Company ProfilePremium

Scully Royalty Ltd.

Company Profile Analysis

Ticker: SRL

ESOMAR 23 Corporate BadgeISO Certifications Badge
Scully Royalty Ltd. - Company showcase

Year Founded & Workforce

2017

Scully Royalty Ltd. logo

Scully Royalty Ltd. Employee Contacts

We don't hold contact details for this company yet — you can request them.

Request Employee Contacts

Scully Royalty Ltd. Overview

Scully Royalty Ltd. is a Cayman Islands holding company listed on the NYSE. Its value rests overwhelmingly on one asset: a net revenues royalty over Mining Lease Lot No. 1 of the Scully iron ore mine in Wabush, Labrador. The royalty pays 7.0% of revenue on ore shipped from the mine and 4.2% on ore derived from tailings, with a floor of C$3.25m a year. The sub-lease runs to 2055. The mine is operated by Tacora Resources Inc., which was recapitalised in 2024 by Cargill, Millstreet and O'Brien-Staley. It produces a premium concentrate grading about 65.9% Fe that is suited to lower-emission steelmaking. Around this core sits a legacy cluster of European merchant banking, German industrial real estate and non-core assets inherited from the MFC Bancorp era, which management has been divesting. Since late 2025 the investment case has been dominated by an unresolved control contest between incumbent management and holders of about 48.5% of the shares. That contest has frozen royalty cash in an Ontario court, delayed audited reporting and led to an NYSE trading suspension.


Company's own description (FY2024 Form 20-F, filed 30 April 2025)

The FY2024 20-F describes the core asset as a net revenues royalty interest in the Scully Mine in Newfoundland and Labrador. The rate is 7.0% on iron ore shipped from the mine and 4.2% on ore shipped from tailings and other disposed material. The royalty is held through a mining sub-lease, which carries a minimum royalty of C$3.25m per year payable quarterly; those quarterly minimums can be credited against earned royalties for the same calendar year.

From 1 January 2024 the company reorganised its reporting into two primary operating segments:

Royalty: the iron ore interest.

Merchant Banking: regulated merchant banking in Europe through a Maltese credit institution, plus two industrial real estate parks in Germany held as investment property.

An "All Other" segment absorbs corporate activities and the former Industrial segment, which was eliminated in 2024.

The company describes itself as specialising in markets not adequately served by traditional sources of supply and finance. It emphasises a partnership approach with small and mid-sized enterprises, under which it may also commit proprietary capital.

The latest corporate releases (July 2026) use a shorter description: the company simply holds a net revenues royalty interest on the Scully Iron Ore Mine.

Independent characterisation

Economically, SRL is a single-asset, non-operating bulk-commodity royalty vehicle wrapped in a legacy conglomerate shell. Four features define it.

1. Revenue model.

  • The royalty is a pure percentage-of-revenue stream. The company bears no operating or capital costs, but it also has no operating control and very limited access to technical data. Management states it requested a technical report summary from the operator and was refused.

  • Royalty income is exposed to three things: Tacora's shipped tonnage, the seaborne 65% Fe iron ore price (including the premium over the 62% Fe benchmark), and the US$/C$ exchange rate.

  • Royalty receipts are subject to a 20% Newfoundland and Labrador provincial mining tax. The company recognised resource property revenue tax of C$3.9m in FY2024 and C$6.9m in FY2023.

2. Revenue mix (FY2024, C$35.3m total).

By product (FY2024 revenue note), revenue from royalty, goods/products and services of C$24.3m comprised C$20.0m of royalty, C$4.2m of energy and C$0.06m of fees. The balance of total revenue is interest, fair-value and other investment items.

  • There is no subscription or product revenue in the conventional sense. The business is best described as roughly 60–85% licensing-style royalty and the rest financial services and asset income.

  • In H1 2025, 83% of revenue came from iron ore royalties.

3. Value-chain position. SRL sits at the very top of the iron ore value chain as a rent collector on the mining lease. Below it are:

  • Tacora: open-pit mining and the 6 Mtpa concentrator.

  • Rail: the QNS&L railway to Arnaud Junction, then Société du Plan Nord-owned track to Pointe-Noire, Sept-Îles.

  • Ship loading at the Port of Sept-Îles.

  • Cargill, the 100% offtaker under a life-of-mine rolling option.

  • Steelmakers in Asia, Europe and the Middle East.

4. Customer types and end-markets.

  • The royalty "customer" is a single counterparty, Tacora. It accounted for 57% of consolidated revenue in FY2024, 64% in FY2023 and 45% in FY2022 (20-F customer concentration note).

  • The ultimate end-market is integrated steelmaking. That includes blast-furnace producers who value high-grade, low-impurity feed for yield and emissions reasons, and potentially direct-reduction / "green steel" routes.

  • Merchant banking customers are European corporates, suppliers and group members. The bank is not a retail or commercial lender.

Strategy

Stated strategy (paraphrased; FY2024 20-F letter and Item 4)

  1. Focus on the core royalty. Maximise earnings and dividends from the Scully iron ore royalty.

  2. Rationalise non-core assets. Divest underperforming legacy holdings in All Other to simplify the structure and concentrate capital and management attention.

  3. Close the valuation discount. Restructure the group to substantially reduce the gap between share price and net book value per share. Management benchmarks against Labrador Iron Ore Royalty, Deterra Royalties and Mesabi Trust.

  4. Maintain liquidity. Keep ample liquid assets and working capital, and use bank-subsidiary facilities secured on government securities when risk-adjusted returns justify it.

  5. Dividend policy. Pay cash dividends based on royalty receipts and the operator's condition.

Initiatives in the last 24 months

InitiativeDateDetailStatus
Rationalisation of All Other assetsH1 2024 onwardAssets held for sale of C$88.5m (FY2024) and C$85.9m (H1 2025); expected consideration of about C$15m securities plus about C$55.4m equity-method stakeCompletion was expected in 2025; not reported closed as of the latest filings
Segment simplification1 Jan 2024Industrial segment eliminatedDone
Bond refinancing2,024€25m bonds extended to Aug 2033 at 5.70%Done
Treasury yield enhancement2,024Cash redeployed into term deposits and short-dated government securitiesDone
Dividend resumptionDec 2024 / Feb 2025C$0.37 per sharePaid; 2026 policy deferred until the FY2025 20-F is filed
Defence against activist controlNov 2025–presentLitigation in the Cayman Grand Court and Court of Appeal and in Ontario courtsOngoing; incumbents won the July 2026 Grand Court judgment
Auditor replacement and FY2025 20-F filingMar 2026–presentNeeded to cure the NYSE delinquency and resume tradingPending
Potential recovery against the MILFAM GroupJul 2026The company referenced potential options to recover against MILFAMUnconfirmed

Activist strategy (Reporting Group, 13D/A filings)

  • Replace the incumbent board through the 12 Jan 2027 EGM. The filings imply a strategy to cut overhead, consolidate around the royalty, and potentially pursue capital return or a sale.

  • The specific operating plan has not been publicly disclosed in the filings retrieved.

ESG and sustainability commitments

None disclosed beyond the "green steel" positioning of the high-grade product.

Medium-term financial targets and guidance

Not publicly disclosed. The company does not issue earnings guidance. The operator Tacora has disclosed a multi-year capital investment and ramp-up plan to return the mine to nameplate capacity of about 6 Mtpa, compared with about 3.1 Mt shipped in 2024. At constant price and FX, that would roughly double gross royalty revenue.

Products & Services

Royalty segment

OfferingDescription and specificationsCounterpartyStart / termPricing
Scully Mine net revenues royalty (Mining Lease Lot No. 1)7.0% of revenue on iron ore products (concentrate, pellets, chips) shipped from the mine; 4.2% on ore from tailings and disposed materialTacora Resources Inc., under the mining sub-lease with 1128349 B.C. Ltd.Lease commenced 1956; expires 2055Percentage of revenue, with a minimum of C$3.25m a year paid quarterly and creditable against same-year earned royalty
Underlying ore product (reference)Concentrate about 65.9% Fe with low silica and manganese and very low moisture. Concentrator capacity about 6.0–6.25 Mtpa; plant rate up to 2,400 tph. Life-of-mine strip ratio 0.87:1. Forecast mine life over 25 yearsCargill buys 100% of output under rolling life-of-mine optionsRestarted 2019Linked to the Platts 65% Fe index. In 2024 the 65% Fe index averaged about US$123/t versus US$109/t for 62% Fe, a premium of about 13% (US$14)
MetricFY2023FY2024
Iron ore products shipped (tonnes)3,535,2383,060,800

Quarterly reference points (6-K dividend releases, 2022):

  • Q1 2022: 767,630 t, with a gross royalty of about C$11.8m.

  • Q2 2022: 923,553 t, with a royalty of C$5.89m, gross of the 20% provincial mining tax.

The large drop in royalty per tonne between Q1 and Q2 2022 illustrates the price sensitivity of the stream.

Merchant Banking segment

OfferingDescriptionTarget customerPricing
Specialty merchant banking (the Bank, Malta)Financial and consultancy services, trade-related finance and investment income. No retail or general commercial banking.Group customers, suppliers and mid-market corporatesFees, spreads and investment income; not disclosed by product
Treasury / liquidity facilitiesBorrowing facilities secured on short-term government securities; undrawn at 31 Dec 2024Internal—
Arneburg industrial park (Germany)1,553,113 m²; about 27 buildings; greenfield land, warehouses, production halls, workshops and offices; rail, road and harbour linksIndustrial tenantsRental income
Dessau industrial park (Germany)109,804 m²; about 21 buildings; offices, production halls, warehouses and land; rail and road linksIndustrial tenantsRental income

All Other / held-for-sale assets

Asset groupDescriptionFY2024 metrics
Former Industrial / legacy businesses (including energy and PRC-held cash)Classified as held for sale under IFRS 5; about 20% of total assetsGross assets C$88.5m; liabilities C$18.1m; net C$70.4m. 2024 third-party revenue C$9.0m; pre-tax loss C$3.3m; net loss C$4.5m; impairment C$18.6m
Expected disposal considerationManagement expected to recognise about C$15m of securities and about C$55.4m as an equity-method investment on closingNot reported closed as of the H1 2025 report; held for sale still C$85.9m at 30 Jun 2025

Named product launches, pricing tiers and versioning: not applicable. The company has no consumer or enterprise product catalogue.

Financial Narrative

All figures are in C$ millions unless stated, for fiscal years ending 31 December, under IFRS.

Unlock Company Financials

Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.

View Subscription Plans

Financial Detail

Group Entities

SubsidiaryJurisdictionInterestFunction

Merkanti Holding plc

Malta

99.96%

Holding company for the regulated bank. Its bonds are listed on the Malta Stock Exchange.

1178936 B.C. Ltd.

Canada (British Columbia)

100%

Canadian holding entity

1128349 B.C. Ltd. ("112")

Canada (British Columbia)

Not stated in the 20-F table; identified in court records as the royalty-holding counterparty

Party with Tacora to the mining sub-lease under which the royalty is paid (MILFAM PR 12 Feb 2026; 2026 ONCA 306)

The "Bank" (Maltese credit institution)

Malta

Indirect via Merkanti

Specialty merchant banking regulated under the EU CRD/CRR framework

German industrial park entities (Arneburg, Dessau)

Germany

Indirect

Investment property; security for the €25m bonds

PRC subsidiary (part of assets held for sale)

China

Indirect

Holds RMB cash classified within assets held for sale

Segment Overview

SegmentContentsStatus

Royalty

7.0% / 4.2% net revenues royalty on Scully Mine Lot No. 1

Core asset

Merchant Banking

Maltese bank (fees, consultancy, investment income); two German industrial real estate parks

Retained

Industrial (to FY2023)

Resource and service assets, including hydrocarbon interests (sold March 2023) and other industrial assets

Eliminated 1 Jan 2024; residual assets moved to All Other

All Other

Corporate plus small entities; from FY2024 also the former Industrial assets, largely classified as held for sale

Being rationalised

Royalty

Americas

Canada (Newfoundland and Labrador); 57% of FY2024 revenue came from one Canadian customer

Merchant Banking

Europe

Malta (bank); Germany (Arneburg and Dessau parks)

All Other / held for sale

Asia and Europe

China (RMB-denominated assets); other

Revenue by Segment

SegmentFY2020FY2021FY2022FY2023FY2024

Royalty revenue (CAD Mn)

33.340.329.235.320.1

Industrial revenue (CAD Mn; segment eliminated FY2024)

17.723.428.512.20

Merchant Banking revenue (CAD Mn)

—6.55.57.46.2

All Other revenue (CAD Mn; FY2024 includes ex-Industrial)

01.00.509.0

Total revenue (CAD Mn)

59.471.363.754.935.3

Unlock Company Financials

Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.

View Subscription Plans

Results by Segment

SegmentFY2023FY2024

Royalty pre-tax income (CAD Mn)

11.1-3.5

Industrial pre-tax income (CAD Mn)

10.10

Merchant Banking pre-tax income (CAD Mn)

-0.11.8

All Other pre-tax income (CAD Mn)

-11.0-17.4

Total pre-tax income (CAD Mn)

10.2-19.0

Segment Margins & Growth (%) and Revenue by Segment (%)

MetricFY2022FY2023FY2024

Royalty pre-tax margin (%)

—31.5-17.3

Royalty revenue YoY growth (%)

-27.520.9-43.1

Royalty share of total revenue (%)

45.864.356.9

Merchant Banking revenue YoY growth (%)

-15.434.5-16.2

Merchant Banking share of total revenue (%)

8.613.417.6

Segment Revenue

SegmentH1 2024H1 2025

Royalty revenue

10.610.2

Merchant Banking revenue

3.23.5

All Other revenue

4.34.8

Total revenue

18.118.6

Income Statement and Per-Share Data

MetricFY2020FY2021FY2022FY2023FY2024

Revenue (CAD Mn)

59.471.363.754.935.3

Gross profit (CAD Mn)

29.838.233.635.828.2

EBITDA (CAD Mn; FY2023–24 derived as pre-tax + interest + D&A from Note 5)

———19.9-9.3

Pre-tax income (CAD Mn)

11.217.5-24.010.2-19.0

Income tax expense / (recovery) (CAD Mn; incl. resource tax where reported)

—10.2-0.5——

Net income attributable to shareholders (CAD Mn)

0.47.6-23.41.4-20.6

EPS basic (CAD)

0.030.51-1.580.09-1.39

EPS diluted (CAD)

0.030.51-1.580.09-1.39

Cash dividends declared per share (C$; by payment year)

001.130.230

Margin Analysis (%)

MetricFY2020FY2021FY2022FY2023FY2024

Gross margin (%)

50.253.652.765.279.9

EBITDA margin (%)

———36.2-26.3

Pre-tax margin (%)

18.924.5-37.718.6-53.9

Net margin (%)

0.610.6-36.72.5-58.4

Revenue YoY growth (%)

-47.520.0-10.7-13.8-35.7

Balance Sheet and Per-Share Data

MetricFY2021FY2023FY2024

Total assets (CAD Mn)

—452.5438.1

Cash and equivalents (CAD Mn; excludes held-for-sale cash)

—78.319.1

Short-term securities (CAD Mn)

—13.023.5

Short-term debt (CAD Mn)

—00

Long-term bonds payable (CAD Mn)

—36.136.5

Long-term loan payable (CAD Mn)

—7.60

Total debt (CAD Mn)

—43.736.5

Net debt (CAD Mn; negative = net cash, after ST securities)

—-47.6-6.0

Deferred income tax liabilities (CAD Mn)

—58.451.5

Total liabilities (CAD Mn)

—122.8127.8

Shareholders' equity (CAD Mn)

—322.5302.3

Book value per share (CAD)

24.7421.7620.39

Royalty interest carrying value (CAD Mn)

——192.1

Current assets (CAD Mn)

—164.5175.3

Current liabilities (CAD Mn)

—20.638.5

Working capital (CAD Mn)

—144.0136.8

Per-Share Data and Cash Flow

MetricFY2020FY2021FY2022FY2023FY2024

Free cash flow per share (C$; aggregator roic.ai)

-1.45-0.522.041.75-0.32

Free cash flow (CAD Mn; derived from per-share × weighted shares)

-21.4-7.730.225.9-4.8

Dividends paid (CAD Mn; derived from DPS × shares)

0016.73.40

Share buybacks (CAD Mn)

00000

Returns & Leverage Ratios (%) and Financial Ratios (x)

RatioFY2023FY2024

ROE (%; NI ÷ closing equity)

0.4-6.8

ROA (%; NI ÷ closing assets)

0.3-4.7

Current ratio (x)

8.04.6

Debt/equity (x)

0.140.12

Net debt/EBITDA (x; negative = net cash)

-2.40.6

Interest coverage (x; (pre-tax + interest) ÷ interest)

6.8-6.6

Asset turnover (x)

0.120.08

Segment Overview — Royalty

SegmentHow revenue is attributed geographically

Royalty

Location of operations (Canada)

Merchant Banking

Location of external customers or reporting units, whichever is appropriate

All Other

Location of reporting units

Revenue by Region (%)

RegionFY2018FY2019H1 2021H1 2025

Europe (% of revenue)

85775.719

Americas (% of revenue)

111791.468

Asia, Africa and other (% of revenue)

462.913

Share Price History

DatePriceNote / source

15 Dec 2025

about 5.30 € (L&S Germany)

Aktien.guide

1 May 2026

6.91

Trendlyne; 33.5% below the 52-week high

10 Jul 2026

5.07

Trivano

21 Jul 2026

5.13

StocksGuide

24 Sep 2026

5.08

ad-hoc-news; 51.1% below the 52-week high of US$10.39

Share Price & Returns

HorizonPerformance

1-year

Approximately -40% to -50% from the 52-week high.

Valuation Snapshot

MultipleValueBasis

Market capitalisation (USD Mn)

77

Calculated

P/B (x)

0.36

Book value per share C$20.39, about US$14.2

EV/Sales (x)

about 2.0–3.0

EV of about US$73m (net cash of about C$6m) over FY2024 revenue of C$35.3m (about US$25m); sensitive to how held-for-sale cash is treated

Per-Share Data

MetricFY2020FY2021FY2022FY2023FY2024FY2025

Cash dividends paid per share (CAD)

001.130.2300.37

Payment Date Details

Payment dateC$US$Royalty reference

4 Mar 2022

0.250.18—

23 May 2022

0.340.27

Q1 2022 royalty of about C$11.8m

26 Aug 2022

0.330.26

Q2 2022 royalty of C$5.89m

6 Dec 2022

0.210.16—

19 May 2023

0.230.17—

21 Feb 2025

0.370.26—

Capital Instruments

InstrumentPrincipalCouponMaturitySecurity

Subsidiary bonds (Malta Stock Exchange)

€25.0m (C$36.5m carrying, FY2024)

5.70% (from 4.00%)

Aug 2033 (extended from Aug 2026)

German industrial parks, with a collateral shortfall cash-trap mechanism on asset sales

Loan payable

C$0 (FY2024); C$7.6m (FY2023)

———

Bank liquidity facilities

Undrawn (FY2024)

——

Short-term securities

Analyst Conclusions

Management guidance and consensus

Guidance: none issued. The only forward-looking commitments are to engage a new auditor, file the FY2025 20-F "as soon as practicable", cure the NYSE delinquency, resume trading, and then set the 2026 dividend policy.

Consensus: none (no coverage).

Operator outlook: Tacora has disclosed a multi-year capital investment and ramp-up plan toward 6 Mtpa nameplate (FY2024 20-F).

Bull case

  1. Deep discount to tangible value. The stock trades at about 0.36x book (C$20.39, about US$14.2 per share), with gross liquid assets of C$165m. Net cash plus liquid assets alone approach the market capitalisation, so the royalty (book C$192m) is effectively being priced near zero.

  2. Volume upside. With Tacora recapitalised (US$250m equity, Cargill offtake and an amended rail contract), shipments could rise from 3.06 Mt (2024) toward 6 Mtpa. That would roughly double gross royalty receipts, which were about C$35m at 3.5 Mt in FY2023.

  3. Governance resolution as a catalyst. A decisive EGM on 12 January 2027 would end the dual-board stalemate. If the Reporting Group (about 48.5%) prevails, the presumed agenda is cutting overhead (C$25m SG&A), finishing the disposals and returning capital. If the incumbents prevail with renewed legitimacy, the royalty cash held in court would be released. Either outcome would unlock trapped cash and could restore the listing.

Bear case

  1. Cash flow interruption. Under 2026 ONCA 306, royalties flow into the Ontario court until the Cayman litigation is finally determined. Further appeals could extend this for many quarters while legal costs mount, including indemnity costs already awarded to Tacora.

  2. Reporting and listing failure. With no auditor, no FY2025 20-F and trading suspended since May 2026, delisting from the NYSE is a real risk. That would compound illiquidity and could push the discount wider. A late audit could also bring further impairments of the held-for-sale assets, which were already written down by C$18.6m.

  3. Structural value leakage. Even before the dispute, the corporate cost base exceeded royalty revenue. FY2024 net loss was C$20.6m, and the four-year cumulative net income for FY2021–FY2024 was negative at about -C$35m. Without radical simplification, royalty value accrues to overhead rather than to shareholders.

Catalysts and monitorables (next 12 months)

Catalyst / monitorableTimingWhat to watch
Appointment of a new auditorAny time6-K announcement; auditor quality
FY2025 Form 20-F filingOverdueAudited FY2025 results, held-for-sale outcomes, cost base, going-concern language
NYSE statusOngoingResumption of trading versus a delisting determination
EGM vote12 Jan 2027Board composition; whether the Reporting Group's 48.5% carries the vote
Cayman Court of Appeal / further appealsUncertainFinality of control; costs orders
Release of royalty funds paid into courtAfter the Cayman determinationCash available for dividends
Tacora production and shipmentsQuarterlyProgress toward 6 Mtpa; royalty per tonne
65% Fe iron ore price and premiumContinuousRoyalty sensitivity
Completion of the All Other rationalisationPendingReceipt of about C$15m securities and the C$55.4m equity stake
2026 dividend decisionAfter the 20-FResumption and size

Analyst verdict

Scully Royalty is a paradox. Its underlying asset is genuinely attractive, but the corporate wrapper has, for now, nearly severed that asset from public shareholders.

The asset is a perpetual-style 7% gross revenue royalty, running to 2055, on a premium 65.9% Fe Labrador Trough concentrate. The operator was recapitalised in 2024 by a consortium led by Cargill and has an articulated plan to roughly double throughput toward 6 Mtpa. On FY2024 audited numbers, the company carried C$302m of equity, about C$165m of gross liquid assets and only C$36.5m of long-dated debt. The market prices all of this at roughly a third of book value.

That discount is not irrational. Over 2021–2024 the conglomerate structure consumed more than the royalty generated. SG&A of C$25.3m exceeded royalty revenue of C$20.1m in FY2024, and cumulative net income across those four years was deeply negative. Since November 2025 the situation has degraded further:

  • a contested proxy fight;

  • two rival boards;

  • an auditor resignation;

  • a missed 20-F deadline;

  • an NYSE trading suspension;

  • most critically, an Ontario Court of Appeal order diverting every royalty payment into court until the Cayman litigation concludes.

The investment case therefore no longer turns on iron ore. It turns on governance finality. The Kellogg–MILFAM Reporting Group controls about 48.5% of the shares and has forced an EGM for 12 January 2027. Arithmetically, it is well placed to win unless further Cayman litigation intervenes. A decisive outcome, whichever side prevails, is the precondition for releasing trapped cash, completing an audit and restoring the listing.

Verdict: SRL is a special-situation, event-driven holding. The asymmetry is real: deep asset backing against a binary governance catalyst. Position sizing should reflect a meaningful probability that cash remains locked well into 2027. Until audited FY2025 accounts and a single legitimate board exist, the stock is better analysed as a litigation-dependent claim on net assets than as a yield-bearing royalty company.


*Data integrity note: All C$ figures are from Form 20-F and 6-K filings unless marked as aggregator-sourced or derived. Where sources conflict, the discrepancy is noted: FY2023 gross profit is 34.6 per Stockopedia versus 35.8 from the 20-F cost line, and the Kellogg stake is 35.7% per the 20-F versus 35.5% per later reporting on a larger share count.

Unlock Company Financials

Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.

View Subscription Plans

Executive Leadership

Governance Detail

ClaimBasisEffect

Incumbent board (company position)

Grand Court of the Cayman Islands judgment, announced 7–8 Jul 2026

The board and management remain unchanged. MILFAM's 27 Dec 2025 meeting and its resolutions are invalid. MILFAM's SEC filings and releases since January 2026 are unauthorised, and Forms 3 filed for MILFAM nominees are improper (6-K/A, Jul 2026).

MILFAM nominees (purportedly "elected" 27 Dec 2025)

MILFAM's purported AGM

Rejected by the Grand Court. MILFAM's 13D/A says it is entitled to appeal. The Reporting Group (Kellogg plus MILFAM) has requisitioned an EGM for 12 Jan 2027 to replace four incumbents.

Board of Directors

NameRoleBoard sinceBackgroundAge

Samuel S. Morrow

President, CEO, CFO and Director

Officer since Jun 2017 (Deputy CEO and CFO); CEO and director since 1 May 2021

CFA. Formerly Vice President of Tanaka Capital Management and Treasurer, CFO and COO of the Tanaka Growth Fund. MILFAM's purported board claimed to terminate him for cause on 12 Jan 2026; the Grand Court found that board lacked authority.

37 per FY2021 20-F, so about 41–42 now

Michael J. Smith

Executive Chairman and Director

Long-standing; CEO until 1 May 2021

Former President and CEO of the company and of MFC Bancorp. Was the company contact person on the FY2020 20-F.

—

Dr. Shuming Zhao

Director

Disclosed in FY2022–FY2024 20-Fs

——

Silke S. Stenger

Director; member of the audit and compensation/nominating committees

Disclosed in FY2020–FY2024 20-Fs

——

Jochen Dümler

Director; Risk Committee

Disclosed in FY2020–FY2024 20-Fs

Former board member at Euler Hermes Kreditversicherung AG; on the board of PRISMA Kreditversicherung AG from 1995 to 2002; member of the German-American Chamber of Commerce (NYC) and German Executive Roundtable (DC)

—

Friedrich Hondl

Director nominee in 2022; Risk Committee in 2020

Listed in the 2022 AGM circular

Not listed in the FY2022–FY2023 board composition text retrieved

—

Indrajit Chatterjee

Former director; chaired the Compensation Committee

2017 to Aug 2024 (deceased)

Retired; formerly in marketing at the GE Transportation Systems Division, India

Deceased

Executive Leadership Team

NameAffiliation disclosedStatus

Jerrod M. Freund

MILFAM nominee

Purportedly elected 27 Dec 2025 (invalid per Grand Court); EGM nominee to succeed Michael J. Smith

Mark Holliday

MILFAM nominee

Purportedly elected (invalid); EGM nominee to succeed Dr. Shuming Zhao

Alan B. Howe

MILFAM nominee; director of Alimco Financial and member of MILFAM's Manager Oversight Committee (company allegation)

Purportedly elected (invalid); not on the September 2026 requisition slate

Nimesh Patel

MILFAM nominee

Purportedly elected (invalid); EGM nominee to succeed Silke S. Stenger

Skyler Wichers

Vice President of MILFAM LLC; director of Alimco Financial Corporation

Purportedly elected (invalid); EGM nominee to succeed Jochen Dümler

Major Shareholders

HolderShares%Date / source

Peter Kellogg group (Peter and Cynthia Kellogg, IAT Reinsurance Co. Ltd., IAT Insurance Group, Harco National Insurance, Goose Creek Capital, Charles Kellogg)

5,293,27635.7

FY2024 20-F (24 Apr 2025). Later reporting cites 35.5% on a larger share count. The 20-F says this group may be considered to control the company.

Neil S. Subin / MILFAM LLC / Alimco Re and Miller family trusts

1,985,95213.0

Schedule 13D/A Amendments No. 3–6 (Nov 2025–Jan 2026), on 15,226,351 shares

— of which MILFAM LLC (aggregated)

1,957,59712.9

13D/A Amendment No. 6

Reporting Group (Kellogg plus MILFAM), combined

about 7.28m

about 48.5

13D/A Amendment No. 5 (Kellogg) and Amendment No. 7 (MILFAM), 29 Jul 2026

Nantahala Capital

317,6812.1

13G/A, Dec 2022 (below 5% since then)

Registered holders

113 holders of record, 109 in the US

—

FY2024 20-F

Board & Management Changes

DateChangeContext

1 May 2021

Morrow becomes CEO; Smith becomes Executive Chairman

Planned succession

Aug 2024

Death of director Indrajit Chatterjee

Compensation Committee chair vacancy

12 Jan 2026

Purported termination of Morrow by the MILFAM slate

Declared invalid by the Grand Court in July 2026

11 Mar 2026

Auditor (AOGB CPA) resigns

Linked by the company to the governance disruption

14 Sep 2026

EGM requisition to replace Smith, Zhao, Stenger and Dümler

Vote on 12 Jan 2027

Competitive Landscape

Key Competitors

#CompetitorSegmentRelative positioning vs SRL
1

Labrador Iron Ore Royalty Corp. (TSX: LIF)

Iron ore royalty (IOC, Labrador Trough)

Closest peer: same region and product type. Much larger and more liquid, with a high payout.

2

Mesabi Trust (NYSE: MSB)

Iron ore royalty (Northshore Mining, Minnesota)

US-listed pass-through trust; simple structure and no corporate overhead

3

Deterra Royalties (ASX: DRR)

Iron ore royalty (BHP's Mining Area C, Pilbara)

Tier-1 asset; trades at a premium P/B

4

Champion Iron Ore (TSX/ASX: CIA)

High-grade Labrador Trough producer (Bloom Lake; Kami project 6 km from Scully)

Competes for premium-grade seaborne demand; validates regional asset values

5

Franco-Nevada (NYSE/TSX: FNV)

Diversified royalty/streaming

Benchmark for royalty multiples

6

Wheaton Precious Metals (NYSE/TSX: WPM)

Streaming

Benchmark

7

Royal Gold (NASDAQ: RGLD)

Royalty/streaming

Benchmark

8

Altius Minerals (TSX: ALS)

Diversified royalty (Canadian; includes Labrador iron ore exposure via LIORC)

Regional royalty peer

9

Osisko Gold Royalties (NYSE/TSX: OR)

Royalty

Benchmark

10

Sandstorm Gold / Metalla Royalty

Small and mid-cap royalty

Small-cap royalty valuation reference

11

European specialty and trade-finance banks

Merchant Banking

Far larger; SRL's bank is sub-scale

Peer Comparison FY2025

MetricLabrador Iron Ore RoyaltyDeterra RoyaltiesMesabi TrustScully Royalty

Share price (local currency)

27.523.5626.39

about 6.9 US$ (May 2026)

Market capitalisation

C$1.761bn

A$1.88bn

US$347.55m

about US$77–105m

Forward dividend yield (%)

11.085.135.86

Suspended pending FY2025 20-F

P/E (x)

8.9213.37

not meaningful

negative (FY2024 loss)

P/B (x)

2.7418.363.65

about 0.36–0.49

Company Snapshot

$25.8M

Revenue

$77M

Market Cap

2017

Founded

Shanghai, China

Headquarters

SWOT Analysis

Strengths

  • Long-dated royalty. The sub-lease runs to 2055, and the operator forecasts a mine life of over 25 years (FY2024 20-F).
  • Premium product. The concentrate grades about 65.9% Fe. The 2024 premium of 65% over 62% Fe averaged about US$14/t, or 13% (FY2024 20-F).
  • Revenue floor. There is a C$3.25m annual minimum royalty, paid quarterly.
  • Recapitalised operator. Tacora received a US$250m equity injection in September 2024 from Cargill, Millstreet and O'Brien-Staley.
  • Strong balance sheet. Equity was C$302.3m (C$20.39 per share) with gross liquid assets of C$165.1m at FY2024.
  • Low leverage with long-dated debt. The only debt is C$36.5m of bonds at 5.70%, extended to 2033. There was a small net cash position after short-term securities at FY2024.

Weaknesses

  • Concentration. One customer accounted for 57% of FY2024 revenue and 64% of FY2023 revenue (20-F customer note).
  • Cost base exceeds royalty income. FY2024 SG&A was C$25.3m against royalty revenue of C$20.1m.
  • Thin disclosure. There is no SEC-compliant reserves disclosure or technical report, and the operator denied the request (FY2024 20-F).
  • Earnings volatility. Net income swung from +C$7.6m (FY2021) to -C$23.4m (FY2022), +C$1.4m (FY2023) and -C$20.6m (FY2024).
  • Governance. Combined CEO and CFO roles; executive chair; auditor turnover (AOGB appointed December 2024, resigned March 2026).
  • Reporting failure. The FY2025 20-F is late, and the H1 2025 report was published only on 31 December 2025.

Opportunities

  • Tacora ramp-up. A return toward 6 Mtpa nameplate, against 3.06 Mt shipped in 2024, could roughly double royalty volumes.
  • Green-steel demand. Decarbonisation is expanding demand for high-grade feed (premium positioning per the 20-F).
  • Simplification. Completing the rationalisation (C$70.4m net held-for-sale assets) would strip loss-making legacy units; those generated a C$4.5m net loss in 2024.
  • Valuation re-rating. The stock trades at roughly 0.36–0.49x book, against peers at 2.7–18x (company's own peer table).
  • Possible overhead reduction under new control. The Reporting Group holds about 48.5% and has requisitioned an EGM for 12 January 2027.
  • Regional M&A interest. The Nippon Steel/Sojitz investment in Kami, 6 km away, signals strategic appetite for Labrador Trough assets.

Threats

  • Trapped royalty cash. 2026 ONCA 306 directs future quarterly royalties into court pending the Cayman litigation.
  • Delisting risk. NYSE trading has been suspended since 12 May 2026 for the late-filing delinquency.
  • Litigation cost and distraction. Proceedings are running in the Cayman Grand Court, the Cayman Court of Appeal and Ontario, with indemnity costs awarded to Tacora.
  • Iron ore prices. Royalty revenue fell 27.5% in FY2022 on weaker pricing (FY2022 20-F).
  • Operator risk. Tacora went through CCAA in 2023–2024 and was disrupted by wildfires in 2024.
  • Capital controls. RMB cash in held-for-sale PRC entities is subject to SAFE conversion controls (FY2024 20-F risk factor).

Unlock Company Financials

Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.

View Subscription Plans

Key Developments

DateEventSignificance
21 Feb 2025C$0.37 (US$0.26) dividend paidFirst cash return since May 2023
24 Apr 2025Kellogg group reported at 35.7% in the 20-FConfirms de facto control block
30 Apr 2025FY2024 Form 20-F filed with AOGB CPA auditLast audited annual report to date
2025 (ongoing)Rationalisation of held-for-sale assets continues (C$85.9m at 30 Jun 2025)Simplification incomplete
25 Nov 2025MILFAM delivers a nomination notice for five directorsProxy contest begins
26 Nov 2025Subin files an amended early warning report and 13D/A (13.0%)Formalises the activist position
7–8 Dec 2025MILFAM files its dissident proxy circular; Walkers (Cayman) writes to the company's counselEscalation
12 Dec 2025Company says MILFAM failed advance-notice requirementsProcedural defence
19 Dec 2025Grand Court rules MILFAM's notice valid and timelyEarly win for MILFAM
22 Dec 2025Company announces appeal and alleges material misstatements and undisclosed nominee ties (Howe, Alimco)Credibility battle
24 Dec 2025Company appeals the 19 Dec decision and postpones the 27 Dec AGMContested postponement
26–27 Dec 2025MILFAM proceeds with a purported AGM and announces the election of its five nomineesDual-board situation
29 Dec 2025Company affirms the existing board remains in place and reserves rights against MILFAM—
31 Dec 2025H1 2025 report: revenue C$18.6m; net loss C$2.0m; EBITDA C$4.3m; working capital C$141.0mOperations stable; report filed late
12 Jan 2026MILFAM's purported board announces termination of CEO/CFO Morrow for causeLater invalidated
14–15 Jan 2026Competing 6-K filingsInvestor confusion
11–12 Feb 2026Tacora files an interpleader over the January 2026 royalty, naming SRL, 1128349 B.C., MILFAM and the directorsRoyalty cash flow to SRL interrupted
11 Mar 2026Auditor resignationPrevents a timely FY2025 20-F
Mar–Apr 2026Ontario Superior Court first dismisses the interpleader and imposes an interim payment orderBrief uncertainty
Late Apr 2026Ontario Court of Appeal (2026 ONCA 306) orders the January royalty and future quarterly royalties paid into court pending the Cayman outcome; Tacora awarded full indemnity costsRoyalty cash trapped until the governance dispute is resolved
30 Apr 2026FY2025 20-F deadline missedNYSE non-compliance
12 May 2026NYSE suspends tradingLiquidity shock; delisting risk
7–8 Jul 2026Grand Court judgment: MILFAM never had authority; incumbents confirmed; MILFAM's proxy disclosure deficientMajor win for incumbents
8 Jul 20266-K/A declares MILFAM filings and releases unauthorised and Forms 3 for its nominees improperClean-up of the record
29 Jul 2026Kellogg and MILFAM form a coordinated Reporting Group of about 48.5%Shifts the balance of power decisively
14 Sep 2026Reporting Group requisitions an EGM to replace four directorsNew route to control
24 Sep 2026Share quoted at about US$5.08, down about 51% from a 52-week high of about US$10.39 (ad-hoc-news)Market discount to book widens
Oct 2026Company convenes the EGM for 12 Jan 2027 (Hong Kong); new Shanghai office address on the 6-KDecisive catalyst set

Financial Performance

Explore key financial metrics, segmented revenue, balance sheet health, and performance trends.

Revenue

4 charts
Revenue by Segment: Total revenue fell from CAD 59.4 Mn in FY2020 to CAD 35.3 Mn in FY2024.
Scully Royalty Ltd. — Revenue by Segment
Series (CAD Mn)FY2020FY2021FY2022FY2023FY2024
Total revenue59.471.363.754.935.3
Royalty revenue33.340.329.235.320.1
Industrial revenue17.723.428.512.20
Merchant Banking revenue—6.55.57.46.2
All Other revenue010.509

Unlock Company Financials

Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.

View Subscription Plans

Unlock Company Contacts

Connect with Key Decision-Makers

Access verified employee contacts and decision-maker information from this company to support your sales, lead generation, and business development efforts.