Monash Absolute Investment Company Limited Overview
Monash Absolute Investment Company Limited was a small, externally managed ASX-listed investment company. It gave retail investors access to Monash Investors' long-biased, benchmark-unaware Australian equity long/short strategy. The manager was founded in 2012 by former UBS Asset Management and Colonial First State executives Simon Shields and Shane Fitzgerald [S7]. The vehicle had two stated aims: a positive return over a 5–7 year cycle, and avoiding a negative return in any financial year [S2][S14]. It ran a concentrated book of best ideas, held cash and shorts, and could invest in pre-IPO companies.
Like most Australian LICs, MA1 persistently traded below its net asset value. Its strategic significance comes from how it dealt with that problem. In 2021 it became the first Australian LIC to convert into an exchange-traded managed fund, and in 2024 that ETMF was folded into an unlisted small-companies fund. Today the "company" survives only as an unlisted Australian small-cap fund run by a boutique being acquired by DMX Asset Management.
What the entity did. MA1 was a closed-end investment company. It raised permanent equity capital on the ASX and handed portfolio management to Monash Investors Pty Limited under an investment management agreement. Its only business was investing in listed (and some pre-IPO) Australian equities, long and short, and paying franked dividends from realised, taxed profits.
Business and revenue model. An LIC has no product, service, subscription or licensing revenue. Its "revenue" is investment income: dividends, interest and realised or unrealised gains and losses on the portfolio. Its main costs are the management fee and the performance fee paid to the external manager, plus listing, registry, audit, directors' fees and brokerage. In 2018 MA1 paid a management fee of 1.5% p.a. (plus GST) and a performance fee of 20% (plus GST) of returns above the RBA cash rate, subject to a high-water mark [S2]. After the 2021 conversion, the MAAT management fee was cut to 1.25% plus GST [S4].
Position in the value chain. MA1 was a retail-facing wrapper sitting between ASX-listed retail capital and a boutique manager. The value chain ran: retail and adviser investors → listed vehicle (MA1) → investment manager (Monash Investors) → ASX-listed small and mid-cap investee companies. Service providers included the share registry, custodian and prime broker, auditor, and Winston Capital Partners, which acted as the AFSL holder for Monash's general advice [S2].
Investor types. Self-directed retail investors, financial advisers and their clients, SMSFs, and some high-net-worth investors. The manager's principals were also substantial holders. Simon Shields, for example, took up 200,000 shares at AUD 1.05 in May 2020 [S15].
End-markets. The portfolio was invested mainly in Australian listed equities across all sectors and sizes, with a bias toward small and mid-caps. Top long holdings in September 2018 included Lovisa, Emeco, EML Payments, Nearmap, Healthia, Speedcast, Paragon Care, Electro Optic Systems and Afterpay Touch [S2].
Company's own description. The 2018 AGM materials describe the approach as benchmark unaware, stock-size agnostic and style agnostic. The portfolio could hold up to 5% in pre-IPO companies, run short positions and hold cash [S2]. Its two objectives were a targeted positive return over the medium to long term and limiting capital losses over the medium term [S2]. A market-data summary of the company describes the cycle as 5 to 7 years and the goal as avoiding negative financial years [S14].
Independent characterisation. MA1 was a sub-scale LIC, with net assets of roughly AUD 45–50m, built around a high-conviction stock-picking franchise. Its returns were respectable but not exceptional: a 9.7% annualised five-year return against 10.1% for the ASX 200 [S3]. Two problems dominated. Its small size gave it high fixed costs per dollar invested. And it suffered a structural share-price discount, at times as wide as 16% [S3]. Management tried buybacks, bonus and loyalty options, a share purchase plan and higher dividends. None of these closed the discount. Management then concluded the closed-end structure itself was the problem and dismantled it, first converting to an ETMF and then moving to an unlisted fund.
Strategy
Stated strategy themes (paraphrased from manager materials):
-
Pursue absolute rather than index-relative returns, with double-digit returns targeted over the cycle [S1].
-
Run a concentrated "best ideas" portfolio of up to about 30 stocks [S21], mostly long Australian equities with some shorts, and no regard to the benchmark [S1].
-
Find stocks through recurring business situations: product rollouts, organic growth plus acquisitions, and industry recoveries [S21][S2].
-
Keep short positions concentrated, typically up to 2.5% per short, two or three at a time, held for about two months [S24].
Medium-term targets. The only stated return target is double-digit returns over a full market cycle (MAAT) [S1][S12]. No numerical financial guidance applies.
ESG commitments. None publicly disclosed in the sources reviewed.
Products & Services
The "products" here are the investment vehicles through which the Monash strategy was offered.
Flagship investment "offerings" (portfolio exposures, 30 Sep 2018) [S2]:
Portfolio construction at 30 Sep 2018: 17 "Outlook" longs (62%), 1 Outlook short (−3%), 2 Event/Pair/Group longs (13%), 1 Event short (−6%), cash 33%. Gross exposure was 84% and net exposure 67% [S2].
Product Portfolio
| Vehicle | Type | Status | Launch | Key features | Target investor | Fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Monash Absolute Investment Company Ltd (ASX: MA1) | Listed investment company | Defunct (converted June 2021) | Apr 2016 | Closed-end; long-biased long/short; benchmark unaware; up to 5% pre-IPO; franked dividends | Retail and SMSF via ASX | 1.5% p.a. + GST management; 20% + GST performance fee over RBA cash rate with HWM [S2] |
MA1 Bonus Options | Listed options | Expired 15 May 2020 | Nov 2018 | Free entitlement to shareholders to grow scale and liquidity | MA1 shareholders | — |
MA1 Loyalty Options | Options issued on exercise of bonus options | — | Nov 2018 | Reward for exercising bonus options | MA1 shareholders | — |
Monash Absolute Active Trust (Hedge Fund) (ASX: MAAT) | ETMF under ASX AQUA rules | Delisted 21 Jun 2024 | 10 Jun 2021 | Open-ended; daily liquidity near NAV; dual registry; long-biased with shorts; up to about 30 stocks | Retail via ASX | — |
Monash Investors Small Companies Trust (Hedge Fund) | Renamed MAAT | Merged June 2024 | 2023 rename | Small-cap mandate; cash 0–10%; limited shorting [S22] | Retail via ASX | — |
Monash Absolute Investment Fund (MAIF) | Unlisted unit trust | Renamed 2023 | Jun/Jul 2012 | Original absolute-return strategy; historic minimum A$500,000 (wholesale era) [S23] | Wholesale, later retail | — |
Monash Investors Small Companies Fund, Class A (MON0001AU) | Unlisted unit trust | Active | Inception 30 Jun 2012 | Invests mainly in ASX securities outside the S&P/ASX 100; barred from buying S&P/ASX 50 stocks [S10][S11] | Retail/adviser; minimum A$20,000 [S10] | — |
Monash Investors Small Companies Fund, Class B (PIM6813AU) | Unit class | Active (per data provider) | — | Same strategy | — | — |
| Holding | Ticker | Business | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
Cash | — | — | 33.1% |
Lovisa | LOV | Fast-fashion jewellery retailer | 6.9% |
Emeco Holdings | EHL | Mining equipment lessor | 6.8% |
EML Payments | EML | Transaction cards | 5.5% |
Nearmap | NEA | Aerial imagery | 5.0% |
Healthia | HEA | Health care | 4.8% |
Speedcast | SDA | Telecommunications | 4.6% |
Paragon Care | PGC | Health care | 4.0% |
Electro Optic Systems | EOS | Defence/space industrials | 3.6% |
Afterpay Touch | APT | Buy-now-pay-later | 3.6% |
Coca-Cola Amatil (short) | CCL | Beverages | −2.6% |
Japara Healthcare (short) | JHC | Aged care | −2.1% |
Estia Health (short) | EHE | Aged care | −2.0% |
Regis Healthcare (short) | REG | Aged care | −2.0% |
Financial Narrative
Applicability. EBITDA, gross profit, capex, ROIC, cash conversion cycle, goodwill and interest coverage do not meaningfully apply to an LIC with no operating business. The board and the industry judge performance by the change in pre-tax net tangible assets (NTA) per share plus dividends, not by statutory profit, which swings with unrealised gains.
Data availability. Only the figures below could be confirmed from primary or near-primary sources during this research.
Income statement (MA1)
Source: FY2018 NPAT and dividend from the 2 Nov 2018 AGM/CIO update [S2].
Investment performance (chartable)
Source: [S2]. FY2016 for MA1 is a stub of about 2.5 months from listing. MA1 FYTD2019 (to 30 Sep 2018) return was +2.88%. MA1's since-inception return to 30 Sep 2018 was 2.04% p.a.; MAIF's was 9.55% p.a. [S2].
Longer-horizon data points:
Balance sheet (MA1)
Point-in-time data: on 30 Sep 2018, shares on issue were 44,314,634 and total pre-tax NAV was AUD 45,698,352 [S2]. That works out to about AUD 1.03 per share pre-tax NAV, calculated from the two disclosed figures. The September 2018 buyback retired 10% of shares at AUD 0.96 [S2].
Debt. No borrowings were disclosed. The strategy was described as using little to no leverage [S7]. Short positions create prime-broker liabilities, which are not financial debt. Net debt, debt/equity and net debt/EBITDA are effectively nil or not applicable.
Cash flow
Capex is zero by nature. Free cash flow is not a meaningful metric for an LIC. The September 2018 buyback cost about AUD 4.7m (10% of about 49m pre-buyback shares × AUD 0.96). This is an analyst estimate derived from the disclosed share count and price. It is not a reported figure and is excluded from the table.
Commentary
FY2017 inflection. MA1's first full year was its worst. The portfolio lost about 9%, in line with the unlisted fund's −8.78% [S2]. That left the LIC trading below its float price and NTA, which started the discount problem that shaped the rest of its life.
FY2018 recovery. The portfolio returned +12.5% and the company earned NPAT of AUD 3.8m. Pre-tax NTA recovered to about AUD 1.01, but the share price stayed at AUD 0.82 [S2], a discount of roughly 19% on those two figures. The 1c dividend was a yield of only about 1.2% [S2].
FY2019–FY2021 capital management. The board tried every standard LIC tool. It ran an off-market buyback at a fixed 5% discount to NTA in September 2018. It issued free bonus options in November 2018, with loyalty options attached. It raised the dividend payout ratio and stepped up investor communication [S3]. Even so, the share price was still at about a 5% discount to NAV in September 2020 [S3].
Termination. At restructure, shareholders received an in-specie capital return of 92.35c and a dividend of 8.27c per share on 9 June 2021, followed by a special franked dividend of 11.8c on 24 August 2021 [S20]. That final dividend distributed the remaining franking credits, which is consistent with a wind-up of the company shell.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansFinancial Detail
Group Structure
| Layer | Entity | Role |
|---|---|---|
Listed vehicle | Monash Absolute Investment Company Limited (ASX: MA1) | Issuer of shares; board oversight |
Investment manager | Monash Investors Pty Limited (ACN 153 180 333; AFSL 417201) | Portfolio management |
Distribution / AFSL arrangements | Winston Capital Partners Pty Ltd (AFSL 469 556) | Monash acted as its authorised representative for general advice (2018) |
Share registry | Boardroom Pty Limited | Registry |
Listed ETMF | Monash Absolute Active Trust (Hedge Fund) / Monash Investors Small Companies Trust (Hedge Fund) (ASX: MAAT; ARSN 642 280 331) | Exchange-traded unit trust (AQUA) |
Responsible entity | The Trust Company (RE Services) Limited (Perpetual), AFSL 235150 | Trustee/RE |
Investment manager | Monash Investors Pty Limited | Portfolio management |
Registry | Apex Fund Services | Unit registry |
Unlisted fund | Monash Investors Small Companies Fund (ARSN 606 855 501), Class A (MON0001AU) and Class B (PIM6813AU) | Successor vehicle |
Responsible entity | The Trust Company (RE Services) Limited | RE |
Investment manager | — | Portfolio management |
Income Statement and Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2018 |
|---|---|
Net profit after tax (AUD Mn) | 3.8 |
Ordinary dividend per share declared (AUD cents) | 1 |
Margin Analysis (%)
| Metric | FY2016 | FY2017 | FY2018 |
|---|---|---|---|
MA1 portfolio return, after fees before tax (%) | -0.26 | -8.97 | 12.52 |
MAIF (unlisted strategy) return (%) | 13.62 | -8.78 | 11.24 |
Margin Analysis (%) (FY2013–FY2015)
| Metric | FY2013 | FY2014 | FY2015 |
|---|---|---|---|
Monash Absolute Investment Fund annual return (%) | 18.53 | 23.05 | 2.21 |
Valuation Snapshot
| Metric | Value | Period |
|---|---|---|
MA1 five-year annualised return | 9.7% p.a. | about 5 years to mid-2021 |
S&P/ASX 200 comparison | 10.1% p.a. | same |
MAIF return since inception (pre-IPO marketing) | 15.91% p.a. net | Jul 2012 to early 2016 |
Monash strategy, nine-year return | 13.2% p.a. | to about Aug 2021 |
MAAT first eight months after fees | more than 14% | to 31 Dec 2021 |
Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2018 |
|---|---|
Pre-tax NTA per share (AUD) | 1.01 |
Financial Analysis
| Metric | FY2017 | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Capex (AUD Mn) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Financial Analysis — ROE
| Ratio | Assessment |
|---|---|
ROE | FY2018 approx. 8%, from NPAT AUD 3.8m over about AUD 46–50m of equity. Analyst estimate, not reported |
ROA | About the same as ROE (minimal liabilities) |
Current ratio | Not meaningful; assets are almost all liquid listed securities and cash |
Debt/equity | About 0 (no borrowings disclosed) |
Management expense ratio | Management fee alone was 1.5% + GST of NAV [S2]. |
Revenue by Region (%)
| Region | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|---|
Australia, share of portfolio investment income (%) | 100 | 100 | 100 |
Share Price
| Metric | 2018 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Reference unit/share price (AUD) | 0.82 | 1.05 | 1.065 | 0.875 | 0.78 | 0.92 |
Per-Share Data and Share Price
| Metric | FY2018 |
|---|---|
MA1 pre-tax NTA per share (AUD) | 1.01 |
MA1 share price (AUD) | 0.82 |
Implied discount to NTA (%) | 18.8 |
Date Paid Details
| Date paid | Type | Amount (AUD cents/share) | Franking |
|---|---|---|---|
31 Oct 2018 | FY2018 final | 1.0 | Fully franked |
30 Oct 2019 | FY2019 dividend | — | — |
30 Oct 2020 | FY2020 dividend | — | 100% franked |
21 Apr 2021 | HY2021 interim | — | Franked |
9 Jun 2021 | Restructure dividend | 8.27 | — |
9 Jun 2021 | In-specie capital return | 92.35 | n/a (capital) |
24 Aug 2021 | Special | 11.8 | Fully franked |
Analyst Conclusions
Management guidance. The only standing objective is double-digit returns over a full cycle while limiting capital loss [S1][S12]. No numerical guidance exists for the successor fund.
Consensus. None. There is no broker coverage.
Bull case
-
A proven small-cap stock-picking franchise. The strategy has compounded since 2012, reaching 13.2% p.a. over nine years by 2021 [S24], and it now sits in a single, lower-cost vehicle without ASX overheads [S8].
-
DMX adds people and capability. A third co-PM with a small/micro-cap specialty, plus a larger combined platform, eases key-person and scale concerns [S8].
-
Small-cap mean reversion. An unlisted fund buying stocks outside the ASX 100 is positioned to benefit if Australian small caps recover relative to large caps [S10].
Bear case
-
Lack of scale persists. A combined manager with about AUD 37m at DMX plus Monash's funds is still very small. Platform access and fee economics remain tough [S8][S6].
-
Mixed record against benchmarks. The LIC's 9.7% p.a. five-year return trailed the ASX 200 [S3], and MAAT's unit price fell markedly between 2021 and 2023 [S29][S27].
-
Execution and continuity risk. Strategy changes in 2023, a structure change in 2024 and an ownership change announced in 2024 create the risk of style drift or team turnover.
Catalysts and monitorables (next 12 months)
-
Confirmation that the DMX acquisition has completed, and the resulting team and ownership structure.
-
Monthly performance of Monash Investors Small Companies Fund Class A (MON0001AU) against the S&P/ASX Small Ordinaries.
-
Changes in funds under management and any further fund mergers or fee changes.
-
Any PDS reissue, change of responsible entity, or research rating action.
-
Ticker hygiene: make sure data systems do not attribute MA Credit Income Trust (ASX: MA1) data to Monash.
Analyst verdict.
Monash Absolute Investment Company Limited is best understood as a case study, not an investable listed company. It was a capable but small boutique strategy placed in a structure that worked against it. Between 2016 and 2021, MA1 delivered reasonable absolute returns of 9.7% p.a. over five years. Yet its shareholders kept suffering from a discount to NTA that reached 16%, and none of the usual remedies fixed it: a fixed-discount buyback, free bonus and loyalty options, and a higher dividend payout. The board and manager deserve credit for putting investors' interests ahead of the manager's "permanent capital." Converting to an ETMF in June 2021 was an industry first, approved by 99.98% of shareholders, and came with a fee cut.
The later history is more sobering. The listed ETMF never reached meaningful scale. It was repositioned toward small caps in 2023 and folded into the unlisted sister fund in June 2024 to save ASX costs. Weeks later, the manager announced its own sale to DMX Asset Management. That sequence points to a business limited mainly by distribution and scale, not by investment ability.
The ticker "MA1" now refers to MA Credit Income Trust, which is unrelated. The economic exposure continues only through the unlisted Monash Investors Small Companies Fund. That fund should be judged as an Australian small-cap active fund on three things: performance against the Small Ordinaries, stability of the team after the DMX deal, and growth in funds under management. Prospective investors should get the current PDS, the latest monthly report and confirmation of the DMX completion before acting. On the evidence available, the vehicle is not ratable as an equity. As a fund, it is a niche, high-conviction small-cap option, and its main uncertainty is the manager's governance and ownership transition, not its investment process.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansExecutive Leadership
Board of Directors
| Name | Role | Tenure | Background |
|---|---|---|---|
Paul Clitheroe (Paul Hugh Clitheroe) | Independent Non-Executive Chairman | Appointed 20 Jan 2016 to wind-up [S15] | — |
Suvan de Soysa | Independent Non-Executive Director | — | — |
Simon Shields | Non-Independent Director | Listed in 2018 [S2] | Co-founder of Monash Investors; former Head of Equities at UBS Asset Management and Colonial First State [S7] |
Paul Jensen (Paul David Kristian Jensen) | Non-Executive Director | Appointed 29 Oct 2020 [S14][S15] | — |
Laura Newell | Company Secretary | — | — |
Executive Leadership Team
| Name | Role | Background |
|---|---|---|
Simon Shields | Co-founder, Principal, Portfolio Manager | Over 30 years' experience; ex-UBS Asset Management and Colonial First State Head of Equities [S7][S25] |
Shane Fitzgerald | Co-founder, Portfolio Manager | Worked with Shields at UBS Asset Management [S7] |
Sebastian Correia | Co-Portfolio Manager | Joined 2018 [S7] |
Michael Haddad | Incoming Co-Portfolio Manager (announced Jul 2024) | Principal of DMX Asset Management; manages the DMX Australian Shares fund [S8] |
Cameron Harris | Business development (acting for Monash) | GSM Capital [S5] |
Board & Management Changes
| Date | Change |
|---|---|
20 Jan 2016 | Paul Clitheroe appointed Chairman |
| 2018 | Sebastian Correia joins manager |
29 Oct 2020 | Paul Jensen appointed director |
Jun 2021 | Board role ends with conversion; Perpetual entity becomes responsible entity of MAAT |
Jul 2024 | Michael Haddad to join as co-PM under DMX transaction |
Competitive Landscape
Key Competitors
| Competitor | Vehicle / ticker | Manager | Relevance |
|---|---|---|---|
L1 Long Short Fund | ASX: LSF | L1 Capital | Large listed Australian long/short LIC; main listed comparator for absolute-return mandates |
Regal Investment Fund | ASX: RF1 | Regal Partners | Listed multi-strategy alternatives trust |
Cadence Capital | ASX: CDM | Cadence Asset Management | Listed long/short equity LIC with a retail investor base |
NAOS Emerging Opportunities | ASX: NCC | NAOS Asset Management | Concentrated listed micro/small-cap LIC |
WAM Microcap | ASX: WMI | Wilson Asset Management | Listed micro-cap LIC with a large retail franchise |
WAM Capital | ASX: WAM | Wilson Asset Management | Listed small/mid-cap LIC; retail distribution benchmark |
Spheria Emerging Companies | ASX: SEC | Spheria Asset Management | Listed small/micro-cap LIC |
DMX Capital Partners / DMX Australian Shares | Unlisted | DMX Asset Management | Small/micro-cap peer that became the announced acquirer [S8] |
Other unlisted Australian small-cap funds | Various | Various boutiques | Direct competitors for the current unlisted fund |
Peer Comparison FY2021
| Dimension | Monash vehicle | Typical scaled peer (e.g., LSF, WAM, RF1) |
|---|---|---|
Scale | About AUD 30–50m (MA1 about AUD 46m in 2018; MAAT about AUD 30m in 2024) | Hundreds of millions to billions |
Fixed-cost burden | High relative to NAV | Lower |
Distribution | Boutique; outsourced business development | In-house retail/adviser distribution |
Track record | Long record since 2012; 9.7% p.a. five-year LIC return [S3] | Varies |
Structure | Moved from LIC to ETMF to unlisted fund | Mostly remain LIC/LIT |
Recent Developments
The 18 months to October 2026 run from roughly April 2025 to October 2026. The successor fund is unlisted and has no continuous-disclosure obligations.
*Data conflict: InvestSMART's Class A page reports two different one-year total returns (8.41% and 6.17%) without clear dates [S10]. Neither can be confirmed against a primary Monash monthly report.
This reflects the entity's delisted, sub-scale status, not an incomplete search.



