M8 Sustainable Limited Overview
M8 Sustainable Limited is a distressed, delisted Perth-based waste-services shell. It once tried to build a vertically integrated waste business in Western Australia. The model combined three things: a construction-and-demolition (C&D) and commercial-and-industrial (C&I) recycling and transfer facility at Maddington; an operations-and-maintenance contract at the Brockwaste waste-to-compost plant in Shenton Park; and the Gingin Class II landfill, the planned earnings engine. The company raised A$19.5m at its December 2019 IPO, but never brought Gingin into operation under its own ownership. Weak recycling economics, repeated impairments and expensive secured debt forced a voluntary administration in February 2023. Under the resulting Deed of Company Arrangement, Gingin passed to the major shareholder, M8 Holding Limited. What remains is a sub-scale Maddington waste transfer and metals operation. It carries negative equity (about A$11.7m deficit at 31 Dec 2023), relies on related-party funding, and has an unexecuted recapitalisation plan. It is now an unlisted public company with essentially no tradeable equity value.
Company's own description
The FY2023 Appendix 4E (lodged 30 Aug 2024) described the principal activities during FY2023 as:
-
receiving and recycling metals, C&I waste and C&D waste;
-
establishing a skip bin business (Access Waste) at the Maddington Waste Facility.
The same report noted that metals recycling was suspended during the year.
The 1H FY2024 Appendix 4D says only that the company's principal activities relate to the waste industry. It records a strategic decision to exit C&D recycling and to focus on scrap-metal recycling and a waste transfer station at Lot 281, Maddington.
The quarterly report for the period ended 30 September 2024 (lodged 24 Dec 2024) describes the latest operating model:
-
a metals shredding facility had been installed at Maddington and commissioning had begun;
-
operations were expected in early 2025, pending a licence amendment from the Department of Water and Environmental Regulation (DWER);
-
the site was accepting skip bin waste, sorting out the recyclable fraction and sending the rest to landfill;
-
management expected the landfill fraction to go to Gingin once Gingin opened in 2025.
Business model and revenue model
| Revenue type | Mechanism | Disclosed revenue recognition | Status (latest) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gate fees (C&D, C&I) | Per-tonne fees charged on waste delivered to Maddington | Point in time, on weighing and acceptance (1H FY24 Appendix 4D, Note 3) | Small; C&D recycling exited in FY2024 |
| Metals recycling sales | Aggregation, processing and sale of recycled metals to local and export buyers | Product sales | Largest revenue line FY2021–FY2022; suspended FY2023; shredder commissioning in 2024 |
| Skip bin services (Access Waste) | Skip hire using third-party logistics and the WasteVantage software platform | Service revenue | Reduced to a minimum in Dec 2022; nil in 1H FY2024 |
| Equipment hire | Hire of mobile plant | Service revenue | A$47.5k in 1H FY2024 |
| O&M service fee | Technical and operating support to Brockwaste (related party Star Shenton Energy) | Recognised over time | Contract terminated (FY2023) |
| Landfill gate fees (planned) | Gingin Class II landfill, 150,000 tpa approved capacity | — | Never earned by M8S; asset deconsolidated in Feb 2023 |
M8's revenue has always been almost entirely transactional service and product revenue. It has had no subscription or licensing income of significance.
Product vs service mix. Metals made up the bulk of revenue in the peak years: 57% in FY2021 and 76% in FY2022, per the FY22 Appendix 4E. That made M8 a commodity-exposed trading business in practice, not the infrastructure-like, gate-fee landfill operator described in its IPO prospectus.
Value chain position and customers
M8 sits in the mid-stream "post-collection" part of the waste value chain: receiving, sorting, processing and transfer. It also planned a downstream disposal asset, the landfill. Through Access Waste it outsourced collection logistics to third-party carriers instead of owning a truck fleet. The FY22 Appendix 4E describes this as a deliberate choice to minimise investment in logistics infrastructure.
Customer types disclosed or implied:
-
C&D waste generators: demolition and civil construction, including roads and buildings;
-
C&I generators: manufacturing, retail and wholesale;
-
metals offtakers in local and export markets;
-
a related-party facility owner (Star Shenton Energy, for Brockwaste O&M);
-
household and commercial skip-bin users in metropolitan Perth.
Concentration was extreme:
-
FY2022: the largest customer contributed A$4.79m, or 52% of revenue; the second contributed A$1.51m (FY22 Appendix 4E).
-
FY2023: the largest customer contributed A$0.84m, or 60% of revenue (FY23 Appendix 4E).
Independent characterisation
M8 Sustainable is best understood as a failed landfill development vehicle with a loss-making recycling yard attached. The investment case at IPO depended on completing and licensing Gingin, where landfill economics (high fixed cost, high incremental margin) could have absorbed Maddington's losses. Construction ran from April 2020 to early 2023 and was still not licensed when funding ran out. The company was then pushed into administration, and the landfill went to the controlling shareholder under the DOCA. The listed shell kept the liabilities and a sub-scale yard but lost the strategic asset. Today it is effectively a related-party-funded micro-business. Its prospects depend on supplying waste to a landfill it no longer owns.
Strategy
Stated strategy themes (latest company documents)
-
Exit low-value C&D recycling. Management judged C&D recycling uneconomic and pivoted to "more valuable waste streams" (1H FY24 Appendix 4D).
-
Metals recycling and shredding. A metals shredding facility was installed at Maddington with a local metals recycler. Commissioning began in 2024, with operations expected in early 2025 subject to a DWER licence amendment (Appendix 4C, Sep 2024 quarter).
-
Waste transfer and feedstock supply to Gingin. Maddington is positioned as a transfer station feeding the landfill fraction of skip waste to Gingin "once it is opened in 2025". M8 no longer owns that landfill (Appendix 4C, Sep 2024 quarter).
-
Cost reduction. Since June 2023:
-
all employees other than the MD were made redundant;
-
rental commitments were cut by 46%;
-
monthly rent fell from A$115k to A$62k (Dec 2023 quarterly; 1H FY24 Appendix 4D).
-
-
Recapitalisation and relisting. A planned A$3.5m raise in February 2025 was intended to fund A$1.5m of loan and creditor repayments and A$2.0m of working capital. It was to be combined with converting the Patina-held notes, so that the shares could trade again by February 2025 (1H FY24 Appendix 4D; Appendix 4C).
Initiatives in the last 24 months (Oct 2024–Oct 2026)
| Initiative | Date | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Patina Metals note conversion notice | 11 Nov 2024 | Requires an AGM vote; no AGM held or result located |
| Metals shredder commissioning | Sep 2024 quarter | Outcome not disclosed |
| A$3.5m recapitalisation | Targeted Feb 2025 | Not completed before delisting; status not disclosed |
| ASX reinstatement | Targeted Feb 2025 | Failed: removed from the Official List on 11 Feb 2025 |
Guidance / medium-term targets
None issued. No financial guidance has been given since the IPO prospectus. At listing, management said IPO funds would cover 18 months of full operations (SmallCaps, Dec 2019). The landfill opening was forecast several times and missed each time: Q4 calendar 2022 (FY22 Appendix 4E), then 2025 (Appendix 4C, Dec 2024).
ESG / sustainability commitments
No formal ESG targets, emissions targets or sustainability report have been published.
Products & Services
Waste Management and Recycling
Maddington Waste Facility (Kelvin Road, Maddington WA)
Description: Licensed waste receival, recycling and transfer facility in Perth's south-eastern industrial corridor.
History: Recommissioned 1 July 2019. Received C&D and C&I waste from August 2019.
Footprint change: From 1 October 2023 reduced to Lot 281 only, after Lot 280 and the offices were surrendered (1H FY24 Appendix 4D).
Capabilities: Sorting and resource recovery of C&D and C&I waste; weighbridge; waste transfer station licence; metals aggregation; and, from 2024, a metals shredder (commissioning, subject to a DWER licence amendment).
Target customers: Demolition contractors, civil contractors, C&I generators, skip operators.
Pricing: Per-tonne gate fees; specific tariffs not disclosed.
Commercial status: All assets impaired to zero by 30 June 2022 (cumulative Maddington impairments FY2020–FY2022: A$14.3m).
C&D waste recycling
Description: Processing of demolition and civil construction waste for resource recovery.
Performance: Revenue fell from A$2.55m (FY2021) to A$0.47m (FY2023).
Reason for decline: Management cited lower competitor gate fees and rising processing costs (FY22 and FY23 Appendix 4E).
Status: Exited in FY2024. Management said market and regulatory conditions had not made C&D recycling economically viable (1H FY24 Appendix 4D).
C&I waste recycling
Description: Processing of low-volume, high-value commercial and industrial waste.
Performance: Revenue A$627k (FY2021) to A$254k (FY2023) to A$18.5k (1H FY2024).
Metals recycling
Description: Aggregation, processing and sale of recycled ferrous and non-ferrous metals to local and export markets.
History: Launched in 2H FY2021. Peaked at A$7.0m revenue in FY2022 (A$6.98m of it in 1H FY2022), then paused as resources went to Gingin. Effectively nil in FY2023 (A$37.7k).
Economics: Cost of recycled metals in FY2022 was A$6.81m against A$7.00m of revenue, a gross spread of about 2.8%. The line was high-volume but nearly margin-free.
Relaunch: The 2024 shredding facility was installed with a local metals recycler. A$38k of financing came from Patina Metals in the September 2024 quarter. Its role as operating partner versus lender is not clearly disclosed.
Access Waste (skip bins)
Description: Perth metropolitan skip-bin hire using third-party logistics providers and a cloud-based ordering and logistics platform.
History: Launched mid-September 2021. Revenue A$420k (FY2022) and A$291k (FY2023). Reduced to a minimum in December 2022; nil in 1H FY2024.
Assets: Skip bins (cost A$91k, fully impaired) and two leased trucks.
WasteVantage / iHUB software platform
Description: Order, logistics and supply-chain software for waste management and transport, marketed in WA through Access Waste as WasteVantage.
Ownership: 50% JV interest in iHUB Technologies acquired for A$351k over 18 months.
Performance: iHUB revenue A$38.2k (Nov 2021–Jun 2022) and A$85.8k (FY2023). The JV was carried at nil by 31 December 2023 (1H FY24 Appendix 4D).
Equipment hire
Description: Hire of mobile plant.
Performance: A$741k (FY2022), A$183k (FY2023), A$47.5k (1H FY2024).
Green waste and weighbridge services
Description: A continuing green-waste agreement with Community Green Waste plus weighbridge activities. The company said these brought in cash flow at relatively low amounts (1H FY24 Appendix 4D).
Operations and Maintenance
Brockwaste O&M contract (Shenton Park WA)
Description: Operation and maintenance of the Brockwaste household-waste compost and energy facility.
Ownership of the facility: Star Shenton Energy Pty Ltd. At the IPO, Thai companies Star Universal (60%) and SBANG (40%) held the Brockwaste interests (SmallCaps, Dec 2019).
Fees: A$596k (FY2019), A$584k (FY2020), A$281k (FY2021), A$270k (FY2022), A$175k (FY2023).
Status: Terminated (FY23 Appendix 4E). Related-party receivables from Star Shenton Energy carried large expected-credit-loss allowances in FY2022–FY2023.
Landfill Operations (historic)
Gingin / Fernview Landfill (Lot 98 Wannamal Road South, Cullalla WA)
Description: Class II putrescible landfill, about 16 km north of the Gingin townsite. Approved capacity of 150,000 tonnes per year. Ten cells planned over the landfill's life; Cell 1 and its leachate system were built.
Approvals: - Ministerial Statements 796 (2009) and 1073 (2018);
-
DWER Works Approval W6083/2017/1;
-
operating licence L9443/2024/1, granted to Fernview on 19 November 2024 and expiring 19 November 2044 (DWER).
Capital invested by M8S: Capital work in progress was A$20.85m at 30 June 2022, plus A$9.2m of land.
Ownership: Lost through the DOCA. M8S holds 0.1% of Fernview; M8 Holding Limited holds 99.9%.
Financial Narrative
Period covered: FY2019–FY2023, the last five fiscal years with full-year statements. No FY2024 full-year income statement or balance sheet has been located; only the 1H FY2024 Appendix 4D and the FY2024 Appendix 4C cash summaries exist. FY2025 and FY2026 are not publicly disclosed.
Basis: FY2019–FY2022 figures are consolidated (including Fernview). FY2023 statutory figures include Fernview's discontinued operation up to deconsolidation.
Income statement
Sources: FY2020, FY2022 and FY2023 Appendix 4E. Notes on the table:
-
FY2019 EPS reflects a pre-IPO weighted share count of 2.47m.
-
FY2020 EPS was reported as A$(0.08) per share.
-
FY2023 continuing EPS was A$(0.011) per share.
-
"Direct site costs" means the "recycling, waste disposal and other site costs" line.
1H FY2024 (unaudited, review only):
-
Revenue A$288.8k; total income A$4.55m; net profit A$2.69m (EPS 0.49c).
-
The profit came entirely from non-cash items: a A$3.53m gain on lease termination, a A$0.30m impairment reversal and a A$0.19m gain on note modification.
-
Excluding those items, the underlying loss was about A$1.33m (analyst calculation from the 1H FY24 Appendix 4D).
Margins and growth (%)
Revenue CAGR (analyst calculations):
-
FY2019–FY2022: +137.7%;
-
FY2019–FY2023: +19.9%;
-
FY2020–FY2023: -10.7%.
Commentary. Revenue grew from FY2019 to FY2022 almost entirely because of metals trading. That stream carried a gross spread of about 2–4% and never covered the cost base. The site-cost margin proxy fell every year from FY2020 to FY2022, which matches management's account of falling competitor gate fees and rising processing costs. Operating losses were driven by three things:
-
repeated Maddington impairments, totalling A$14.3m over FY2020–FY2022;
-
IPO costs of A$5.94m in FY2020, mostly non-cash;
-
rising finance costs once the Remagen loan was drawn.
Finance costs were partly hidden by capitalising interest into Gingin: A$1.66m in FY2021, A$2.40m in FY2022 and A$1.22m in FY2023. The FY2023 net loss of A$17.9m is dominated by an A$11.8m loss on discontinued operations. That loss nets a A$17.3m DOCA contribution against a A$29.1m disposal of the Fernview investment.
Balance sheet
Sources: FY2020, FY2022 and FY2023 Appendix 4E. Net debt and working capital are analyst calculations.
No reconciliation was published.
At 31 December 2023 (1H FY24 Appendix 4D):
-
Total assets A$1.13m; cash A$1,906.
-
Borrowings A$7.80m, of which convertible notes plus capitalised interest were A$7.22m.
-
Lease liabilities A$3.15m.
-
Net assets A$(11.67)m; net current liabilities A$2.37m.
Cash flow
Notes:
FY2022 OCF restated: The FY2023 Appendix 4E restates FY2022 operating cash flow as -A$6,202.1k, versus -A$1,054.6k in the FY2022 Appendix 4E. The difference appears to be a reclassification of SBANG payables and project cash flows.
FY2023 OCF not meaningful: The reported FY2023 operating inflow of A$9.08m is distorted by adding back a A$27.6m "gain on deconsolidation" against the DOCA-driven loss. It does not reflect cash generation. Analysts should treat FY2023 OCF and FCF as not meaningful.
FY2024 cash flows (Appendix 4C, 12 months to 30 Jun 2024):
-
Customer receipts A$610k; operating cash flow -A$1,165k.
-
Asset-sale proceeds A$237k.
-
Net borrowings A$889k.
-
Cash at 30 June 2024 was reported as -A$13k, an overdrawn position as disclosed.
September 2024 quarter (Appendix 4C): operating cash flow -A$288k; financing +A$305k; cash at quarter end A$4k.
Ratios
Blank cells are not meaningful (negative equity) or lack the prior-year balance needed for an average. All ratios are analyst calculations from Appendix 4E data.
Other metrics:
ROIC: Not meaningful (negative NOPAT every year).
Net debt / EBITDA: Not meaningful (negative EBITDA every year).
Cash conversion cycle: Not publicly disclosed. Inventory was only held in FY2021 (A$389k of finished metals), and receivables were dominated by related-party balances.
Trend commentary. The balance sheet followed a simple arc:
-
Pre-IPO insolvency (FY2019 equity of -A$6.2m, funded by A$20.0m of SBANG loans).
-
IPO recapitalisation: A$19.5m cash plus A$18.5m of debt converted to equity in FY2020.
-
Debt-funded landfill construction: Remagen about A$10.5m in FY2021, then M8H loans and notes.
-
Collapse back into negative equity in FY2023.
The current ratio of 0.04x at 30 June 2022, with A$10.8m of Remagen debt falling current, was the clearest warning sign. It preceded the February 2023 administration by eight months.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansFinancial Detail
Segment Overview
| Segment | Contents | Products / services | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
Waste Management and Recycling | Maddington Waste Facility | C&D and C&I gate fees, metals recycling, skip bins (Access Waste), equipment hire | Only revenue-generating segment from FY2024 |
Operations and Maintenance (O&M) | Brockwaste contract, Shenton Park | Technical, business and ancillary support to waste-industry companies | Ceased on VA appointment (14 Feb 2023); contract terminated |
Landfill Operations | Gingin landfill (via Fernview) | Planned Class II landfill disposal | Never generated revenue; removed after deconsolidation |
Segment revenue (AUD K)
| Segment revenue (AUD K) | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Waste Management and Recycling | 87 | 1,399 | 7,760.2 | 8,911.7 | 1,235.5 |
Operations and Maintenance | 596 | 584 | 280.9 | 270.0 | 175.0 |
Landfill Operations | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Total revenue from contracts | 683 | 1,983 | 8,041.0 | 9,181.7 | 1,410.5 |
Segment EBITDA (AUD K)
| Segment EBITDA (AUD K) | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Waste Management and Recycling | -5,460 | -9,158 | -1,314.9 | -3,380.5 | -2,615.4 |
Operations and Maintenance | 378 | 45 | 45.8 | -43.2 | -40.1 |
Landfill Operations | -455 | -795 | -355.4 | -223.7 | 0 |
Total segment EBITDA | -5,537 | -9,908 | -1,624.5 | -3,647.5 | -2,796.3 |
Revenue by Segment
| Segment pre-tax result (AUD K) | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|
Waste Management and Recycling | -9,891.3 | -10,381.2 | -5,899.9 |
Operations and Maintenance | 22.0 | -77.9 | -40.1 |
Landfill Operations | -595.6 | -912.6 | 0 |
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansRevenue by Segment (FY2019–FY2021)
| Segment capital expenditure (AUD K) | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|---|
Waste Management and Recycling | 1,198 | 507 | 1,218.6 |
Operations and Maintenance | 102 | 35 | 43.6 |
Landfill Operations (Gingin) | 380 | 2,891 | 6,090.1 |
Segment Margins & Growth (%) and Revenue by Segment (%)
| Metric (%) | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|
WM&R EBITDA margin | -16.9 | -37.9 | -211.7 |
O&M EBITDA margin | 16.3 | -16.0 | -22.9 |
WM&R revenue YoY growth | 454.7 | 14.8 | -86.1 |
O&M revenue YoY growth | -51.9 | -3.9 | -35.2 |
WM&R share of total revenue | 96.5 | 97.1 | 87.6 |
O&M share of total revenue | 3.5 | 2.9 | 12.4 |
Revenue stream (AUD K)
| Revenue stream (AUD K) | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|
C&D waste gate fees | 2,554.3 | 545.4 | 470.2 |
C&I waste gate fees | 627.4 | 203.7 | 253.5 |
Metals recycling | 4,578.5 | 7,001.6 | 37.7 |
Skip bin (Access Waste) | 0 | 420.2 | 290.6 |
Equipment hire | 0 | 740.8 | 183.4 |
O&M service fee | 280.9 | 270.0 | 175.0 |
Income statement (AUD K)
| Income statement (AUD K) | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Revenue from contracts with customers | 683.5 | 1,982.6 | 8,041.0 | 9,181.7 | 1,410.5 |
Total income (incl. other and interest income) | 1,081.0 | 2,035.8 | 8,997.7 | 9,443.3 | 2,666.1 |
Revenue less direct site costs (analyst gross profit proxy) | 485.9 | 486.0 | 1,807.2 | 1,695.5 | 277.9 |
Segment EBITDA (as reported) | -5,537 | -9,908 | -1,624.5 | -3,647.5 | -2,796.3 |
EBIT (analyst-derived: pre-tax loss plus finance costs) | -5,675.2 | -13,288.1 | -9,919.1 | -10,267.6 | -2,738.7 |
Depreciation | 535.9 | 1,188.5 | 1,341.8 | 1,593.1 | 0 |
Impairment | 0 | 2,245.5 | 6,981.8 | 5,077.9 | 0 |
Finance costs (expensed) | 1,569.6 | 1,178.9 | 545.8 | 1,104.0 | 3,342.1 |
Pre-tax loss (continuing) | -7,244.8 | -14,467.0 | -10,464.9 | -11,371.7 | -6,080.8 |
Loss from discontinued operations | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | -11,813.2 |
Net loss after tax | -7,230.3 | -13,794.1 | -10,464.9 | -11,371.7 | -17,894.0 |
Basic and diluted EPS (A$ cents) | -293.0 | -8.0 | -4.2 | -2.5 | -3.4 |
Dividends per share (A$ cents) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Margin / growth metric (%)
| Margin / growth metric (%) | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gross margin proxy | 71.1 | 24.5 | 22.5 | 18.5 | 19.7 |
Segment EBITDA margin | -810.1 | -499.7 | -20.2 | -39.7 | -198.2 |
EBIT margin (derived) | -830.3 | -670.2 | -123.4 | -111.8 | -194.2 |
Net margin | -1,057.9 | -695.8 | -130.1 | -123.9 | -1,268.6 |
Revenue YoY growth | — | 190.1 | 305.6 | 14.2 | -84.6 |
Balance Sheet and Share Count (millions)
| Balance sheet (AUD K) | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Total assets | 17,596.6 | 29,507.2 | 32,271.1 | 35,001.0 | 2,447.6 |
Cash and equivalents | 41.0 | 4,164.3 | 1,815.1 | 11.6 | 41.9 |
Property, plant and equipment | 15,616.4 | 17,214.6 | 20,829.5 | 30,049.7 | 0 |
Right-of-use assets | 0 | 6,136.8 | 3,428.0 | 0 | 0 |
Goodwill and intangibles | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Borrowings, current | 20,550.2 | 61.2 | 1,086.2 | 10,780.0 | 574.7 |
Borrowings, non-current | 20.1 | 1.3 | 10,518.5 | 2,841.6 | 6,344.7 |
Total borrowings | 20,570.3 | 62.6 | 11,604.7 | 13,621.6 | 6,919.3 |
Lease liabilities | 0 | 7,685.2 | 9,067.9 | 8,695.0 | 6,909.9 |
Net debt excl. leases | 20,529.3 | -4,101.7 | 9,789.6 | 13,610.0 | 6,877.4 |
Net debt incl. leases | 20,529.3 | 3,583.5 | 18,857.5 | 22,305.0 | 13,787.3 |
Total liabilities | 23,838.7 | 8,800.2 | 22,291.9 | 31,882.0 | 15,384.8 |
Total equity | -6,242.1 | 20,707.0 | 9,979.2 | 3,119.0 | -12,937.2 |
Working capital (current assets less current liabilities) | -21,311.5 | 3,652.7 | 529.9 | -20,260.1 | -682.1 |
Shares on issue (millions) | 15.5 | 233.2 | 233.2 | 477.2 | 548.6 |
Financial Analysis
| Item at 30 Jun 2023 | FY2023 Appendix 4E | 1H FY2024 Appendix 4D |
|---|---|---|
Cash | A$41.9k | A$25.7k |
Total assets | A$2.45m | A$0.97m |
Net assets | A$(12.94)m | A$(14.39)m |
Net current liabilities | A$0.68m | A$3.66m |
Issued capital | A$48.31m | A$47.01m (convertible note reserve of A$1.39m shown separately) |
Cash flow (AUD K)
| Cash flow (AUD K) | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Operating cash flow (as reported) | -3,151.6 | -5,012.7 | -2,001.0 | -1,054.6 | 9,076.9 |
Purchase of PP&E (capex) | 1,679.8 | 3,240.6 | 7,020.7 | 5,147.6 | 0 |
Other landfill investing payments (capitalised interest and contractor) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1,947.9 |
Free cash flow (OCF less capex, analyst) | -4,831.4 | -8,253.3 | -9,021.7 | -6,202.2 | 7,129.0 |
Proceeds from share issues | 0 | 19,500.0 | 0 | 4,379.9 | 500.0 |
Dividends paid | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Share buybacks | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Net change in cash | -31.6 | 4,123.3 | -2,349.2 | -1,803.5 | 28.2 |
Returns & Leverage Ratios (%) and Financial Ratios (x)
| Ratio | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ROE (%, net loss / average equity) | — | -190.7 | -68.2 | -173.6 | — |
ROA (%, net loss / average assets) | — | -58.6 | -33.9 | -33.8 | -95.6 |
Current ratio (x) | 0.08 | 2.74 | 1.15 | 0.04 | 0.72 |
Debt / equity (x, borrowings only) | — | 0.003 | 1.16 | 4.37 | — |
Debt / equity (x, incl. leases) | — | 0.37 | 2.07 | 7.16 | — |
Interest coverage (x, EBIT / finance costs) | -3.6 | -11.3 | -18.2 | -9.3 | -0.8 |
Asset turnover (x, revenue / average assets) | — | 0.08 | 0.26 | 0.27 | 0.08 |
Geographic revenue (AUD K)
| Geographic revenue (AUD K) | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|
Australia (Western Australia) | 8,041.0 | 9,181.7 | 1,410.5 |
Rest of world (reported separately) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Geographic growth (%)
| Geographic growth (%) | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|
Australia YoY revenue growth | 305.6 | 14.2 | -84.6 |
Share Price & Returns
| Reference point | Date | Price (AUD) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
IPO price | 11 Dec 2019 | 0.20 | FY2020 Appendix 4E; Stockhead |
Rights issue (implied: A$4.66m / 233.2m shares) | FY2022 | 0.02 | FY22 Appendix 4E (analyst calculation) |
Last trade | 8 Feb 2023 | 0.009 | MarketIndex |
Removal from Official List | 11 Feb 2025 | Not traded | ASX |
Share capital metric
| Share capital metric | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ordinary shares on issue at year end (millions) | 15.53 | 233.23 | 233.23 | 477.21 | 548.64 |
Weighted average shares (millions) | 2.47 | 165.01 | 249.50 | 453.56 | 530.63 |
Issued capital (AUD K) | 2,345.4 | 41,991.4 | 41,991.4 | 46,513.0 | 48,309.2 |
Net tangible assets per share (A$ cents) | -40 | 9 | 4 | 1 | -2 |
Capital Markets
| Item | Status |
|---|---|
P/E, EV/EBITDA, EV/Sales | Not meaningful (losses, negative EBITDA, no quoted price) |
P/B | Not meaningful (negative book value) |
Peer multiples | Not presented, since M8 has no market price |
Analyst consensus | None; no broker coverage identified |
Dividend history / policy | No dividends ever paid (all Appendix 4E reports) |
Credit ratings (Moody's / S&P / Fitch) | Not rated |
Debt Facilities
| Facility | Lender | Limit / drawn (AUD K) | Rate | Maturity | Security |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Convertible notes (M8H facility, now assigned to Patina) | Patina Metals (from 13 Aug 2024) | 7,048 / 7,048 (plus capitalised interest; carrying value A$7.22m at Dec 2023) | 10% (A$5.5m tranche); 4.5% (A$2.5m facility tranche) | 15 Aug 2025 (A$5.5m tranche); 31 Mar 2025 (A$1.55m tranche); holder intends to convert | Unsecured |
Working capital loan | M8 Holding Limited | 750 limit | 0% | 2-year term | Unsecured |
Working capital loan | Patina Metals | 500 limit | 0% | 2-year term | Unsecured |
Combined drawn on the two loans above | — | 965 drawn of 1,250 | — | — | — |
Gingin construction loan / payable | SBANG Australia Pty Ltd | 942 / 942 | 10% | Jun 2025 | Unsecured |
Lease liabilities (Maddington) | Lessor | 3,152 (Dec 2023) | — | 7-year lease from Oct 2023 | Bank guarantee A$406.5k |
Analyst Conclusions
Management guidance
No quantitative guidance. The last stated plan (December 2024) was:
-
raise A$3.5m in February 2025;
-
convert the Patina-held notes;
-
restart metals shredding in early 2025;
-
supply residual waste to Gingin once it opened in 2025.
None of these outcomes has been publicly confirmed. Removal from the ASX on 11 February 2025 strongly suggests the recapitalisation was not completed in time.
Consensus expectations
None. There is no analyst coverage.
Bull case
-
Clean balance sheet after conversion. If Patina converts about A$7.2m of notes and the A$3.5m raise is completed, interest-bearing debt would fall to roughly the SBANG A$0.94m and the small working-capital loans. That would leave a debt-light transfer and metals business with a 7-year site lease.
-
Gingin feedstock synergy. Fernview's DWER licence (granted 19 November 2024, valid to 2044) gives Maddington's transfer station a dedicated, licensed disposal outlet. That could support recurring throughput revenue from skip and C&I residuals.
-
Shell value plus tax losses. An unlisted public company with about A$60m of accumulated losses and existing waste licences could be useful to the controlling group for consolidation or a relisting. Use of the tax losses depends on Australian tax tests.
Bear case
-
Value transferred to the parent. The economically valuable asset, the licensed Gingin landfill, now sits 99.9% with M8 Holding. Minority shareholders of M8S kept the loss-making yard and the liabilities.
-
No demonstrated earnings power. Even at peak revenue (A$9.18m in FY2022) M8 lost A$3.6m at segment EBITDA level. In 1H FY2024, underlying operations generated only A$289k of revenue against roughly A$1.3m of underlying losses (analyst calculation).
-
Governance and reporting deficits. Chronic late reporting, unreconciled restatements, unpaid listing fees and related-party funding make the equity very hard to underwrite. Minority shareholders now also lack the protections of ASX listing.
Catalysts and monitorables (next 12 months)
-
Any AGM notice, especially a resolution to approve the Patina note conversion and its implied price.
-
Completion or abandonment of the A$3.5m recapitalisation.
-
DWER decision on the Maddington licence amendment for metals shredding.
-
Start of operations at the Fernview/Gingin landfill and any supply agreement with M8S.
-
Lodgement of FY2024, FY2025 and FY2026 annual financial reports with ASIC.
-
Any relisting application, takeover or compulsory acquisition by the controlling shareholder group.
-
Repayment or extension of the SBANG A$942k loan (due June 2025) and the convertible notes (due March and August 2025).
-
Any insolvency event, given near-zero cash and the auditor's going-concern uncertainty.
Concluding analyst verdict
M8 Sustainable Limited is a cautionary case study, not an investable equity. It came to market in December 2019 with a coherent thesis: pair a licensed Perth recycling yard with a fully approved Class II landfill, and let landfill economics fund the group. Execution failed on every axis that matters for a development-stage waste company.
Construction of Gingin absorbed about A$21m of capital work in progress. Licensing took from March 2022 to November 2024, and by then the company no longer owned the asset. Maddington, meant to be the feeder, was impaired three years in a row, for A$14.3m in total, and was written to zero. Revenue growth came from near-zero-margin metals trading, which flattered the top line while losses continued: A$7.2m, A$13.8m, A$10.5m, A$11.4m and A$17.9m over FY2019–FY2023.
The February 2023 administration settled outside creditors. But it did so by moving the landfill, the one asset with long-duration value, to the controlling shareholder. Minority investors kept a negative-equity shell with A$1,906 of cash at 31 December 2023. Cost-cutting and a A$3.53m non-cash lease gain produced an accounting profit in 1H FY2024. That profit masks an underlying business generating under A$0.6m of annual revenue.
The company's own plan, a A$3.5m raise, note conversion and an ASX return by February 2025, did not stop removal from the Official List on 11 February 2025. No subsequent disclosure has been located.
For an outside investor the equity is effectively illiquid and, on available evidence, of negligible value. Any recovery depends on decisions by the related-party creditor and controlling shareholder group, on terms not yet disclosed. The only parties positioned to capture value are the holders of Gingin (M8 Holding) and of the convertible notes (Patina Metals).
Rating view: Avoid / no coverage. Monitor ASIC lodgements and any shareholder-meeting notice for conversion terms.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansExecutive Leadership
Executive Leadership Team
| Name | Role | Tenure / appointment | Background (as disclosed or reported) | Compensation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Tomasz (Tom) Jacek Rudas | Managing Director and CEO | Since before IPO (founder-era MD) | Founder of AnaeCo Limited (ASX: ANQ), a waste-treatment technology company (Stockhead, Dec 2019). Yahoo profile lists BSc, BSc (Hons) and MBA | Yahoo Finance lists pay of A$308.01k (fiscal year not stated) |
Saithsiri Saksitthisereekul | Non-executive Chairman | Appointed Chairman 14 Dec 2022 | Not publicly disclosed in reviewed documents | — |
Damien Craig Flugge | Director (described elsewhere as General Manager and Executive Director) | Appointed to the board 14 Dec 2022 per 1H FY24 Appendix 4D; earlier involvement indicated by an FY2019 "Flugge superannuation loan" settlement | — | Yahoo lists A$252.51k (year not stated) |
Winton Willesee | Company Secretary | Appointed 23 Feb 2024 | Not publicly disclosed in reviewed documents | — |
John Colli | Company Secretary (former) | Retired 23 Feb 2024 | Signed ASX lodgements 2020–2022 | — |
Alessandra Gauvin | Joint Company Secretary (per Yahoo; not in 1H FY24 directory) | — | — | — |
“—” = not publicly disclosed.
Major Shareholders
| Holder | Stake | Basis / date | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
M8 Holding Limited (Thailand) | Described as "largest shareholder" (2022 Annual Report) and "majority shareholder" (1H FY24 Appendix 4D); exact % not publicly disclosed | 2022–2024 | 2022 Annual Report; 1H FY24 Appendix 4D |
SBANG Sustainable Energies Ltd (Thailand) | 83,215,038 shares (35.68%) | Substantial holder notice from the IPO era (on 233.2m shares); current % diluted and not disclosed | InvestSMART; Stockhead |
Star Universal (Thailand) | Substantial shareholder at IPO; % not disclosed | Dec 2019 | SmallCaps |
Adroit Capital Group ESG Pty Ltd | 71,428,521 shares issued in FY2023 (about 13.0% of 548.6m; analyst calculation) | FY2023 | FY23 Appendix 4E, Note 21 |
Patina Metals Pty Ltd | Holds assigned convertible notes (face value A$7.05m plus capitalised interest); has given notice to convert subject to shareholder approval | Aug–Nov 2024 | 1H FY24 Appendix 4D |
Competitive Landscape
Key Competitors
| Competitor | Segment overlap | Revenue (latest available) | Positioning vs M8 |
|---|---|---|---|
Cleanaway Waste Management (ASX: CWY) | Collection, C&I, landfill, resource recovery | FY2025 net revenue A$3,302.7m; underlying EBITDA A$791.3m (Cleanaway FY25 results, 20 Aug 2025) | National market leader with integrated landfills; overwhelming scale advantage |
Sims Limited (ASX: SGM) | Metals recycling | FY2025 sales revenue A$7,494.0m; ANZ segment A$1,575.5m; underlying EBIT A$174.9m (Sims FY25 results, 19 Aug 2025) | Global metals recycler with shredders and export logistics; sets metal pricing benchmarks M8 faces |
Veolia Australia and New Zealand | Collection, landfill, resource recovery (original proponent of the Fernview landfill approval) | Not publicly disclosed separately | Multinational integrated operator |
Resource Recovery Solutions (Bayswater WA) | C&D processing | Not publicly disclosed (private) | — |
Brajkovich Landfill & Recycling Pty Ltd (WA) | Landfill, C&D crushing/screening | Not publicly disclosed (private) | Licensed WA landfill and recycling operator (DWER register) |
Shire of Gingin Waste Management Facility | Class II landfill in the same shire | Not applicable (local government) | Municipal Class II landfill, licence L6900/1997/13 (reissued 31 Mar 2022) |
Fernview Environmental (M8 Holding) | Landfill | — | Former subsidiary; now both a potential customer and a competitor for disposal margin |
Repurpose It (Victoria) | C&D and resource recovery (benchmark peer) | Not publicly disclosed; acquired by Palisade Infrastructure in Nov 2023 | Example of a scaled, institutionally owned C&D recycler |
Perth regional council landfills (e.g., Tamala Park / Mindarie Regional Council; Red Hill / Eastern Metropolitan Regional Council) | Landfill / disposal | — | — |
Local skip-bin operators (fragmented, unnamed) | Skip hire | — | Low-barrier, price-competitive market that Access Waste struggled in |
“—” = not publicly disclosed.
Peer Comparison FY2025
| Metric | M8 Sustainable (FY2022, last full operating year) | Cleanaway (FY2025) | Sims (FY2025) |
|---|---|---|---|
Revenue (AUD Mn) | 9.18 | 3302.7 (net) | 7,494.0 |
Revenue growth (%) | 14.2 | 3.4 | 4.1 |
EBITDA margin (%) | -39.7 | 24.0 (underlying) | 5.7 (underlying) |
EBIT margin (%) | -111.8 | 12.5 (underlying) | 2.3 (underlying) |
Recent Developments
Disclosure limitation: * The 18-month window to 11 October 2026 runs from April 2025 to October 2026. No company announcements, press coverage or regulatory filings concerning M8 Sustainable Limited dated after the 11 February 2025 delisting were found. As an unlisted public company, M8 has no continuous-disclosure obligation to the ASX. Its remaining obligations are ASIC annual lodgements, which were not searched in paid registries.
The table below therefore covers the most recent available period, from August 2023 to February 2025.



