Optima Technology Group Limited Overview
Optima Technology Group, which began as BidEnergy and was later Bill Identity, was a Melbourne-based micro-cap SaaS company. It automated how multi-site enterprises collect, validate, pay and report their electricity, gas and water bills. Its core proposition was robotic process automation (RPA) applied to utility invoices. The platform extracted bill data, checked it against contract terms, tariffs and meter data, flagged exceptions before payment, and produced spend and consumption analytics. In 2022 management repositioned that data layer as an audit-grade input for Net Zero (Scope 1 and 2) emissions reporting. It rebranded the group around the 30-year-old UK Optima Energy Systems business acquired in December 2020. The company reached about A$15M of annual revenue but never achieved profitability. It burned roughly A$9–14M a year and depended on repeated equity raises. A customer loss (Origin Energy), falling equity values and an exhausted funding path led to administration in July 2023, liquidation and delisting.
Company's own description (FY2022 Annual Report, paraphrased)
The FY2022 Directors' Report described the principal continuing activities as those of a software technology company. It offered accurate, automated and secure energy data management solutions focused on Net Zero reporting, bill management and procurement planning. In the United States only, the group also earned fees from a rebate business. That business managed the submission of information to energy retailers so that clients could claim rebates under energy-efficiency infrastructure programs.
Independent characterisation
The business was best understood as three economically distinct activities sharing one corporate shell:
-
Utility Bill Management (UBM) SaaS, ANZ. This was the original BidEnergy platform. It sold to large multi-site enterprises directly and through white-label channel partners, notably Origin Energy from 2019 to 2023. Revenue was recurring platform subscription fees. Gross margins were modest for SaaS (about 44–45%), which shows that a meaningful human exception-handling layer sat behind the "automation".
-
Energy data management SaaS, UK/EU. This was the Optima Energy Systems business (founded 1988, Skipton, Yorkshire), acquired December 2020. Its long-tenured software served large end users and energy consultants for bill validation, data loading and contract analysis. Gross margin was about 49–51%.
-
US energy-efficiency rebate administration. This was RealWinWin (Philadelphia), acquired November 2016. It was a transactional, success-fee service with high margins (about 76–84% gross margin) and lumpy, project-dependent revenue. It was classified as non-core in FY2022 and sold in November 2022.
A fourth activity, US UBM platform contracts, was shut down between December 2021 and May 2022. About 20 contracts with negative or low gross profit were exited and reported as a discontinued operation (A$3.29M loss in FY2022).
Business and revenue model
| Revenue stream | Model | FY2022 revenue (AUD K) | Share of continuing revenue | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Platform subscription fees (ANZ + UK/EU) | Recurring SaaS subscription, recognised over service period | 11,691 | 80.1% | FY2022 Annual Report |
| US energy rebate fees | Success / transaction fees, recognised when rebate cash received from utilities | 2,910 | 19.9% | FY2022 Annual Report |
| Non-subscription energy spend review services | Project services, percentage-of-completion | — | — | FY2022 Annual Report (accounting policy) |
| Micro-service licensing (data extraction / validation, US) | Licensing | — | — | FY2022 Annual Report (strategy narrative) |
Mix assessment (FY2022): about 80% subscription and 20% transactional services. There were no meaningful hardware or perpetual-licence revenues.
Value-chain position
The company sat between energy suppliers (retailers and utilities), which issue invoices and meter data, and corporate energy buyers' accounts payable, procurement and sustainability teams. Its main distribution partners were energy retailers (Origin, Simply Energy), energy brokers and consultants, and professional-services firms. It did not own meters, trade energy or carry retail licences.
Customer types and end-markets
Customers: Multi-site enterprises, including telcos (Singtel Optus), not-for-profits (The Salvation Army), US conglomerate units (Berkshire Hathaway business, US), a large US retailer with over 850 stores, BP (UK/EU), and energy retailers' commercial and industrial (C&I) portfolios.
Scale indicators: 92 clients and more than 85,000 meters at 30 June 2019 (Canaccord via FNArena). The Optima UK acquisition added 51 customers and more than 196,000 meters (December 2020, iTWire). Group marketing in 2022 claimed more than 530,000 meters and over £4.9bn of spend under management across six countries (Energy Live News sponsor profile).
End-markets: Corporate energy and utility spend management; ESG / Net Zero emissions data and reporting; US utility energy-efficiency incentive programs.
Strategy
Stated strategy (FY2022 Annual Report and 24 Feb 2022 strategy update, paraphrased)
-
Refocus on Net Zero data. Point the core SaaS data and analytics platform at Net Zero reporting, delivered mainly through channel-partner networks in the UK, Europe, Australia and New Zealand.
-
UK first. Invest "first and fast" in the UK to capture Net Zero tailwinds, then extend the existing channel-partner network into Europe.
-
ANZ stabilisation. Improve platform performance, client retention and profitability rather than chase growth.
-
US minimalism. Serve existing global platform customers and license micro-services (data extraction and validation). Place the rebate business under strategic review, leading to its sale in November 2022.
-
Brand consolidation. Replace the "Bill Identity" brand, which the board considered limiting, with "Optima Technology Group", drawing on 30+ years of Optima brand equity in the UK.
-
Ambition. Become the most accurate SaaS solution for Net Zero reporting (November 2022 ASX release), against a claimed TAM of A$6.4bn across the UK, Europe and Australia.
Initiatives register (last 24 months of corporate life, 2021–2023)
| Initiative | Date | Target / outcome |
|---|---|---|
| US platform restructure (exit of about 20 contracts) | Dec 2021 – May 2022 | About A$4M annualised P&L benefit (company estimate); A$3.29M FY2022 discontinued loss |
| Senior management delayering | FY2022 | About A$2M annualised saving (company estimate) |
| Vendor rationalisation; continued R&D tax claims | FY2022 | Not quantified |
| Capital raising (placement and SPP) | Mar–Jun 2022 | A$8.26M gross raised |
| ANZ–UK platform integration and migration | FY2022 | Ongoing; flagged as a key risk |
| Optima Technology Group rebrand | 13 Jul 2022 | Completed; legal name change Dec 2022 |
| Channel partner build-out (brokers, advisory, consulting, retailers) | 2,022 | Outcomes not disclosed |
| US rebate business sale | Completed 2 Nov 2022 | — |
| Australian BID platform sale process | From May 2023 | Due diligence by several parties; outcome not publicly confirmed before administration |
| ESG / sustainability commitments (own operations) | — | None disclosed; the company stated it was not subject to significant environmental regulation |
Medium-term targets and guidance
The company did not publish formal revenue or EBITDA guidance in the sources reviewed. In 2019 Canaccord Genuity expected break-even across FY2021–FY2022; this did not occur. After the FY2022 results, management said it expected new client wins in the UK and Europe to lift revenue and expected ANZ segment margins to scale with revenue.
Products & Services
Platform segment — ANZ (BidEnergy / Bill Identity platform)
| Product / offering | Description and capabilities | Target customer | Launch / latest | Pricing model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BidEnergy RPA Utility Bill Management platform | Cloud platform that collects bills, validates them, resolves major exceptions before payment, stores data, and checks charges against contract terms, meter data and tariffs. Integrates with accounting systems to pass approved bills to payment files. Provides a portal for bills, meter data, custom reports and analytics. | Multi-site enterprises; energy retailers' C&I portfolios | Core product since mid-2010s; Origin white-label 2019 | Recurring subscription (often per meter / per site; exact tariffs not disclosed) |
| Bid energy auction / procurement marketplace | Marketplace where energy retailers bid for a company's energy spend during contract renewal tendering | Enterprise energy buyers | Pre-2018 (described by Stockhead, 2018) | — |
| Origin Energy white-label service | RPA platform offered under Origin's relationship to its C&I customers | Origin C&I customers (more than 14,500 organisations) | Signed Aug 2019; terminated May 2023 | Services agreement (about A$750k annual revenue at termination) |
| BID Billy | Single-bill RPA solution for franchised single-site businesses, small businesses and households; positioned as zero-cost to consumers via retailers | Residential and SME consumers via retailers and franchise networks | Announced 2018 with August 2018 target launch | Not disclosed; commercial traction not reported |
Platform segment — UK/EU (Optima Energy Systems / Optima Technology)
| Product / offering | Description and capabilities | Target customer | Launch / latest | Pricing model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Optima energy data management software | Bill validation, data loading and contract analysis; energy data analytics | Large energy end users and energy consultants | Business founded 1988; acquired Dec 2020 | Subscription |
| Optima Technology "Collect" | Set-and-forget collation of energy and utility invoices from multiple suppliers | Multi-site enterprises | Branded 2022 | Subscription |
| Optima Technology "Extract" | Extraction of bill data at claimed audit-grade accuracy | Same | 2,022 | Subscription / micro-service licensing |
| Optima Technology "Validate" | Automated validation of invoices against contracts and tariffs | Same | 2,022 | Subscription / micro-service licensing |
| Optima Technology "Measure" | Custom reports on energy use and spend; set baselines and targets; track emissions against global reporting frameworks | Sustainability / ESG teams | 2,022 | Subscription |
| Optima Technology "Manage" | Management of energy use, spend, budgeting and forecasting | Finance and energy managers | 2,022 | Subscription |
| Net Zero reporting (Scope 1 and 2) | Data foundation for baselining and tracking emissions. Company claimed 98% data accuracy versus 70–75% for competitors (company claim). | Corporates with Net Zero commitments | July 2022 rebrand | Subscription |
| EV network management | Listed by data aggregator Pearler as part of the offering | Fleet / EV operators | — | — |
| Procurement planning | Supports energy contract procurement decisions | Enterprise buyers | Ongoing | — |
| "Optix" platform; Bureau Veritas partnership (Collect / Validate / Assure) | Cited only by the aggregator roic.ai | — | — | — |
Rebate segment — US (RealWinWin, a division of Bill Identity)
| Product / offering | Description | Target customer | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rebate Administration | Outsourced identification, creation and capture of utility rebates and incentives for energy-efficient equipment purchases and installations; strategy on combining energy savings, rebate dollars and timelines | Large US multi-site owners and operators (portfolios exceeding one billion sq ft per Ben Franklin profile) | Acquired Nov 2016; sold Nov 2022 |
Discontinued — US Platform
About 20 US Utility Bill Management platform contracts were exited from December 2021 to May 2022. The company estimated a benefit of about A$4M a year from this restructure (FY2022 Annual Report). The group kept "global platform customers" in the US and licensed data-extraction and validation micro-services there.
Financial Narrative
Income statement: notes and sources
Sources: FY2022 Annual Report (Appendix 4E, Directors' Report and five-year table); Market Index / Morningstar for EBITDA and EBIT.
Margins (% of continuing revenue where available)
Net margin is computed as NPAT divided by total revenue (incl. discontinued) from the FY2022 Annual Report five-year table. Market Index shows NPAT margins of -83.18% (FY2021) and -65.34% (FY2022) on a different denominator. The discrepancy is noted; company figures are preferred.
Ratios
ROE (average equity) and ROA are computed from FY2022 Annual Report figures. FY2021 ROA uses closing assets because FY2020 total assets were not available. ROIC is approximated as EBIT (Morningstar) over the sum of equity and debt minus cash, which is not meaningful given net cash and the scale of losses. Net debt / EBITDA and interest coverage are not meaningful (negative EBITDA and EBIT; net cash position). The cash conversion cycle is not meaningful: no inventory, and receivables of A$1.05M against A$14.6M revenue imply roughly 26 days of receivables.
Commentary on trends, inflections and drivers
Revenue scaling without operating leverage. Revenue nearly quadrupled from FY2018 to FY2022 (39% CAGR). However, about half the FY2021 step-up came from acquisitions (the Optima UK consolidation from December 2020) and the lumpy US rebate business. Organic platform growth in FY2022 was 15%, which is respectable but not enough to cover a cost base that consumed about A$27M of supplier and employee payments against A$17.5M of customer receipts in FY2022.
Gross margin compression. Group gross margin fell from 59.4% to 52.5% in FY2022. The main reason was mix: the high-margin rebate segment shrank. Platform gross margins of 44–51% are weak for SaaS and point to a services-heavy delivery model. Software vendors in this category usually run at 65–80% gross margin.
Accounting quality signals. Capitalised R&D labour rose 106% to A$3.95M, and the capitalisation rate rose from 44% to 58%. That flattered reported opex: gross R&D was A$6.79M, or 46% of continuing revenue. Amortisation rose to A$3.75M. Share-based payments of A$4.0M (FY2021) and A$2.0M (FY2022) were large relative to revenue. Management's preferred "Underlying EBITDA" excluded share-based payments, discontinued losses, one-offs, D&A and grants. The gap between Underlying EBITDA (-A$4.8M) and operating cash flow (-A$8.8M) shows the limits of the adjusted measure.
Balance sheet. The company was debt-free in substance. Its solvency depended entirely on cash: A$16.5M at June 2021 and A$10.7M at June 2022, against free cash burn of about A$12.7M in FY2022. Goodwill and intangibles of A$14.9M were about 53% of total assets at June 2022 and had little realisable value in insolvency. The UK assets were sold by administrators for an undisclosed sum, and the Australian operations company was renamed after an apparent asset sale.
Inflection. Management reported quarterly cash outflows improving from -A$4.90M (Q1 FY2022) to -A$2.40M (Q4 FY2022) on a normalised basis that excluded raisings, earn-outs, R&D incentives and FX. Even at the improved run-rate, A$10.7M of cash gave about four quarters of runway. The going-concern note relied on further equity raising. The share price fell from A$0.52 to A$0.06 during FY2022, so equity became prohibitively dilutive. The Origin termination in May 2023 then removed revenue just as funding options closed.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansFinancial Detail
Group Entities
| Entity | Jurisdiction | Role |
|---|---|---|
Bill Identity Limited (later Optima Technology Group Limited) | Australia | Listed parent |
Optima Technology Group (Operations) Pty Ltd (ACN 158 837 097) | Australia | Australian operating entity (in liquidation; renamed ACN 158 837 097 Pty Ltd) |
Optima Management Holdings Ltd | UK | Holding company for Optima UK |
Optima Energy Systems Ltd (Co. No. 02599030) | UK | UK operating company (administration Aug 2023; assets sold to Valsoft) |
Bill Identity Ltd | UK | UK subsidiary |
Bill Identity Inc. | USA | US operations (rebate and platform) |
Revenue by Segment
| Segment | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
ANZ Platform subscription revenue (AUD K) | 6,210 | 7,259 |
UK/EU Platform subscription revenue (AUD K) | 2,614 | 4,432 |
US Energy Rebates revenue (AUD K) | 4,758 | 2,910 |
Total continuing revenue (AUD K) | 13,582 | 14,601 |
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansResults by Segment and Segment Margins & Growth (%)
| Metric | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
ANZ gross profit (AUD K) | 2,791 | 3,191 |
ANZ gross margin (%) | 44.9 | 44.0 |
ANZ segment profit (AUD K) | 511 | 395 |
ANZ segment margin (%) | 8.2 | 5.4 |
UK/EU gross profit (AUD K) | 1,279 | 2,270 |
UK/EU gross margin (%) | 48.9 | 51.2 |
UK/EU segment profit (AUD K) | -75 | 409 |
UK/EU segment margin (%) | -2.9 | 9.2 |
US Rebate gross profit (AUD K) | 3,993 | 2,203 |
US Rebate gross margin (%) | 83.9 | 75.7 |
US Rebate segment profit (AUD K) | 3,535 | 2,009 |
US Rebate segment margin (%) | 74.3 | 69.0 |
Revenue by Segment (%) and Segment Margins & Growth (%)
| Metric | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
ANZ share of continuing revenue (%) | 45.7 | 49.7 |
UK/EU share of continuing revenue (%) | 19.2 | 30.4 |
US Rebate share of continuing revenue (%) | 35.0 | 19.9 |
ANZ revenue growth YoY (%) | — | 17 |
UK/EU revenue growth YoY (%) | — | 70 |
US Rebate revenue growth YoY (%) | — | -39 |
Income Statement and Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Total revenue incl. discontinued (AUD K) | 4,067 | 5,304 | 9,388 | 14,593 | 15,295 |
Revenue from continuing operations (AUD K) | — | — | — | 13,582 | 14,601 |
Platform subscription revenue (AUD K) | — | — | — | 8,824 | 11,691 |
Gross profit, continuing (AUD K) | — | — | — | 8,063 | 7,664 |
Underlying EBITDA, company definition (AUD K) | — | — | — | -2,854 | -4,755 |
EBITDA, Morningstar definition (AUD K) | — | — | — | -10,630 | -5,462 |
EBIT, Morningstar (AUD K) | — | — | — | -12,158 | -9,761 |
Loss before tax, total (AUD K) | -4,528 | -6,600 | -6,893 | -13,126 | -13,879 |
Net loss after tax (AUD K) | -4,518 | -6,566 | -6,911 | -12,923 | -13,630 |
Basic EPS (A$ cents) | -4.47 | -6.00 | -5.52 | -8.65 | -7.73 |
Diluted EPS (A$ cents) | -4.47 | -6.00 | -5.52 | -8.65 | -7.73 |
Dividends per share (A$ cents) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Margin Analysis (%)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gross margin (%) | — | — | — | 59.4 | 52.5 |
Underlying EBITDA margin (%) | — | — | — | -21.0 | -32.6 |
Net margin on total revenue (%) | -111.1 | -123.8 | -73.6 | -88.6 | -89.1 |
Valuation Snapshot
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
Total revenue CAGR FY2018–FY2022 (%) | 39.3 |
Total revenue growth FY2022 (%) | 4.8 |
Continuing revenue growth FY2022 (%) | 7.5 |
Platform subscription revenue growth FY2022 (%) | 32.5 |
Platform subscription organic growth FY2022 (%) | 15 |
Cost line
| Cost line | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Sales and marketing (AUD K) | -4,092 | -4,851 |
R&D, net of capitalisation (AUD K) | -2,480 | -2,841 |
Corporate costs (AUD K) | -4,345 | -4,727 |
Significant one-off items (AUD K) | -988 | -803 |
EBITDA from discontinued operations (AUD K) | -2,851 | -3,287 |
Depreciation and amortisation (AUD K) | -2,497 | -4,299 |
Share-based payments (AUD K) | -4,027 | -1,956 |
Other income (AUD K) | 123 | 1,263 |
Finance costs (AUD K) | -32 | -42 |
Tax benefit (AUD K) | 203 | 249 |
Balance Sheet and Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
Cash and cash equivalents (AUD K) | 8,296 | 16,455 | 10,680 |
Total current assets (AUD K) | — | 18,710 | 12,158 |
Intangibles incl. goodwill (AUD K) | — | 15,155 | 14,922 |
Total assets (AUD K) | — | 35,215 | 27,975 |
Current liabilities (AUD K) | — | 6,902 | 5,238 |
Borrowings, current (AUD K) | — | 304 | 0 |
Borrowings, non-current (AUD K) | — | 219 | 217 |
Lease liabilities, total (AUD K) | — | 951 | 543 |
Total debt incl. leases (AUD K) | — | 1,474 | 760 |
Net debt, negative = net cash (AUD K) | — | -14,981 | -9,920 |
Total liabilities (AUD K) | — | 8,795 | 6,257 |
Total equity (AUD K) | 8,918 | 26,420 | 21,718 |
Working capital (AUD K) | — | 11,808 | 6,920 |
Accumulated losses (AUD K) | -29,972 | -42,759 | -56,359 |
Issued capital (AUD K) | 37,007 | 64,802 | 73,543 |
NTA per share (A$ cents) | — | 7.51 | 3.02 |
Cash Flow
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Receipts from customers (AUD K) | — | — | — | 15,788 | 17,503 |
Operating cash flow (AUD K) | — | — | — | -5,632 | -8,826 |
Capex, plant and equipment (AUD K) | — | — | — | -191 | -91 |
Capitalised development (AUD K) | — | — | — | -1,921 | -3,751 |
Free cash flow (AUD K) | — | — | — | -7,744 | -12,668 |
Acquisitions incl. earn-out (AUD K) | — | — | — | -6,033 | -768 |
Equity raised, gross (AUD K) | — | — | — | 23,054 | 8,262 |
Dividends paid (AUD K) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Share buybacks (AUD K) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Returns & Leverage Ratios (%) and Financial Ratios (x)
| Ratio | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
ROE on average equity (%) | -73.1 | -56.6 |
ROE, Morningstar basis (%) | -45.39 | -43.93 |
ROA (%) | -36.7 | -43.1 |
ROIC (%) | -88.4 | -63.2 |
Current ratio (x) | 2.71 | 2.32 |
Debt to equity incl. leases (x) | 0.06 | 0.03 |
Asset turnover, continuing revenue / average assets (x) | 0.39 | 0.46 |
Revenue by Region
| Region | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Australia and New Zealand revenue (AUD K) | 6,210 | 7,259 |
United Kingdom and Europe revenue (AUD K) | 2,614 | 4,432 |
United States revenue, continuing rebate (AUD K) | 4,758 | 2,910 |
Region Overview
| Region | FY2022 growth (%) |
|---|---|
ANZ | 17 |
UK/EU | 70 |
US (continuing) | -39 |
Share Price and Market Valuation
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Share price at FY start (AUD) | 0.02 | 0.34 | 0.83 | 0.62 | 0.52 |
Share price at FY end (AUD) | 0.05 | 0.83 | 0.62 | 0.52 | 0.06 |
Market capitalisation at FY end (AUD Mn) | — | — | — | 84.62 | 13.90 |
Shares outstanding at FY end (M) | — | — | — | 162.72 | 243.94 |
Share Price & Returns
| Horizon | Return |
|---|---|
1-year | Not applicable; delisted 28 Aug 2023 with no trading |
3-year | Not applicable; delisted |
5-year | Not applicable on a traded basis. From about A$0.52 (June 2021) to delisting at about A$0.02 is a loss of about 96%, and equity value in liquidation is likely nil (the liquidators' Nov 2024 agenda included expected returns to shareholders; the outcome was not located). |
Valuation Multiples (x) and Market Valuation
| Metric | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
P/E (x) | -6.40 | -1.05 |
Price to book (x) | 3.16 | 0.64 |
Price to cash flow (x) | -12.12 | -5.49 |
Enterprise value (AUD Mn) | 69.63 | 3.98 |
EV to continuing revenue (x) | 5.13 | 0.27 |
Capital Markets
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
Analyst consensus | None current. Historical: Canaccord Genuity Buy, A$1.50 target (Aug 2019). Simply Wall St listed one covering analyst (date unknown). |
Dividend history and policy | No dividends paid or declared FY2018–FY2022 (FY2022 AR; Market Index) |
Credit ratings (Moody's / S&P / Fitch) | Not rated |
Debt maturity profile | Negligible. A$0.22M non-current borrowings and A$0.54M lease liabilities at June 2022. |
Equity raises (selected) | A$15M at A$1.07 (Dec 2020); A$6M at A$0.105 plus about A$2.2M SPP at A$0.105 (Mar–May 2022) |
Analyst Conclusions
Management guidance and consensus
No guidance or consensus exists. The company has been in liquidation since 15 August 2023 and off the ASX since 28 August 2023. The last management outlook (FY2022 AR, August 2022) expected UK and European client wins to drive revenue and expected ANZ profitability to improve. Neither was demonstrated before the collapse.
Bull-case arguments (historical, as they stood in mid-2022)
-
Recurring revenue with improving unit economics. Platform subscription revenue grew 32% to A$11.7M. UK/EU segment margin turned from -2.9% to +9.2%. Normalised quarterly cash burn halved from -A$4.9M to -A$2.4M within FY2022.
-
Structural Net Zero demand. UK reporting mandates and corporate commitments (over 47% of the ASX 200, per the company) favoured audit-grade utility data. The Optima brand gave credible entry to that market.
-
Asset value above market price. At June 2022 the enterprise value was about A$4M against A$14.6M of revenue and A$10.7M of cash. Valsoft's subsequent purchase of the UK assets confirms that the operating assets had strategic value to a buyer.
Bear-case arguments (which proved correct)
-
Burn exceeded runway. FY2022 free cash flow of -A$12.7M against A$10.7M of cash, with a going-concern assumption that relied on equity at a share price down about 90% in a year.
-
Channel concentration and insourcing. The Origin white-label channel was terminated in favour of an in-house build, showing that large retailers can replicate the core RPA function.
-
Sub-scale, low-margin "SaaS". Gross margins of 44–51% and gross R&D at 46% of revenue meant breakeven needed revenue far beyond any reasonable near-term growth path. The most profitable segment (US rebates, 69% segment margin) was sold for cash.
Catalysts and monitorables (next 12 months)
| Item | Relevance |
|---|---|
| Liquidators' reports to creditors (Deloitte) | Final dividend to creditors; confirmation of any return to shareholders (expected nil) |
| Decision on pooling the parent and operations subsidiary | Affects creditor recoveries |
| ASIC deregistration of ACN 131 445 335 and ACN 158 837 097 | Formal end of the corporate entities |
| UK administration closure (Optima Energy Systems Ltd) | Completion of the UK estate |
| Valsoft / Aspire stewardship of the Optima UK product | The surviving operating legacy, now private |
| Identity of the buyer of the Australian BID platform (if any) | Not publicly confirmed; relevant to former customers |
Concluding analyst verdict
Bill Identity Limited no longer exists as an investable security. The entity was renamed Optima Technology Group Limited, failed, and was removed from the ASX on 28 August 2023, about seven weeks after directors called in administrators and thirteen days after creditors voted to liquidate it. Former shareholders should treat their equity as having no recoverable value unless the liquidators report otherwise, and nothing published indicates a surplus.
The company's history is a clear example of a capital-intensive land-grab in a commoditised niche. BidEnergy correctly saw that utility invoices are messy, high-volume and error-prone, and that automation could cut processing costs. It won credible logos (Optus, Salvation Army, Origin) and bought a respected UK franchise. But it never built software economics. Platform gross margins stayed near 50%, gross R&D approached half of revenue, and expansion went into a US platform business so unprofitable that it had to be shut within 18 months. Strategy changed repeatedly: auction marketplace, SME "BID Billy", US platform, Net Zero data. Each pivot was funded with equity at falling prices, from A$1.07 in December 2020 to A$0.105 in March 2022.
The fatal combination came in 2022–2023. Equity markets stopped funding loss-making small-cap tech. The company sold its only high-margin segment. Then its most important channel partner, Origin, decided to build the capability in-house. With about four quarters of runway at June 2022 and no debt capacity, a single customer loss was enough to trigger insolvency.
The surviving value moved to private owners: Valsoft holds the UK Optima business, and the Australian platform appears to have changed hands on undisclosed terms. For analysts, the lessons are to scrutinise gross margins behind "automation" claims, to treat channel partners as potential competitors, and to measure runway on free cash flow rather than adjusted EBITDA.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansExecutive Leadership
Executive Leadership Team
| Name | Role | Tenure | Prior roles and background | Other listed boards (at FY2022) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Peter Tonagh | Non-Executive Chairman | From 4 Jan 2021 | Former CEO, Foxtel and News Corp Australia; former COO and nine years as Foxtel CFO. B Comm, MBA (INSEAD). Deputy Chair, ABC. | Chairman, GTN Limited; former Lead Independent Director, Village Roadshow |
Michele Garra | Managing Director and CEO | CEO from 29 Nov 2021; MD from 31 Jan 2022 | Senior executive roles at Telstra, Sony Pictures Home Entertainment, Optus | — |
Leanne Graham | Independent NED | Pre-FY2021 to at least FY2022 | NZ software entrepreneur; former Xero country manager; GeoOp CEO (NZX listing 2015); MNZM 2018 | archTIS (NED) |
Geoffrey Kleemann | NED | Pre-FY2021 to at least FY2022 | CFO of Crown, PBL, Woolworths, Pioneer International; started at Deloitte. CPA. | Domain Holdings Australia (NED) |
David Hancock | NED | From 1 Sep 2020 (company AR); ASX release dated 27 Aug 2020 | Executive Director and Group Head, Afterpay Touch; CEO Tower Insurance; MD JPMorgan; CBA roles. BBus, GAICD. | Former: Afterpay, ELMO Software |
Shane Gild | NED | From 28 Jul 2022 | Former Executive Director, Canaccord Genuity; Senior Director, Deutsche Bank | PayGroup; The Sustainable Nutrition Group |
Prateek Munjal | CFO | From 31 Mar 2022 | Not detailed | — |
Lior Harel | Company Secretary and General Counsel | FY2022 | GC and CoSec, Cronos Australia; about 7 years Chief Legal Counsel, SEEK; Arnold Bloch Leibler. LLB/BA (Melbourne). | — |
Guy Maine | Former MD and CEO | 17 Jan 2018 – 30 Sep 2021 | Ex-Virgin, Foxtel, Optus executive (Stockhead) | — |
Fionn O'Keeffe | Former CFO | 23 Nov 2020 – 31 Mar 2022 | Not detailed | — |
Directors' Remuneration
| Name | Cash salary and fees | Cash bonus | Termination | Super | Equity-settled | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Peter Tonagh | 120,000 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 9,955 | 129,955 |
Michele Garra | 280,737 | 0 | 0 | 25,522 | 282,640 | 608,374 |
Leanne Graham | 72,500 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 86,146 | 158,646 |
Geoffrey Kleemann | 72,831 | 0 | 0 | 6,621 | 104,260 | 183,712 |
David Hancock | 50,229 | 0 | 0 | 4,566 | 132,493 | 187,288 |
Guy Maine | 110,140 | 82,500 | 127,500 | 7,650 | 257,590 | 568,119 |
Prateek Munjal | 221,278 | 0 | 0 | 20,116 | 45,041 | 304,006 |
Fionn O'Keeffe | 227,116 | 55,000 | 0 | 19,125 | 45,870 | 344,600 |
Total KMP | 1,154,831 | 137,500 | 127,500 | 83,600 | 963,995 | 2,484,700 |
Major Shareholders
| Holder | Interest | Date | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
David Hancock (NED) | 5,217,549 shares (about 2.1%) | 30 Jun 2022 | FY2022 Annual Report |
Shane Gild (NED) | 2,190,952 shares | Aug 2022 | FY2022 Annual Report |
Peter Tonagh (Chair) | 1,590,352 shares | 30 Jun 2022 | FY2022 Annual Report |
Geoffrey Kleemann | 799,640 shares | 30 Jun 2022 | FY2022 Annual Report |
Leanne Graham | 330,197 shares | 30 Jun 2022 | FY2022 Annual Report |
Michele Garra | 300,000 shares | 30 Jun 2022 | FY2022 Annual Report |
Tiga Trading Pty Ltd; TEK (Thorney-associated) | — | Nov 2021 | ASX announcement list |
Competitive Landscape
Competitors by Segment
| Segment | Competitor | Type | Relevance |
|---|---|---|---|
UBM / energy data (UK) | Inspired PLC (incl. Energy Cost Management, SystemsLink, Ignite) | Listed UK energy consultancy and software roll-up | Direct UK UBM / bill validation competitor (Verdantix) |
UBM / energy procurement (UK) | Accenture (EnergyQuote JHA, acquired 2015) | Global consultancy | Bundled procurement and bill management |
UBM / energy data (UK / Europe) | Wattics | Energy analytics SaaS | Named Optima competitor (Owler) |
Energy procurement (UK) | Utility Bidder | Broker / platform | Named Optima competitor (Owler) |
Energy software (UK) | Next Control Systems | Energy management software | Named Optima competitor (Owler) |
ESG / carbon data (Global, incl. ANZ) | IBM Envizi | Enterprise sustainability data platform | Head-on competitor in the Net Zero data pivot |
UBM / sustainability (Global) | Schneider Electric (Resource Advisor / sustainability services) | Global energy-management major | Enterprise UBM and ESG |
UBM (Global) | Engie Impact | Utility-affiliated sustainability services | Enterprise UBM |
Utility data access (Global) | Arcadia (incl. former Urjanet) | Utility data API / platform | Data-extraction substitute |
Utility bill pay (US) | Cass Information Systems; Conservice | Bill payment and processing | US UBM competition behind the exited US platform |
Rebates (US) | Rebate Bus; Encentiv Energy; Enercon; Energy Federation | Rebate and incentive specialists | Competitors to RealWinWin (Bouncewatch) |
In-house build | Origin Energy and other retailers | Customer insourcing | Origin replaced the BID platform with an in-house build (2023) |
Competitor Detail
| Metric | Optima / Bill Identity (FY2022) |
|---|---|
Revenue | A$14.6M continuing |
Revenue growth | 7.5% (continuing) |
Gross margin | 52.5% |
R&D intensity (gross) | 46.5% of revenue |
Profitability | Loss of A$13.6M |



