disclosed.
Development of New Energy segment
| Project | Location | Scale | Contract value | Status (last disclosed) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jiange Wind Power Generation Project | Jiange County, Sichuan | 500 MW in 5 phases of 100 MW | RMB50 million total (RMB10 million per phase) | Phase 1 supplemental agreement proposed Oct 2022; archival review targeted before 31 Dec 2023; wind resource measurement application commenced in 2022 |
| Heping Photovoltaic Power Generation Project | Heping County, Heyuan, Guangdong | 800 MW, in phases of 120 MW | RMB6.0 million for phase 1 (120 MW) | County-level filing certificate obtained Apr 2022, grid access approval from county government; completion targeted Jun 2023 (phase 1) and 2024 (phase 2) |
(a) New-energy project development technical services (launched June 2021)
Scope: Advisory on site selection and land use; grid-connection planning; collection of wind, solar and meteorological data; liaison with government and investors; preparation of filings for pre-approval, submission and construction stages; post-approval support for construction permits, grid-connection agreements, on-grid price approvals and grid safety assessments; contractor monitoring; completion verification (Resumption announcement, 7 Oct 2022).
Pricing model: Case-by-case fees, charged by stage and/or on government approval. Revenue is recognised only on NDRC approval.
Flagship engagements: - Realization: Management forecast HK$16.8 million of FY2023 segment revenue from these two contracts. Neither H1 2023 nor any later disclosure confirmed recognition, and H1 2023 segment revenue was nil.
(b) Sales of new energy systems (FY2022)
- HK$15.4 million recognised in FY2022 from "Customer C." The system type is not specified in sources reviewed. Management's narrative refers to system integration of energy-storage equipment, but this attribution is not confirmed.
(c) Energy storage and "Wind-PV-Hydrogen-Storage" integration (research/aspirational)
- The Interim Report 2023 states that the group will keep promoting and demonstrating R&D on energy-storage systems and exploring wind-PV-hydrogen-storage integration. No commercial product, specification or launch was disclosed.
Discontinued and historical product lines (for completeness)
| Product line | Entity | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Wind turbines (made-to-order; 850 kW and 1.5 MW classes supplied to own/associate farms) | Beijing Energine, Gansu Energine | Terminated; Beijing Energine in bankruptcy liquidation since Dec 2020 |
| Wind turbine maintenance services | Same | Continued into 2020; ended with liquidation |
| Energy storage and related products | Group subsidiary | Ceased 2019 (discontinued operation) |
| Automotive engine management systems (electronic fuel injection) | Beijing Delphi Wan Yuan JV | Status not publicly disclosed after 2020 |
| Telecommunications equipment | CASIL Telecom era | Exited |
Financial Narrative
Income statement: notes and sources
Note: Diluted EPS equals basic EPS because there were no potential ordinary shares (FY2019 and FY2022 filings). The FY2022 announcement shows diluted EPS as "N/A."
Composition of FY2021–FY2022 non-operating items
The FY2022 profit of HK$608.0 million is almost entirely non-cash and non-recurring. The HK$434.5 million gain came from transferring fully impaired receivables (RMB399.9 million) to Beijing Energine in exchange for discharging RMB376.1 million of trade payables. The HK$185.5 million gain came from deconsolidating two subsidiaries wound up on 17 August 2022. Together these account for about HK$620.0 million, more than the reported profit.
Analyst-derived profitability metrics
Calculation notes: FY2022 EBITDA = PBT 608,600 + finance costs 49 + depreciation of PPE 16,489 + depreciation of ROU 2,641. Underlying EBITDA removes the gain on debt restructuring and net other gains and losses (FY2022) and removes other gains and adds back the guarantee charge (FY2021). Operating income is not presented as a separate line by the company. Third-party data (etnet) reports a FY2022 EBITDA margin of 1,510.2% and a net margin of 1,112.1%; the net margin there appears to be based on profit attributable to owners. The differences arise from methodology. The FY2020 growth figure compares restated continuing revenue (wind farm only) with FY2019 revenue that included turbine sales, so it is not like-for-like.
Revenue CAGR FY2018–FY2022: -8.6% per year (HK$59.1 million to HK$41.2 million). This calculation is distorted by the exit from turbines and the deconsolidation and reconsolidation of Benxi.
Balance sheet
Notes:
- FY2020 cash is the opening cash and cash equivalents for 2021 (Interim Report 2021/2022 cash flow statement). FY2020 equity attributable comes from the statement of changes in equity at 1 January 2021.
Treatment of the CALT balance: The company's notes describe it as unsecured, non-interest-bearing and repayable on demand (Interim Reports 2022/2023). However, the FY2022 MD&A says these borrowings were determined at market interest rates. This is an internal inconsistency in the filings. CALT's March 2025 demand letter also referred to a right to exercise "pledged assets," while the FY2022 accounts state that no material assets were pledged. These discrepancies are flagged and unresolved.
- Third-party data (etnet) shows FY2022 "net cash" of HK$44.7 million because it excludes the CALT balance from debt.
Interim balance sheet (HK$'000)
The CALT balance was later disclosed at about HK$1,212.6 million at 31 December 2023 (announcement, 29 April 2024). This is unaudited and was cited as part of the explanation for the results delay.
Cash flow
FY2022 additions to non-current assets totalled HK$1.75 million (segment note). Annual operating cash flow for FY2018–FY2022 is not publicly disclosed in the sources reviewed. No dividends were paid and no shares were repurchased in any year from FY2018 to H1 2023.
Ratios
ROE / ROIC: Not meaningful, because equity is negative from FY2019 onward and invested capital is negative.
ROA: Not meaningful in FY2022 (profit was one-off driven). Etnet reports 123.5%.
Debt/equity and net debt/EBITDA: Not meaningful, because equity is negative and underlying EBITDA (HK$8.1 million) implies net debt of about 157× underlying EBITDA in FY2022.
Cash conversion cycle: Not computable. Trade receivables were HK$26.0 million at FY2022, of which HK$6.4 million was more than one year old. Trade payables were HK$50.6 million, of which HK$43.0 million was more than one year old.
Commentary on trends, inflections and drivers
FY2018–FY2019: collapse of the turbine franchise. Revenue fell 35% to HK$38.3 million in FY2019. Turbine product sales dropped to HK$12.3 million from HK$33.7 million, while wind farm sales were stable at about HK$26 million. Losses were dominated by receivable impairments of HK$698.9 million (FY2018) and HK$531.9 million (FY2019). Management attributed these to curtailment-driven regional restrictions (NEA Document No. 52 of 2017), competitive tariff-setting for new onshore projects (NDRC Fa Gai Jia Ge [2019] No. 882), the end of the subsidy mechanism for non-grid-connected wind farms from end-2020, and unresolved technical and quality deficiencies in certain turbine products. Working capital swung from a surplus of HK$621 million to a deficit of HK$693 million, and short-term borrowings rose to HK$660 million.
FY2020: insolvency of the operating subsidiary. Beijing Energine entered liquidation on 25 December 2020. Losses from continuing operations were HK$348.4 million, and the balance sheet shrank to HK$254.6 million of assets against HK$1,976.6 million of liabilities. Most of these liabilities were CALT guarantee claims (HK$1,005.0 million) and trade payables.
FY2021: accounting rebuild. Revenue fell to HK$9.1 million, consisting entirely of consulting income, because Benxi was not consolidated for virtually the whole year. A HK$399.0 million financial-guarantee charge was largely offset by a HK$295.3 million deconsolidation gain and other gains, leaving a net loss of HK$74.1 million.
FY2022: paper profit, persistent insolvency. With Benxi reconsolidated and a system sale booked, revenue rose to HK$41.2 million. A HK$434.5 million debt-restructuring gain and a HK$185.5 million deconsolidation gain produced a headline profit of HK$608.0 million. Net liabilities improved by HK$734 million to HK$1,029.5 million, but underlying EBITDA was only about HK$8 million. The auditor disclaimed its opinion on going-concern grounds.
H1 2023: last disclosed period. Revenue was HK$12.4 million (down 6.8%). Profit of HK$85.0 million came almost entirely from an HK$84.2 million guarantee reversal, after a former subsidiary repaid RMB77.65 million to CALT. Operating cash flow was negative at HK$3.7 million, and cash was HK$41.4 million against HK$1.19 billion of on-demand CALT debt.
Post-H1 2023: terminal phase. The CALT forbearance expired on 20 November 2024 and was not renewed. CALT formally demanded repayment in March 2025. The FY2023 audit never closed. The company also disclosed that its Hong Kong head office could not even meet its audit fee, because PRC cross-border borrowing rules prevented its mainland subsidiaries from funding it.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansFinancial Detail
Segment Overview
| Segment | Contents | Products/services |
|---|---|---|
Operation of Wind Farm | Longyuan Benxi wind farm (consolidated) plus share of results of associates Jilin Longyuan and Jiangsu Longyuan (all associates are allocated to this segment) | Grid electricity sales to State Grid |
Development of New Energy | Technical services subsidiary (referred to as "Beijing New Technology" in the October 2022 resumption announcement) | Development consultancy for wind and PV projects (site selection, resource measurement, permitting, grid-connection approvals); sales of new energy systems (FY2022) |
Revenue by Segment
| Segment | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
Operation of Wind Farm revenue (HKD K) | 26,151 | 0 | 25,771 |
Development of New Energy revenue (HKD K) | 0 | 9,100 | 15,447 |
Total revenue (HKD K) | 26,151 | 9,100 | 41,218 |
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansResults by Segment
| Segment | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Operation of Wind Farm segment result (HKD K) | 19,221 | 998 |
Development of New Energy segment result (HKD K) | 8,020 | 200 |
Total segment result (HKD K) | 27,241 | 1,198 |
Revenue by Segment (%) and Segment Margins & Growth (%)
| Metric | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
Wind Farm share of revenue (%) | 100.0 | 0.0 | 62.5 |
New Energy share of revenue (%) | 0.0 | 100.0 | 37.5 |
New Energy segment margin (segment result / revenue, %) | — | 88.1 | 1.3 |
Wind Farm segment margin (segment result / revenue, %) | — | — | 3.9 |
Segment Assets & Liabilities
| Metric | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Wind Farm segment assets (HKD K) | 364,432 | 328,184 |
New Energy segment assets (HKD K) | 14,036 | 17,773 |
Wind Farm segment liabilities (HKD K) | 4,163 | 4,344 |
New Energy segment liabilities (HKD K) | 842 | 8,283 |
Results by Segment (Half-Yearly)
| Metric | H1 2022 | H1 2023 |
|---|---|---|
Wind Farm revenue (HKD K) | 13,303 | 12,404 |
New Energy revenue (HKD K) | 0 | 0 |
Wind Farm segment result (HKD K) | 6,756 | 5,996 |
New Energy segment result (HKD K) | -910 | -1,496 |
Group Entities
| Entity | Relationship | Status (latest disclosed) |
|---|---|---|
China Energine International (Holdings) Ltd | Listed holding company (Cayman) | Delisted 4 Nov 2025 |
Aerospace Longyuan (Benxi) Wind Power Co., Ltd | Subsidiary (controlling interest; exact % not disclosed in sources reviewed) | Consolidated since 28 Dec 2021 |
Jilin Longyuan (Tongyu wind farm) | Associate (% not disclosed in sources reviewed) | Equity-accounted |
Jiangsu Longyuan (Rudong wind farm) | Associate (% not disclosed in sources reviewed) | Equity-accounted |
New-energy technical services subsidiary ("Beijing New Technology") | Subsidiary | Active through 2023 |
Beijing Energine Industry Co., Ltd | Former wholly owned subsidiary (turbines) | In bankruptcy liquidation since Dec 2020 |
Gansu Energine | Former subsidiary (turbines) | Status not publicly disclosed in sources reviewed |
New Image Development Limited | Former subsidiary | Wound up; claim against company withdrawn July 2023 |
Inner Mongolia Datang Wanyuan Xinghe wind farm (49.5 MW) | Investee listed in FY2019 | Not mentioned in FY2022 disclosures; status not publicly disclosed |
Beijing Delphi Wan Yuan Engine Management Systems Co., Ltd | Joint venture (automotive EMS); shares pledged to a CALT subsidiary in 2019–2020 | Not mentioned in FY2022 disclosures; status not publicly disclosed |
Income Statement and Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Revenue continuing ops (HKD K) | 59,116 | 38,307 | 26,151 | 9,100 | 41,218 |
Cost of revenue (HKD K) | -53,157 | -53,642 | — | -1,080 | -32,273 |
Gross profit (HKD K) | 5,959 | -15,335 | 4,445 | 8,020 | 8,945 |
Share of results of associates (HKD K) | -129,834 | -5,076 | — | 10,268 | 5,216 |
Share of results of joint ventures (HKD K) | 76,177 | 31,359 | — | 0 | 0 |
Finance costs (HKD K) | -82,546 | -80,860 | — | -116 | -49 |
Profit before tax continuing ops (HKD K) | -1,233,464 | -926,070 | — | -71,027 | 608,600 |
Income tax (HKD K) | -580 | -3,770 | — | -3,113 | -581 |
Profit for year continuing ops (HKD K) | -1,234,044 | -929,840 | -348,421 | -74,140 | 608,019 |
Loss from discontinued ops (HKD K) | -96,102 | -59,841 | — | 0 | 0 |
Profit for year total (HKD K) | -1,330,146 | -989,681 | — | -74,140 | 608,019 |
Profit attributable to owners (HKD K) | -1,320,525 | -979,508 | — | -76,499 | 458,373 |
EPS basic (HK cents) | -30.22 | -22.42 | — | -1.75 | 10.49 |
EPS diluted (HK cents) | -30.22 | -22.42 | — | -1.75 | 10.49 |
Dividend per share (HK cents) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Balance Sheet
| Item | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Gain on debt restructuring (HKD K) | 0 | 434,463 |
Gain on deconsolidation of subsidiaries (HKD K) | 295,308 | 185,547 |
Gain on bargain purchase (HKD K) | 20,494 | 0 |
Gain on deemed disposal of associate (HKD K) | 8,953 | 0 |
Financial guarantee contract liabilities (HKD K) | -399,032 | 0 |
Administrative expenses (HKD K) | -11,402 | -25,025 |
Other income (HKD K) | 620 | 2,132 |
Margin Analysis (%) and Income Statement
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gross margin (%) | 10.1 | -40.0 | 17.0 | 88.1 | 21.7 |
Net margin continuing ops (%) | -2,087.5 | -2,427.3 | -1,332.3 | -814.7 | 1,475.1 |
Pre-tax margin (%) | -2,086.5 | -2,417.5 | — | -780.5 | 1,476.5 |
Revenue YoY growth (%) | — | -35.2 | -31.7 | -65.2 | 352.9 |
Reported EBITDA analyst calc (HKD K) | — | — | — | -70,615 | 627,779 |
Underlying EBITDA ex one-offs analyst calc (HKD K) | — | — | — | 7,802 | 8,123 |
Balance Sheet (FY2018–FY2022)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Total assets (HKD K) | 4,274,430 | 3,183,686 | 254,607 | 393,069 | 349,151 |
Non-current assets (HKD K) | 1,769,397 | 1,547,930 | 225,017 | 305,427 | 260,076 |
Current assets (HKD K) | 2,505,033 | 1,635,756 | 29,590 | 87,642 | 89,075 |
Cash and bank incl pledged (HKD K) | 88,838 | 78,236 | 19,956 | 31,257 | 44,998 |
Total liabilities (HKD K) | 3,571,273 | 3,469,825 | 1,976,615 | 2,156,962 | 1,378,645 |
Current liabilities (HKD K) | 1,883,635 | 2,329,090 | 1,974,463 | 2,148,809 | 1,371,519 |
Bank borrowings short-term (HKD K) | 125,542 | 659,983 | — | 0 | 0 |
Bank borrowings long-term (HKD K) | 1,641,178 | 1,094,019 | — | 0 | 0 |
Amount due to CALT on demand (HKD K) | — | — | 1,005,043 | 1,439,008 | 1,317,108 |
Total debt incl CALT (HKD K) | 1,766,720 | 1,754,002 | 1,005,043 | 1,439,008 | 1,317,108 |
Net debt incl CALT (HKD K) | 1,677,882 | 1,675,766 | 985,087 | 1,407,751 | 1,272,110 |
Total equity deficiency (HKD K) | 703,157 | -286,139 | -1,722,008 | -1,763,893 | -1,029,494 |
Equity attributable to owners (HKD K) | 650,053 | -327,330 | -1,551,312 | -1,677,230 | -1,093,451 |
Goodwill and intangibles (HKD K) | 65,169 | 2,004 | — | 0 | 0 |
Working capital (HKD K) | 621,398 | -693,334 | -1,944,873 | -2,061,167 | -1,282,444 |
Interests in associates (HKD K) | 206,108 | 194,587 | — | 212,094 | 191,504 |
Trade payables (HKD K) | 944,674 | 1,129,823 | — | 507,338 | 50,577 |
Balance Sheet (31 Dec 2021–30 Jun 2023)
| Metric | 31 Dec 2021 | 30 Jun 2022 | 31 Dec 2022 | 30 Jun 2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Total assets (HKD K) | 393,069 | 372,604 | 349,151 | 331,898 |
Cash (HKD K) | 31,257 | 42,399 | 44,998 | 41,377 |
Amount due to CALT (HKD K) | 1,439,008 | 1,375,756 | 1,317,108 | 1,191,872 |
Trade and other payables (HKD K) | 706,076 | 673,391 | 54,025 | 44,047 |
Net liabilities (HKD K) | -1,763,893 | -1,685,908 | -1,029,494 | -912,442 |
Cash Flow
| Metric | H1 2021 | H1 2022 | H1 2023 |
|---|---|---|---|
Operating cash flow (HKD K) | -7,066 | 10,576 | -3,656 |
Dividends received from associates (HKD K) | 0 | 4,485 | 3,448 |
Capex purchase of PPE (HKD K) | 0 | -52 | 0 |
Free cash flow OCF less capex (HKD K) | -7,066 | 10,524 | -3,656 |
Lease repayments (HKD K) | -590 | -739 | -438 |
Dividends paid (HKD K) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Share buybacks (HKD K) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Financial Ratios (x)
| Ratio | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Current ratio (x) | 1.33 | 0.70 | 0.015 | 0.041 | 0.065 |
Total liabilities to total assets (x) | 0.84 | 1.09 | 7.76 | 5.49 | 3.95 |
Asset turnover revenue over year-end assets (x) | 0.014 | 0.012 | 0.103 | 0.023 | 0.118 |
Interest coverage underlying EBITDA over finance costs (x) | — | — | — | 67.3 | 165.8 |
Revenue by Region
| Region | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
PRC mainland revenue (HKD K) | 26,151 | 9,100 | 41,218 |
Hong Kong revenue (HKD K) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Rest of world revenue (HKD K) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Segment × Province Details
| Segment × Province | Revenue FY2022 | Notes |
|---|---|---|
Wind Farm — Liaoning (Benxi) | 25,771 | Sole consolidated generating asset |
New Energy — province not disclosed | 15,447 | Customer C; province not disclosed |
Valuation Snapshot
| Multiple | Value | Comment |
|---|---|---|
P/E (FY2022 reported EPS HK$0.1049) | 0.38x | Meaningless; one-off profit. Google showed 0.32x on a different earnings basis. |
P/B | n/m | Negative equity |
EV/Sales (EV ≈ HK$174.8m + HK$1,317.1m CALT − HK$45.0m cash ≈ HK$1,446.9m; FY2022 sales HK$41.2m) | ≈35x | Debt-dominated EV |
EV/EBITDA (underlying FY2022 ≈ HK$8.1m) | ≈178x | Reflects insolvency |
Share Count (millions)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dividend per share (HK cents) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Shares repurchased (count) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Shares in issue (millions) | 4,369 | 4,369 | 4,369 | 4,369 | 4,369 |
Analyst Conclusions
Management guidance
The last formal guidance was the October 2022 resumption forecast. For FY2022 it was met (revenue and profit came in at or above forecast because of the timing of the one-offs). For FY2023, wind revenue of HK$25.6m and new-energy revenue of HK$16.8m were forecast but never reported. After delisting, the company is no longer subject to Listing Rule disclosure obligations, and no further guidance can be expected. Consensus estimates do not exist.
Bull case (residual / recovery scenario)
-
CALT has economic incentives to restructure rather than liquidate. Nearly all creditor value sits with CALT (HK$1.19bn of HK$1.24bn of liabilities at H1 2023). A debt-to-equity swap or asset transfer under CASC would be an intra-group decision, as the September 2022 LOI showed.
-
Real assets with cash flow exist. Benxi (HK$25.8m revenue in FY2022) and the associate stakes (HK$191.5m book value, regular dividends) could support a recovery of value outside the listed structure.
-
Repowering policy (NEA, June 2023) could materially increase Benxi's output if an owner can fund the replacement of 29 × 850 kW units.
Bear case (base expectation)
-
Equity is likely worthless. Net liabilities of HK$912m (H1 2023) against about HK$332m of total assets, with the controlling shareholder demanding repayment and asserting rights over pledged assets.
-
Contingent guarantee liabilities are crystallising. The RMB230m-related judgment is final after the Supreme People's Court rejected re-examination. No provision had been booked as of H1 2023.
-
Minority holders have no exit or information rights equivalent to a listed company. Delisting removed the market and the Listing Rule protections, and five sets of financial results remain unpublished.
Catalysts and monitorables (next 12 months)
-
Any CALT/CASC restructuring, debt-for-equity transfer or enforcement over group assets (Benxi or the associate stakes).
-
Outcome of the RMB65m Supreme People's Court proceeding and enforcement of the RMB230m-related judgment.
-
Any winding-up petition against the Cayman holding company or its Hong Kong subsidiaries.
-
Any disclosure on the status of the Beijing Energine liquidation and recoveries to CALT. This was condition (1) of the swap LOI.
-
Any offer to minority shareholders or any privatisation-style transaction (none announced).
-
Any belated publication of the FY2023–FY2025 accounts (none found as of October 2026).
Analyst verdict
China Energine illustrates how a state-sponsored industrial pivot can collapse into a listed shell. The 2008 transformation from CASIL Telecom into a vertically integrated wind company left it exposed on three fronts at once. China's curtailment-driven development restrictions in 2017–2018 hit its home markets. Subsidy reform in 2019–2020 removed the demand that its made-to-order turbine model depended on. And its own product quality problems made new orders hard to win. Receivable impairments of about HK$1.2bn in FY2018–FY2019, followed by the liquidation of Beijing Energine in December 2020, wiped out the equity.
The 2021–2023 restructuring was technically skilful. Winding up subsidiaries, a debt expiation and a guarantee reversal generated more than HK$700m of accounting gains and secured a resumption of trading in October 2022. It never addressed the core problem: about HK$1.2bn of on-demand debt to CALT supported by an operating business producing about HK$8m of underlying EBITDA. The September 2022 debt-to-equity swap was the only credible path to solvency. It depended on performance and share-price targets that a single 24.65 MW wind farm and a lumpy consultancy could not meet.
When CALT's finance department judged the company's progress inadequate in 2024, the going-concern basis collapsed, and the FY2023 audit, the resumption plan and the listing failed in turn. On the disclosed numbers, minority equity has negligible value. Any recovery depends entirely on how CASC/CALT chooses to deal with the residual assets, which is a related-party decision outside minority shareholders' control and no longer subject to Hong Kong listing disclosure. Analysts should treat the entity as a delisted, insolvent subsidiary of a state group. Its information environment has gone dark, and the most likely outcome is an intra-group asset transfer or liquidation rather than value restoration for public shareholders.
APPENDIX A — SOURCE REGISTER (primary filings unless noted)
1: Announcement of Unaudited Annual Results FY2019 (irasia.com/HKEX) — 31 Mar 2020 — FY2018–FY2019 financials, segments, employees, R&D, litigation
2: Inside information: Beijing Energine bankruptcy (HKEX) — 15 Dec 2020; 2 Mar 2021 — Deconsolidation
3: Resumption guidance announcement — 24 May 2021 — First suspension
4: Interim Results / Report H1 2021 — 17 & 30 Sep 2021 — H1 2021 data, employees
5: Interim Report 2022 — 27 Sep 2022 — H1 2022 financials, corporate information, CALT debt, litigation, shareholders
6: Fulfilment of Resumption Conditions and Resumption of Trading — 7 Oct 2022 — FY2020–FY2021 data, profit forecast, projects, business model
7: Supplemental announcement to 2021 Annual Report — 30 Aug 2022 — Associates held since 2005
8: Annual Results FY2022 (via moomoo newsfile mirror of HKEX filing) — 31 Mar 2023 — FY2022 financials, segments, auditor disclaimer, debt expiation, wind farm capacities
9: Interim Report 2023 — 29 Sep 2023 — H1 2023 financials, prospects, employees, litigation, swap conditions
10: Delay / supplemental announcements on FY2023 results — 28 Mar, 29 Apr, 20 May, 14 Jun 2024 — Suspension causes, CALT balance end-2023
11: Resumption Guidance and Quarterly Update — 28 Jun 2024 — Delisting deadline
12: Quarterly updates / delay notices — 30 Aug 2024 – 30 Sep 2025 — Status chronology
13: Board change announcements and lists of directors — 26 Oct 2022; 1 Feb 2023; 2 Jan 2025; 13 Jun 2025 — Governance
14: Inside information: Supreme People's Court rulings — 21 Jan 2025 — Litigation
15: Inside information: CALT repayment demand — 5 Mar 2025 — Default risk
16: Listing Committee decision announcement (EN/CN) — 24 Oct 2025 — Delisting
17: HKEX regulatory announcement: cancellation of listing — 30 Oct 2025 — Delisting confirmation
18: Inside information: restoration of quality certificates — 17 Sep 2019 — 2019 certificate suspension
19: Voluntary announcement: business progress (Chinese) — 18 May 2018 — 2017 policy impact
20: Wikipedia: China Energine (secondary) — Accessed Oct 2026 — Founding, former name, 2008 rename, 2016 market cap
21: Google Finance HKG:1185 (aggregator) — Accessed Oct 2026 — Last price, range, implied market cap
22: etnet ratio page for 1185 (aggregator) — Accessed Oct 2026 — Third-party ratio cross-check
23: China Longyuan Power quarterly results (HKEX) — 27 Oct 2022; 30 Oct 2024 — Peer benchmark data
24: FilingReader / Tiger Brokers news summaries (secondary) — Jul–Oct 2025 — Corroboration of delisting timeline
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansExecutive Leadership
Board of Directors
| Name | Role | Tenure / appointment | Background (as disclosed) | Age |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Mr. Li Lei | Chairman, Executive Director; Chair of Nomination and of Development & Investment Committees; member of Remuneration Committee | ED since at least Mar 2020; CEO until 13 Jun 2025; Chairman from 13 Jun 2025 | CALT-system executive (details not disclosed in sources reviewed) | — |
Mr. Liu Zhongbing (Liu Zhong Bing) | Executive Director, CEO; member of Nomination and of Development & Investment Committees | From 13 Jun 2025 | Master's degree holder. At CALT departments since 2000. Deputy GM of Beijing Aerospace Wanyuan Technology Co. (Jan 2014–Apr 2021). Deputy head of CALT industrial development department since Apr 2021. | 51 (2025) |
Mr. Xu Jun | Executive Director, Financial Controller; member of Development & Investment Committee | ED since at least 2019 | — | — |
Ms. Xu Jinghui | Non-executive Director | From 2 Jan 2025 | Bachelor's degree. At CALT since 1989. Deputy GM, board secretary, general counsel and chief compliance officer of Aerospace Long March Chemical Engineering Co. (Apr 2015–Oct 2023). Business manager in CALT industrial development department since Oct 2023. No director's fee. | 54 (2025) |
Mr. Lau Fai Lawrence | Independent NED; Chair of Audit Committee | Since at least Mar 2020 | — | — |
Mr. Li Dapeng | Independent NED; member of all four committees | Since at least 2019 | — | — |
Ms. Xu Hong | Independent NED; Chair of Remuneration Committee | — | — | — |
“—” = not publicly disclosed.
Board & Management Changes
| Date | Change | Context |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Board led by Chairman Liu Xiaowei (劉效偉); EDs Li Guang and Xu Jun; INEDs Kan Lai Kuen Alice, Gordon Ng and Li Dapeng | Announcement, 17 Sep 2019 (Chinese version) |
Mar 2020 | Chairman shown as "Mr. Liu Zhiwei"; EDs Li Lei, Han Qingping, Xu Jun and Wang Guanghui; INEDs Lau Fai Lawrence, Gordon Ng and Li Dapeng | FY2019 unaudited results. |
By Aug 2021 | Han Qingping is Chairman; Li Lei is CEO | Board meeting notices 2021 |
Before Oct 2022 | — | Board list 26 Oct 2022 |
1 Feb 2023 | Shen Jian appointed ED and Vice-CEO | Board list 1 Feb 2023 |
Jun 2024–Jan 2025 | Gordon Ng (INED, Remuneration Committee chair) leaves; Xu Hong joins as INED | Board lists Jun 2024 vs 2 Jan 2025 |
2 Jan 2025 | Shen Jian resigns (retirement and health); Xu Jinghui appointed NED | Announcement, 2 Jan 2025 |
13 Jun 2025 | Han Qingping resigns as Chairman and ED (retirement); Li Lei becomes Chairman; Liu Zhongbing becomes CEO | Announcement, 13 Jun 2025 |
Directors' Remuneration
| Committee | Chair | Members |
|---|---|---|
Audit | Lau Fai Lawrence | Li Dapeng, Xu Hong |
Remuneration | Xu Hong | Li Lei, Lau Fai Lawrence, Li Dapeng |
Nomination | Li Lei | Liu Zhongbing, Lau Fai Lawrence, Li Dapeng, Xu Hong |
Development and Investment | Li Lei | Liu Zhongbing, Xu Jun, Li Dapeng |
Directors' Remuneration (Half-Yearly)
| Metric | H1 2021 | H1 2022 | H1 2023 |
|---|---|---|---|
Key management salaries and benefits (HKD K) | 2,272 | 487 | 431 |
Key management retirement contributions (HKD K) | 42 | 84 | 81 |
Key management total (HKD K) | 2,314 | 571 | 512 |
Major Shareholders
| Holder | Shares | Stake (%) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
Astrotech Group Limited (beneficial owner) | 2,649,244,000 | 60.64 | Wholly owned by CALT |
CALT (deemed) | 2,649,244,000 | 60.64 | Via Astrotech |
CASC (deemed) | 2,649,244,000 | 60.64 | Owns 100% of CALT |
Public / other holders | 1,719,751,668 | 39.36 | No other substantial shareholders (≥5%) notified |
Directors and chief executives | 0 | 0.00 | No interests disclosed (Interim Reports 2022/2023) |
Competitive Landscape
Competitors by Segment
| Segment | Named competitors / peers | Relative positioning |
|---|---|---|
Wind generation (IPP) | China Longyuan Power Group (916.HK); CGN New Energy (1811.HK); China Datang Corp Renewable Power (1798.HK); Huadian Fuxin Energy; Beijing Jingneng Clean Energy (579.HK); Concord New Energy (182.HK); China Suntien Green Energy (956.HK); China Three Gorges Renewables (600905.SS); China Power International (2380.HK) | Peers operate GW-scale fleets; China Energine consolidated 24.65 MW |
New-energy development services | Design institutes under China Energy Engineering (3996.HK) and Power Construction Corp of China; provincial survey and design institutes; developer in-house teams | Small, relationship-based; dependent on local government framework deals |
Wind turbines (historical) | Goldwind (2208.HK); Envision; Mingyang Smart Energy; Windey; Sany Renewable Energy; Shanghai Electric | China Energine exited after quality issues and order collapse |
Peer Comparison FY2022
| Metric | China Energine (FY2022) | China Longyuan Power |
|---|---|---|
Revenue | HK$41.2m | RMB30.21bn (9M 2022, unaudited quarterly results) |
Wind capacity | 24.65 MW consolidated (+ minority stakes in 350 MW) | 25,711 MW wind (Q3 2022); 28,381 MW (Q3 2024) |
Revenue growth | +352.9% (base effect) | 9M 2022 revenue up vs 9M 2021 (RMB27.61bn) |
Gross margin | 21.7% | — |



