iSelect Limited Overview
iSelect is one of Australia's pioneering consumer comparison and purchase platforms. It started in private health insurance around 2000 and grew into a multi-vertical marketplace covering health, life, car, home and contents, travel and pet insurance, electricity, gas, broadband and referral-based personal finance. Its defining feature has always been a hybrid model: online comparison combined with an Australian-based call centre of "comparison experts". That model supports higher conversion and revenue per sale in complex categories like health insurance, but it carries a heavier fixed-cost base than pure-digital rivals. After a high-profile 2013 IPO, iSelect suffered repeated earnings downgrades, CEO turnover, an $8.5 million ACCC penalty and steady revenue erosion, from about $181 million in FY2018 to $93 million in FY2022. In December 2022 it was taken private by IHA, owner of its largest rival Compare the Market and of insurer Auto & General. iSelect now operates as a separately branded comparison channel inside a vertically integrated comparison-plus-underwriting group.
What the company does. iSelect runs consumer-facing comparison services. Australians can compare products from a panel of partner providers, online or by phone, and then buy or be referred. iSelect does not charge consumers. Providers pay it fees and commissions when a consumer who used the service buys a product (ACCC media release, Oct 2020; ACCC merger review, Dec 2022).
Company's own description (final listed-era characterisation, as summarised by MarketScreener from company filings): iSelect is an Australia-based online product comparison company covering insurance, utilities and personal finance. It reported three segments: Health (private health insurance); Life and General Insurance (life, car and other general insurance); and Energy and Telecommunications (electricity, gas and broadband). It also offered referral-based financial products including home loans, car loans, personal loans, business loans, credit cards and income protection.
Current self-description (iSelect website, 2025): iSelect presents itself as a pioneer of Australian comparison. Customers can compare online or speak to an Australia-based comparison expert by phone, and the range now spans "complex products across insurance, utilities and personal finance".
Revenue model. iSelect is effectively 100% service and commission revenue, with no product manufacturing or subscription income. The main revenue streams are:
The trail-commission model is a structural feature of iSelect's accounts. Revenue was recognised up front against a receivable whose value depends on policy-lapse assumptions. Revaluations of the "trail book" therefore caused repeated statutory-versus-underlying gaps (Insurance Business, 2014; FNN, Oct 2020).
Value chain position. iSelect sits between product manufacturers (health funds, insurers, energy retailers, telcos, lenders) and retail consumers. It acts as a customer-acquisition and distribution intermediary. Since December 2022 it is a sister company of an insurer (Auto & General, the issuer of Budget Direct products) and of a competing intermediary (Compare the Market). This is a vertically integrated position: iSelect's FSGs now state that iSelect, Auto & General Services and Auto & General are related entities, and that car and home comparisons on iSelect web pages are partly arranged by Auto & General Services (FSG, Sep and Oct 2025).
Customer types and end-markets.
-
Retail consumers and households in Australia (the only geography).
-
Product-provider partners, which are the paying customers: private health insurers, life insurers, general insurers, energy retailers, broadband providers and financial institutions.
Independent characterisation. iSelect is a sub-scale, call-centre-heavy, seasonally lumpy lead-generation and conversion business. It is highly exposed to regulatory changes in its biggest category, private health insurance. Health contributed about 66% of FY2022 revenue (derived: $61.83m of $93.11m). Demand peaks around the 1 April premium rise and the 30 June Lifetime Health Cover deadline, and an analyst noted the first half's contribution is "usually negligible" (Livewire). Its competitive moat (brand awareness and a human-advice capability) eroded as digital-native rivals grew and the cost of paid search rose. The 2022 takeover by IHA turned iSelect from an independent challenger into a second brand within a group already holding the leading comparison brand.
Strategy
Listed-era strategic themes (FY2019–FY2022):
"Focus on core": (FY2019 reset): exit non-core assets (InfoChoice, iMoney, Energy Watch, in-house home loans, Cape Town centre), rebuild marketing ROI and improve customer ease.
- Customer-experience platform investment, with the stated aim of enhancing ROI "through marketing strategy" (FY2019 results).
Digital mix shift: car insurance online sales rose from 23% to 40% of the mix in FY2022.
Partnership-led adjacency growth: Choosi (pet), BizCover (business) and home and contents, with partnership categories growing 57% in 2H FY2020.
New life insurance model: with improved unit economics (FY2022).
Medium-term targets: none current. The last guidance-type statement was Hebard's late-2020 view that FY2021 would show "significantly improved profitability" with a return to growth in FY2022. That growth did not materialise, as FY2022 revenue fell 16%.
Post-acquisition initiatives (public record):
"Save More" brand campaign: (May 2024, agency Howatson+Company), positioning iSelect around household savings.
Group integration: Compare the Market is contracted for parts of iSelect's general insurance comparison service, and related-party Auto & General (Budget Direct) products sit on the panel (FSGs, 2025).
Organisational renewal: new General Managers in Health, Utilities and General Insurance (2023).
- Cost programmes, targets and ESG commitments: not publicly disclosed.
Products & Services
Detailed specifications, version years and commission rates are not publicly disclosed beyond the FSG commission schedules.
Product Portfolio
| Segment | Offering | Description & capabilities | Target customer | Launch / latest | Pricing model |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Health | Private health insurance comparison | Online and phone comparison of hospital, extras and combined policies from partner funds, with consultant-assisted switching | Individuals, couples, families; tax-driven (MLS) and Lifetime Health Cover-driven buyers | c. 2000; active | Free to consumer; upfront plus trail commission from funds |
Life & General | Life insurance comparison | Life, TPD, trauma and income protection. Reworked under a "new life insurance model" with improved economics by FY2022. | Households with dependants and mortgage holders | Active | Commission |
Life & General | Car insurance comparison | Comprehensive and third-party comparison. Online sales reached 40% of the car sales mix in FY2022 (23% in FY2021). About two million car insurance comparisons since 2018. | Drivers | Car comparison since at least 2013 (Auto & General panel deal); active | Commission. iSelect says the comprehensive cover price matches going direct. |
Life & General | Home & contents insurance | Comparison, with related-party Budget Direct products arranged by Auto & General Services | Homeowners, renters | First enabled via Auto & General agreement; active | Commission |
Life & General | Travel insurance | Comparison and referral | Travellers | Active (FSG 2025) | Commission |
Life & General | Pet insurance | Via Choosi partnership | Pet owners | Partnership disclosed FY2020; active | Commission / referral |
Life & General | Business insurance | Via BizCover partnership | SMEs | Disclosed FY2020 | Referral |
Energy & Telco | Electricity & gas comparison | Plans from partner retailers. About 4 million energy comparisons in the two years to Oct 2020. Since the ACCC case, disclosures state iSelect does not compare all providers or plans. | Households, movers | 2012; active | Retailer commission per switch |
Energy & Telco | Broadband / NBN comparison | Plans from partner providers | Households | Active | Commission |
Energy & Telco | Moving-home connection service | Your Porter partnership for utility transfers | Movers | 2,016 | Referral |
Energy & Telco | Energy Watch | Energy brokerage and comparison business (acquired 2014) | Households and businesses | Exited / impaired by FY2020 | Commission |
Finance | Home loans | Referral partnership with AFG after the in-house operation closed | Borrowers | Mar 2019 | Referral fee |
Finance | Car, personal and business loans, credit cards | Referral comparison | Consumers | Per company description | Referral |
Finance | InfoChoice | Financial-product comparison site | Consumers | Acquired pre-2018; written down $16.9m in FY2018; sold to LK Group in FY2019 | — |
International | iMoney (20.1% stake, later increased) | Malaysia/Philippines comparison platform | SE Asian consumers | 2014 to exited | — |
Loyalty | Qantas Frequent Flyer partnership | Points incentive for purchases | Consumers | c. FY2014 | Loyalty cost borne by iSelect |
Financial Narrative
Income statement
Notes: - FY2018 NPAT is reported as -$13.5m (FNN, Aug 2018). The FY2019 results described the prior year as a $15.6m loss (Banking Day), which reflects a restatement or different basis. Both are noted.
-
FY2021 underlying EBITDA is derived from FY2022's $9.9m being a 52% decline.
-
Reports said FY2022 underlying NPAT "tumbled 94%" to $1.8m. That implies about $30m in FY2021, which conflicts with the reported FY2021 statutory loss of $5.2m. The likely cause is tax or trail items in FY2021 underlying NPAT; it is unresolved and flagged.
-
Gross profit and operating income on a consistent basis are not publicly disclosed in retrieved sources.
Margins (% derived)
Revenue CAGR FY2018–FY2022 (derived, as-reported basis): (93.1 / 181.4)^(1/4) − 1 ≈ -15.4% per year.
Per-share data
Dividends: InvestSMART records 1.5c fully franked (ex-date 22 Feb 2018). FNN reported that a 2.5c fully franked final dividend was declared with the FY2018 result, but InvestSMART lists no Aug/Sep 2018 payment (discrepancy). InvestSMART also lists a distribution with ex-date 1 Jun 2021, unfranked, amount not displayed. Earlier distributions were 1.5c in Sep 2016, 1.5c in Mar 2017 and a payment in Sep 2017. Share count is derived from $72m / $0.30.
Balance sheet
In April 2018 iSelect reported no debt and cash of $21.1m (Channel News). In FY2016 it had about $100m cash and about $80m of trail receivables (Intelligent Investor, Feb 2016). The trail commission receivable (contract asset) was historically the largest asset.
Cash flow
Operating cash flow figures from Banking Day (FY2019 results). In 1H FY2019, operating cash flow was +$1.4m only because of a tax refund. JobKeeper receipts were $3.4m in the June 2020 quarter.
Ratios
ROE, ROA, ROIC, current ratio, debt/equity, net debt/EBITDA, interest coverage, asset turnover and cash conversion cycle are not computable from verified data. Qualitatively, iSelect carried no meaningful bank debt through the period (April 2018 disclosure). Leverage ratios were therefore near zero, and returns on equity were negative in every statutory year from FY2018 to FY2021.
Commentary on trends and drivers
The defining financial trend is a four-year revenue contraction of roughly half, from $181.4m (FY2018) to $93.1m (FY2022). Four drivers stand out:
-
Marketing failure and reset (FY2018). The "life admin" campaign and less search-engine marketing cut lead volumes. That led to the April 2018 downgrade, the CEO's exit and a statutory EBIT loss of $12.9m. Management then moved to "ROI-driven" marketing: 1H FY2019 marketing spend fell from $29.3m to $20.5m, and revenue per marketing dollar rose from $2.82 to $3.54 (Livewire). This improved underlying earnings but shrank revenue.
-
Energy regulation (FY2019–FY2020). The Default Market Offer and Victorian Default Offer, introduced in 2019, cut switching incentives and commissions. Energy & Telco revenue fell from $43.1m to $15.0m between FY2019 and FY2022, a decline of about 65%.
-
Health insurance policy shocks (FY2020). The 1 April 2020 premium rise was deferred to 1 October 2020 because of COVID-19, removing iSelect's peak demand trigger. This was compounded by suspended elective surgery. Some demand shifted into 1Q FY2021, when EBITDA reached $8.1m versus $1.7m a year earlier (FNN).
-
Life insurance market reform (FY2020–FY2021). Industry repricing and disability-income product changes cut life volumes. An iSelect revised model then lifted Life & General EBITDA to $9.07m in FY2022.
FY2022's 16% revenue decline and 52% fall in underlying EBITDA came as Health revenue fell 17.6% while the takeover was in prospect. iSelect was a structurally shrinking business when IHA acquired it, which explains the low take-out price.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansFinancial Detail
Income Statement
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Revenue as reported (AUD Mn) | 181.4 | 154.2 | 120.4 | 110.97 | 93.1 |
Revenue restated comparative (AUD Mn) | 176.9 | — | — | — | — |
Statutory EBITDA (AUD Mn) | -5.5 | — | — | — | — |
Underlying EBITDA (AUD Mn) | — | — | — | 20.6 | 9.9 |
Statutory EBIT (AUD Mn) | -12.9 | — | — | — | — |
Underlying EBIT (AUD Mn) | 8.5 | — | — | — | — |
Net profit after tax incl discontinued (AUD Mn) | -13.5 | -4.4 | -43.5 | -5.2 | — |
Net profit continuing operations (AUD Mn) | — | -2.0 | -20.5 | — | — |
Underlying NPAT (AUD Mn) | — | — | — | — | 1.8 |
Margin Analysis (%)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Underlying EBITDA margin (%) | — | — | — | 18.6 | 10.6 |
Statutory net margin (%) | -7.4 | -2.9 | -36.1 | -4.7 | — |
Underlying net margin (%) | — | — | — | — | 1.9 |
Per-Share Data and Share Count (millions)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Underlying EPS derived (AUD cents) | — | 0.75 |
Dividends per share (AUD cents) | 1.5 | — |
Shares on issue approx (millions) | — | 240 |
Financial Analysis
| Metric | FY2018 |
|---|---|
Total debt (AUD Mn) | 0 |
Cash Flow
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 |
|---|---|---|
Operating cash flow (AUD Mn) | 8.8 | 4.7 |
Operating Metrics (millions) and Margin Analysis (%)
| Metric | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Total leads (millions) | 3.9 | 3.3 | — | — |
Conversion ratio (%) | 9.6 | 8.9 | — | — |
Health leads (thousands) | 982 | — | — | — |
Car online share of sales (%) | — | — | 23 | 40 |
Revenue by Region
| Region | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
Australia revenue (AUD Mn) | 120.43 | 110.97 | 93.11 |
International revenue continuing (AUD Mn) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Region Margins & Growth (%)
| Region | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
Australia revenue growth (%) | -19 | -7.9 | -16.1 |
Capital Markets
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
IPO | June 2013; implied market cap about $480m (derived) |
Peak price | About $2.20 (July 2017, per Startup Daily) |
April 2018 crash | Fell from about $1.00 to $0.38 intraday on the downgrade |
2020–2022 range | About $0.15–$0.50 (Banking Day) |
Undisturbed price before SIA | About $0.16 (derived from the 87.5% premium) |
Take-out | $0.30 cash; about $72m equity value |
Final quote | About $0.298 |
1/3/5-year performance | Not applicable (delisted since Dec 2022) |
Valuation multiples at take-out (derived) | EV/underlying EBITDA about 7.3x. P/underlying earnings about 40x. |
Analyst consensus | None (delisted) |
Credit ratings | None (no rated debt) |
Debt maturity profile | Not applicable (no material borrowings in the listed era) |
Metric | FY2018 |
Dividends per share (AUD cents) | 1.5 |
Analyst Conclusions
Management guidance: none public since the takeover. The last listed-era outlook (Aug 2022) pointed to "a new chapter" under full IHA ownership.
Consensus growth expectations: not available (private).
Bull case
-
Group synergies. Shared technology, data, panel and services with Compare the Market (already contracted under the 2025 FSGs) can cut iSelect's cost base and restore margins above the FY2022 underlying EBITDA margin of 10.6%.
-
Product economics. Access to Auto & General products and group negotiating power should improve panel price competitiveness and revenue per sale in car and home, where online share had already reached 40%.
-
Demand environment. Persistent cost-of-living pressure and premium inflation increase switching in iSelect's core categories, which the "Save More" campaign targets.
Bear case
-
Structural decline. Revenue fell about 15% a year from FY2018 to FY2022, and nothing public shows that trend has reversed.
-
Brand redundancy. Inside a group whose lead brand is Compare the Market, iSelect may become a secondary channel with constrained marketing investment. Narrowing product categories (FSG v18) could signal managed contraction.
-
Regulatory and conflict risk. Related-party product placement and the 2020 penalty history invite further ACCC or ASIC scrutiny of comparator neutrality.
Catalysts and monitorables (next 12 months):
-
Lodgement of iSelect Pty Ltd financial statements with ASIC, if lodged as a large proprietary company.
-
Further FSG revisions that signal category additions or exits.
-
Brand-architecture decisions within IHA Group (consolidation versus a dual-brand strategy).
-
ACCC comparator-sector enforcement or Digital Platform Services Inquiry recommendations.
-
The private health insurance premium round (April 2027) and energy default-offer resets (July 2027).
Concluding analyst verdict:
iSelect's public-market story is a cautionary one for consumer intermediaries. A 2013 float worth roughly half a billion dollars ended nine years later in a $72 million take-private by its largest competitor's owner. The equity value fell about 85% even though the take-out carried an 87.5% premium. Four forces drove the decline. First, a hybrid online-plus-call-centre model whose cost structure suited a world of scarce information, not ubiquitous digital comparison. Second, heavy dependence on health insurance, whose demand triggers are set by government policy. Third, regulatory shocks in energy and life insurance that compressed whole verticals; Energy & Telco revenue fell about 65% from FY2019 to FY2022. Fourth, governance turbulence: six CEO transitions in seven years, a failed brand campaign and an $8.5 million penalty for misleading consumers.
Strategically, the IHA acquisition was rational for the buyer. It removed an independent competitor, which the ACCC accepted, and gave IHA a second established brand, a health-advice capability and a panel at a modest multiple (about 7x trailing underlying EBITDA, derived). For iSelect the business, the outcome is a lower-volatility existence inside a vertically integrated group. The cost is real independence, which its own disclosures now acknowledge.
Investors cannot own iSelect today. Its relevance is as a benchmark for the economics of Australian comparison, and as an indicator of IHA Group's consolidation strategy. Absent public financials, the key judgement is whether IHA invests behind iSelect as a differentiated, advice-led brand or slowly folds it into Compare the Market. Evidence so far, including a 2024 brand campaign alongside operational integration, points to a dual-brand strategy with shared infrastructure. The FY2018–FY2022 record nonetheless argues for caution about any assumption of standalone growth. Verdict: a structurally challenged asset that now draws its strategic value from group synergies rather than standalone growth. Monitor for brand rationalisation.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansExecutive Leadership
Leadership History
| CEO | Tenure | Background | Exit context |
|---|---|---|---|
Damien Waller (Founder / Executive Chairman) | c. 2000 – 2014 (chair to Dec 2014) | Co-founder | Became NED |
Matt McCann | c. 2011 – Oct 2013 (two years as CEO, six on the executive team) | Founding management at Shazam | Resigned over growth priorities; later CEO of Compare the Market AU |
David Chalmers (Acting) | Oct 2013 – Mar 2014 | CFO | Interim |
Alex Stevens | Mar 2014 – c. 2015 | Ex-MD Fonterra Brands Australia, MD Carlton & United Breweries, CEO PepsiCo ANZ; former surgeon | — |
Scott Wilson | c. 2015/16 – Apr 2018 | — | Exited with the April 2018 downgrade |
Brodie Arnhold | Apr 2018 (interim), Aug 2018 – Nov 2020 | Board member | Moved back to the board; later Chairman |
Warren Hebard | Nov 2020 – Dec 2022 (listed era) | Chief Marketing & Commercial Officer; led the 2018 marketing review | Post-acquisition role not publicly disclosed |
Major Shareholders
| Holder | Stake | Source |
|---|---|---|
Innovation Holdings Australia / BHL Management Services Ltd and associates | 26% (62,430,788 shares) | InvestSMART; SmallCaps |
Thorney Investment Group | 14.34% | SmallCaps; Startup Daily |
Microequities Asset Management | 9.5% | SmallCaps |
Competitive Landscape
Key Competitors
| Competitor | Segments overlapping | Ownership | Positioning vs iSelect |
|---|---|---|---|
Compare the Market (AU) | Health, car, home, life, energy, finance | IHA Group (sister company since Dec 2022) | Market-leading brand ("meerkat"); now a co-owned rival |
Canstar (incl. RateCity) | Finance, insurance, energy ratings | Private | Ratings and research-led |
Finder | All categories | Private | Content and SEO-led, global |
Compare Club | Health, life, energy, home loans | Private | Hybrid phone and online, a close model analogue |
Choosi | Life, health, pet, funeral | Private | Also an iSelect partner (pet) |
Mozo | Banking, finance, energy | Private | Finance-focused |
WhistleOut | Broadband, mobile | Private | Telco specialist |
Econnex / other energy comparators | Energy | Private | Energy specialist |
Energy Made Easy / Victorian Energy Compare | Energy | Government | Free, whole-of-market; cited by the ACCC as the benchmark |
PrivateHealth.gov.au | Health | Government | Free, non-commercial comparison |
Direct channels (Medibank, Bupa, HCF, nib, insurers) | All | Listed and mutual | Disintermediation risk |
Recent Developments
As a private subsidiary, iSelect publishes no continuous-disclosure announcements.



