Sky Chinafortune Holdings Group Limited Overview
Sky Chinafortune was a Hong Kong-incorporated investment holding company whose real economic substance was a small portfolio of PRC investment properties. These were street-level shop units, residential flats and car-parking spaces in Shanghai, Hainan and Anshan (Liaoning), carried at about HKD 508M fair value at end-2022. The portfolio produced roughly HKD 26M of annual rent, and a single anchor tenant accounted for about half of group revenue.
From 2018 the controlling shareholder, a Shanghai real-estate and hotel investor, tried to diversify. The attempts were an automobile dealership (2018–2019), a Moutai-focused liquor shop and "大橘" convenience stores (2020–2022), Anshan property management (2020–2022), and a braised-food concept. Every venture was loss-making and was closed or abandoned.
HKEX judged that the business lacked sufficient operations under Rule 13.24, suspended the shares and ultimately cancelled the listing in April 2023. The company is now best understood as an unlisted, debt-free, cash-holding PRC landlord controlled by a single family, with no public reporting obligations.
Company's own description (latest annual filings)
In its FY2022 results announcement the company describes itself as an investment holding company. Its subsidiaries operated across three reportable segments:
-
Property investment. Leasing of properties situated in the PRC.
-
Trading of properties and property-related services. Sale of PRC properties, including short-term leasing of properties held for sale, plus property-related services in the PRC. The company did not renew its property management agreements when they expired on 31 May 2022, citing unsatisfactory financial performance.
-
Retail business. Sale of Chinese liquor and wine, everyday items and ready-cooked food in the PRC. All convenience stores and retail food stores were closed during 2022. Management stated that the segment would continue selling Chinese liquor and wine.
The 2020 ESG report describes the group as mainly engaged in PRC property investment, with residential premises, shops and car parks held for rental. It names property-related services and retail (Chinese liquor and wine, everyday items) as ancillary activities.
Independent characterisation
Economically the company was a passive PRC landlord with a public-listing wrapper. In FY2022, 81% of revenue (HKD 25.78M of HKD 31.71M) was rental income, and the rent roll was highly concentrated:
-
One tenant in the property investment segment paid HKD 15.65M in FY2022, 49% of group revenue. The same tenant paid HKD 15.61M in FY2021, 32% of revenue.
-
A second tenant paid HKD 3.42M in FY2022, about 11% of revenue.
Gross margins on rent were very high (net rental income HKD 23.99M on gross rent of HKD 25.78M in FY2022). Group profitability was nonetheless driven by:
-
non-cash fair-value movements on investment properties (−HKD 66.51M in FY2022);
-
corporate overhead (administrative expenses of HKD 23.31M, about 90% of rental revenue);
-
recurring losses from the diversification ventures.
Revenue model mix
| Revenue type (HKD Mn) | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
| Rental revenue – shops | 23.974 | 22.795 |
| Rental revenue – residential | 2.589 | 2.397 |
| Rental revenue – car parking spaces | 0.537 | 0.587 |
| Retail sales (product) | 17.949 | 4.453 |
| Property related services (service) | 3.680 | 1.481 |
| Total revenue | 48.729 | 31.713 |
Source: FY2022 final results announcement, note 2: Mix in FY2022: leasing 81.3%, product sales 14.0%, services 4.7%. There was no subscription or licensing revenue.
Revenue recognition:
-
Retail sales are recognised at a point in time.
-
Property services are recognised over time.
-
Leases ran from one to ten years at fixed rents, some with escalation clauses (FY2022 results, note 2).
Value chain position, customers and end-markets
| Dimension | Description |
|---|---|
| Value chain position | Asset owner / lessor (downstream of developers). Short-lived small-format retailer of third-party FMCG and liquor. Short-lived third-party property manager. |
| Customer types | Commercial tenants of street-level shops (concentrated: two tenants each above 10% of revenue in FY2022). Residential tenants (15 units). Car-park users. Retail consumers in Shanghai and Anshan. One property management counterparty in Anshan. |
| End-markets | PRC commercial and retail property leasing (Shanghai, Liaoning); PRC residential leasing (Shanghai, Hainan); PRC consumer retail of baijiu/wine; PRC convenience retail (exited 2022) |
| Geography | Substantially all operations in the PRC. No geographic segment information presented because there were no material operations outside the PRC. |
Strategy
Stated strategic themes (paraphrased from the FY2020 and FY2022 Chairman's Statements and MD&A)
-
Enlarge and diversify the property portfolio. The aim was a mixed portfolio of investment properties built by acquiring quality assets over time. This was restated in the FY2022 prospects section.
-
Build a property management track record. The aim was a reputation as a reliable property services provider (FY2020). It was abandoned in May 2022.
-
Consumer retail diversification. The plan centred on a Moutai-focused liquor shop and a convenience store chain aimed at the growing PRC middle class (FY2020). Convenience retail was abandoned in 2022.
-
Food-related expansion. This began with Chinese braised food, with ambitions to offer dishes for various regional cuisines (FY2020). No evidence of launch was found.
-
Strategic flexibility. In FY2022 management said it would avoid a rigid business strategy and keep flexibility across segments to adapt to fast-changing conditions.
Initiatives in the last 24 months (October 2024 – October 2026)
There are none publicly disclosed. The company ceased public reporting after the April 2023 delisting.
Initiatives in the final 24 months of listing (April 2021 – April 2023)
| Date | Initiative | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 2,021 | Retail cost-structure review and store closures in Shanghai | HKD 14.16M of impairment and closure losses |
| 2,022 | Closure of all convenience and food stores in Shanghai and Anshan | Retail revenue −75% |
| 31 May 2022 | Exit from Anshan property management | Services revenue −60% |
| Aug–Nov 2022 | Exploration of "different business opportunities" to restore Rule 13.24 compliance | No definitive agreement |
| Jan 2023 | Non-binding term sheet for a proposed acquisition requiring a new listing application | Rejected as a basis for resumption by the Listing Committee (31 Mar 2023) |
Cost programmes, ESG commitments and guidance
Cost programmes: No formal targets were disclosed. Administrative expenses fell by HKD 5.62M and selling expenses by HKD 14.38M in FY2022 as a result of store closures.
ESG commitments: No quantified targets were set.
Medium-term financial targets or guidance: None publicly disclosed.
Products & Services
Property investment
| Offering | Description | Scale / specifications | Target customer | Year | Pricing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shop lots (Shanghai) | Street-level and retail shop units leased to commercial tenants; includes properties placed on 10-year leases in 2019 | Number of units not publicly disclosed. Combined shops and car parks revenue HKD 23.38M (FY2022); average occupancy 70.0% (FY2022), 100% (FY2021). | Commercial and retail tenants; one anchor tenant at about 49% of group revenue | Held pre-2016; reclassified to investment property in 2019 | Fixed rents over 1–10 year terms, some escalating |
| Shop units (Anshan, Liaoning) | 11 contiguous double-deck shop units in a two-storey retail building in a new private housing estate | Acquired 2019 for about HKD 22.85M; vacant at acquisition | Local retail tenants | 2,019 | — |
| Residential premises (Shanghai and Hainan) | 15 residential units classified as investment properties | Revenue HKD 2.38M (FY2022); average occupancy 91.11% (FY2022); year-end occupancy 86.67% | Residential tenants | 15 units since 2019 (12 in 2018) | — |
| Car parking spaces | Leased parking spaces | Revenue HKD 0.587M (FY2022) | Residents and tenants | — | — |
Trading of properties and property related services
| Offering | Description | Scale | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Residential unit held for sale (Shanghai) | Single unit carried at lower of cost and net realisable value; short-term leased | Revenue HKD 0.02M (FY2022); occupancy 25% (FY2022) vs 66.67% (FY2021); carrying value HKD 1.202M | Held at last report |
| Property management services (Anshan) | Services for residential properties, shop lots and auxiliary facilities under three agreements with Anshan Xinhaijia | Contracted about RMB 3.0M per year; recorded HKD 2.00M (FY2020), HKD 3.68M (FY2021), HKD 1.48M (FY2022) | Not renewed after 31 May 2022 |
Retail business
| Brand / format | Description | Scale | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| "大橘珍品" (Da Ju Zhen Pin) Chinese liquor and wine store, Shanghai | Retail of baijiu and wine with primary focus on Moutai | 1 store at end-2020 | Continuing at minimal scale per FY2022 results |
| "大橘便利" (Da Ju Bian Li) convenience stores, Shanghai and Anshan | Selected fast-moving consumer goods plus casual convenience food aimed at middle-class consumers | 3 stores at end-2020; later expanded (peak count not publicly disclosed) | All closed in 2022 |
| Retail food stores, Shanghai | Ready-cooked food | Count not publicly disclosed | All closed in 2022 |
| Braised food concept (Chinese 卤味) | Food-related business, planned initially around braised dishes | Preparation from Dec 2020; launch not confirmed | Not publicly disclosed whether launched; superseded by closures |
Discontinued offerings
| Offering | Description | Period | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Automobile sales and tertiary services (Shanghai "automobile city") | Dealer operation via Shanghai Chengzhi; NEV exposure | Jun 2018–2H2019 | Ceased. FY2019 loss HKD 9.71M; FY2018 loss HKD 2.78M. |
| Trading operation (historic, as Great China Holdings) | Commodity trading including fishmeal into China | Pre-2016 (1H2004 turnover HKD 538.6M) | No longer part of the group by 2018; date of exit not publicly disclosed |
Financial Narrative
All figures are in HKD millions unless stated. FY2018–FY2020 figures come from the continuing-operations data in the AR2019 and AR2020 MD&A. FY2021–FY2022 figures come from the audited statements in the FY2022 results announcement.
Income statement — full series
Sources: AR2019 MD&A (FY2018–FY2019), AR2020 MD&A (FY2020), FY2022 results (FY2021–FY2022).
Revenue CAGR FY2018–FY2022: about 6.8% a year (24.35 to 31.71). This is distorted by the temporary retail revenue in FY2020–FY2021.
Income statement — detailed (FY2021–FY2022, audited)
Source: FY2022 results announcement. EBITDA lines are analyst-derived. D&A comprises PP&E depreciation, right-of-use depreciation, trademark amortisation and intangibles amortisation.
Discontinued operation (automobile)
Source: AR2019. The business generated no revenue in either year according to the AR2019 Chairman's Statement.
Balance sheet — full series
Sources: AR2019 and AR2020 MD&A (Liquidity and Financial Resources); FY2022 results.
Sources: FY2022 results (statement of changes in equity opening balance for FY2020 equity; note 10 for investment property opening balance). FY2020 total liabilities are derived as total assets less total equity.
Goodwill: nil, none recorded in either year.
Debt split: no bank borrowings in any year FY2018–FY2022. The only interest-bearing obligations were lease liabilities:
-
FY2022: HKD 0.246M, all current.
-
FY2021: HKD 2.359M current and HKD 0.856M non-current.
Cash flow
Sources: FY2022 results (segment note 3; dividend note 9; no purchase or redemption of listed securities).
Operating cash flow and free cash flow on a statutory basis are not publicly disclosed in the documents extracted. The full cash flow statement exists in AR2021, but the FY2022 annual report does not appear to have been published before the April 2023 delisting.
The decline in cash and deposits shows the scale of cash burn:
-
HKD 140.76M at end-2018
-
HKD 48.05M at end-2022
-
A cumulative fall of about HKD 92.7M over four years with no dividends paid
The FY2019 acquisition of the Anshan shop units (HKD 22.85M) and the automobile and retail ventures (about HKD 24.4M of placing proceeds) account for part of the decline. The rest reflects recurring corporate overhead.
Ratios
All ratios are analyst-derived from the FY2022 results: Ratios that are not meaningful:
-
ROIC: invested capital is almost entirely equity and operating profit is negative, so ROIC is effectively the same as ROA.
-
Net debt to EBITDA and interest coverage: the company had net cash and negative EBITDA.
-
Cash conversion cycle: not meaningful for a landlord and not computed.
Commentary on trends, inflections and drivers
The rental base was stable but small.
-
Rental revenue was flat at about HKD 24–27M from FY2018 to FY2022.
-
Average shop occupancy collapsed to 51.47% in FY2019 because the newly acquired Anshan units were vacant. It recovered to 100% in FY2021, then fell back to 70.0% in FY2022.
-
Residential occupancy held at about 87–92% throughout.
-
Rent relief granted in FY2020 cost about HKD 2.51M.
Diversification destroyed value.
-
Retail added HKD 18.3M of revenue in FY2020 and HKD 17.9M in FY2021.
-
It also produced losses of HKD 6.17M (FY2020), HKD 38.94M (FY2021, including HKD 14.16M of impairment and closure costs) and HKD 6.64M (FY2022).
-
Gross margin fell from about 91% to about 55% as retail diluted the high-margin rent mix. It rebounded to 75.7% in FY2022 once the stores closed.
Valuation losses were the decisive inflection.
-
The FY2022 net valuation loss on investment properties of HKD 66.51M was driven mainly by shops and car parks (−HKD 58.54M), reflecting falling PRC property prices.
-
Together with a HKD 44.60M translation loss as the RMB weakened, this cut equity by HKD 103.6M in one year.
-
Book value per share fell from about HKD 1.79 (FY2020) to HKD 1.42 (FY2022).
The overhead structure was oversized.
-
Administrative expenses of HKD 21–29M a year roughly equalled total rental revenue.
-
The company therefore could not earn a sustainable operating profit from its core assets, even before valuation movements.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansFinancial Detail
Segment Overview
| Segment | Contents | Status at last report |
|---|---|---|
Property investment | Leasing of PRC shops, residential units and car parks held as investment properties (Shanghai, Hainan, Liaoning) | Core, continuing |
Trading of properties and property related services | One Shanghai residential unit held for sale (short-term leased); Anshan property management (Jun 2020–May 2022) | Services ceased 31 May 2022; one unit held for sale remains |
Retail business | Chinese liquor and wine ("大橘珍品"); convenience stores ("大橘便利"); retail food stores | Convenience and food stores closed in 2022; liquor sales continuing at minimal scale |
Automobile business (discontinued) | Car sales and automobile tertiary services in Shanghai (Shanghai Chengzhi) | Ceased 2H2019; deregistered 3 Jun 2020 |
Revenue by Segment
| Segment | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Property investment revenue (HKD Mn) | 23.75 | 24.46 | 27.022 | 25.756 |
Trading of properties and property services revenue (HKD Mn) | 0.29 | 2.10 | 3.758 | 1.504 |
Retail business revenue (HKD Mn) | 0 | 18.30 | 17.949 | 4.453 |
Total revenue, continuing operations (HKD Mn) | 24.04 | 44.86 | 48.729 | 31.713 |
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansResults by Segment
| Segment | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Trading of properties and property services profit after tax (HKD Mn) | 0.24 | 0.29 | 0.336 | -0.269 |
Retail business profit after tax (HKD Mn) | -1.63 | -6.17 | -38.940 | -6.635 |
Results by Segment (FY2021–FY2022)
| Segment | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Property investment profit after tax (HKD Mn) | 12.824 | -40.802 |
Net corporate expenses (HKD Mn) | -15.293 | -11.381 |
Group loss for the year (HKD Mn) | -41.154 | -59.135 |
Segment Margins & Growth (%) and Revenue by Segment (%)
| Metric | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Property investment post-tax margin (%) | 47.5 | -158.4 |
Trading and services post-tax margin (%) | 8.9 | -17.9 |
Retail post-tax margin (%) | -216.9 | -149.0 |
Property investment share of revenue (%) | 55.5 | 81.2 |
Trading and services share of revenue (%) | 7.7 | 4.7 |
Retail share of revenue (%) | 36.8 | 14.0 |
YoY revenue growth (%)
| YoY revenue growth (%) | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|
Property investment | 3.0 | 10.5 |
Trading and services | 624.1 | 79.0 |
Retail | 0 | -1.9 |
Group | 86.6 | 8.6 |
Segment Revenue
| Segment | Assets FY2021 | Assets FY2022 | Liabilities FY2021 | Liabilities FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Property investment | 636.447 | 546.052 | 101.812 | 85.561 |
Trading of properties and services | 2.944 | 1.225 | 17.081 | 15.561 |
Retail business | 20.763 | 5.873 | 4.880 | 1.360 |
Unallocated corporate | 63.520 | 43.376 | 5.277 | 3.058 |
Consolidated | 723.674 | 596.526 | 129.050 | 105.540 |
Group Entities
| Subsidiary | Place of incorporation | Activity |
|---|---|---|
Capital Head Investment Limited | Hong Kong | Property investment in Shanghai |
Concord Trinity Development Limited | Hong Kong | Property investment in Shanghai |
Jelson Enterprises Limited | Hong Kong | Property investment in Shanghai |
Glory South Investment Limited | Hong Kong | Property investment in Hainan |
Poppins Properties (Shanghai) Co., Ltd. (博平置業(上海)有限公司) | PRC | Property investment in Shanghai |
Anshan Tian Xi Hai Jia Sales Co., Ltd. (鞍山天禧海嘉商業銷售有限公司), formerly Anshan Jian Xin Property Management | PRC | Property related services in Anshan |
Sky Chinafortune (Shanghai) Business Management Co., Ltd. (天禧海嘉(上海)商務管理有限公司) | PRC | Investment holding |
Ju Mian (Shanghai) Catering Co., Ltd. (橘面(上海)餐飲有限公司) | PRC | Retail sales and F&B |
Shanghai Da Ju Convenience Ltd. (上海大橘便利店有限公司) | PRC | Retail sales and F&B (convenience stores) |
Great China Holdings Limited (re-used name) | Hong Kong | Investment holding |
Sky Chinastar Holdings Group Limited | Hong Kong | Investment holding |
Adamgate, Dragon Intellect, Max Benefit, Poppins Properties Ltd, Sino Season, Splendid Maple | British Virgin Islands | Investment holding |
Idscan Technology Limited | Hong Kong | Investment holding |
Shanghai Chengzhi Automobile Sales Co., Ltd. | PRC | Automobile sales (deregistered 3 Jun 2020) |
Income Statement and Margin Analysis (%)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Revenue, continuing (HKD Mn) | 24.35 | 24.04 | 44.86 | 48.73 | 31.71 |
Gross profit (HKD Mn) | 21.86 | 21.87 | 24.97 | 26.87 | 24.02 |
Gross margin (%) | 89.8 | 91.0 | 55.7 | 55.1 | 75.7 |
Administrative expenses (HKD Mn) | 21.41 | 24.12 | 23.89 | 28.93 | 23.31 |
Other income (HKD Mn) | 1.74 | 1.64 | 1.62 | 0.87 | 2.30 |
Profit or loss attributable to owners, continuing (HKD Mn) | -3.91 | 4.54 | -3.53 | -39.18 | -58.89 |
EPS basic and diluted, continuing (HK cents) | -1.13 | 1.31 | -1.02 | -11.34 | -17.05 |
Dividend per share (HK cents) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansIncome Statement
| Metric | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Revenue (HKD Mn) | 48.729 | 31.713 |
Cost of sales (HKD Mn) | -21.862 | -7.694 |
Gross profit (HKD Mn) | 26.867 | 24.019 |
Other income (HKD Mn) | 0.869 | 2.295 |
Administrative expenses (HKD Mn) | -28.930 | -23.307 |
Selling and distribution expenses (HKD Mn) | -16.954 | -2.566 |
Other operating expenses, store impairment and closure (HKD Mn) | -14.159 | 0 |
Expected credit loss provision (HKD Mn) | 0 | -1.123 |
Net valuation loss on investment properties (HKD Mn) | -5.501 | -66.513 |
Loss from operations (HKD Mn) | -37.808 | -67.195 |
Finance costs, lease interest (HKD Mn) | -1.229 | -0.054 |
Loss before taxation (HKD Mn) | -39.037 | -67.249 |
Income tax (HKD Mn) | -2.117 | 8.114 |
Loss for the year (HKD Mn) | -41.154 | -59.135 |
Attributable to owners (HKD Mn) | -39.177 | -58.893 |
Attributable to non-controlling interests (HKD Mn) | -1.977 | -0.242 |
Other comprehensive income, FX translation (HKD Mn) | 15.392 | -44.604 |
Total comprehensive income (HKD Mn) | -25.762 | -103.638 |
Depreciation and amortisation (HKD Mn) | 9.819 | 2.455 |
EBITDA, derived = operating result + D&A (HKD Mn) | -27.989 | -64.740 |
EBITDA excluding valuation loss and impairment, derived (HKD Mn) | -8.329 | 1.773 |
Staff costs (HKD Mn) | 24.441 | 16.681 |
Auditor's remuneration (HKD Mn) | 1.650 | 1.580 |
Margin Analysis (%)
| Metric | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Gross margin (%) | 55.1 | 75.7 |
Operating margin (%) | -77.6 | -211.9 |
EBITDA margin, derived (%) | -57.4 | -204.1 |
Pre-tax margin (%) | -80.1 | -212.1 |
Net margin (%) | -84.5 | -186.5 |
Key Financials
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 |
|---|---|---|
Loss after tax, discontinued automobile business (HKD Mn) | -2.78 | -9.71 |
Impairment and write-off within discontinued loss (HKD Mn) | 0 | 7.98 |
Balance Sheet and Financial Ratios (x)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Total assets (HKD Mn) | 711.58 | 699.44 | 764.71 | 723.67 | 596.53 |
Cash, bank balances and deposits (HKD Mn) | 140.76 | 103.01 | 98.03 | 70.70 | 48.05 |
Current assets (HKD Mn) | 150.82 | 111.04 | 108.11 | 84.30 | 72.74 |
Current liabilities (HKD Mn) | 26.46 | 26.35 | 30.24 | 32.36 | 26.45 |
Working capital, derived (HKD Mn) | 124.36 | 84.69 | 77.87 | 51.94 | 46.29 |
Current ratio (x) | 5.70 | 4.21 | 3.57 | 2.60 | 2.75 |
Bank borrowings (HKD Mn) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Net debt, negative = net cash (HKD Mn) | -140.76 | -103.01 | -98.03 | -70.70 | -48.05 |
Gearing ratio (%) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Balance Sheet and Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
Investment properties at fair value (HKD Mn) | 606.764 | 617.010 | 508.412 |
Total equity (HKD Mn) | 620.386 | 594.624 | 490.986 |
Equity attributable to owners (HKD Mn) | 619.553 | 595.095 | 491.658 |
Total liabilities, FY2020 derived (HKD Mn) | 144.32 | 129.050 | 105.540 |
Book value per share, derived (HKD) | 1.79 | 1.72 | 1.42 |
Balance Sheet
| Balance sheet detail (HKD Mn) | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Property, plant and equipment | 6.544 | 0.633 |
Right-of-use assets | 2.499 | 0.241 |
Intangible assets and trademarks (goodwill nil) | 0.166 | 0.093 |
Inventories | 8.513 | 4.649 |
Properties held for sale | 1.302 | 1.202 |
Trade and other receivables, total | 16.945 | 33.246 |
Trade and other payables and accruals | 29.935 | 25.837 |
Lease liabilities, total | 3.215 | 0.246 |
Deferred tax liabilities | 90.936 | 74.725 |
Rental deposits received | 4.955 | 4.364 |
Cash Flow
| Metric | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
Additions to PP&E, capex proxy (HKD Mn) | 8.585 | 0.016 |
Additions to intangible assets (HKD Mn) | 0.360 | 0 |
Dividends paid (HKD Mn) | 0 | 0 |
Share buybacks (HKD Mn) | 0 | 0 |
Change in cash and deposits, balance sheet derived (HKD Mn) | -27.33 | -22.65 |
Returns & Leverage Ratios (%) and Financial Ratios (x)
| Ratio | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
ROE, attributable, average equity (%) | -6.45 | -10.84 |
ROA, average total assets (%) | -5.53 | -8.96 |
Asset turnover (x) | 0.065 | 0.048 |
Current ratio (x) | 2.60 | 2.75 |
Debt to equity, bank debt (x) | 0 | 0 |
Net cash to equity (%) | 11.9 | 9.8 |
Revenue by Region and Revenue by Region (%)
| Region | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
PRC revenue (HKD Mn) | 44.86 | 48.729 | 31.713 |
Hong Kong revenue (HKD Mn) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
PRC share of revenue (%) | 100 | 100 | 100 |
Capital Markets
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
Status | Delisted from HKEX on 20 Apr 2023. Suspended from 2 Sep 2021. |
Last traded / reference price | HKD 0.18 (aggregator data; suspension price) |
Shares in issue | 345,374,910 |
Last implied market capitalisation | About HKD 62.17M |
Enterprise value, derived (market cap − cash HKD 48.05M) | About HKD 14.1M (GuruFocus shows HKD 13.08M; minor difference in the cash definition) |
Valuation Multiples
| Multiple | Sky Chinafortune | Peer reference |
|---|---|---|
P/E | Not meaningful (FY2022 EPS −HK 17.05 cents) | — |
P/B, last equity HKD 491.66M | 0.13x (analyst-derived). Lixinger shows 0.11x; the difference likely reflects a different equity date. | HK small-cap landlords often trade at deep discounts to book (not quantified) |
EV/Sales, FY2022 | About 0.45x (derived) | — |
EV/EBITDA | Not meaningful (negative EBITDA) | — |
Capital Markets (Annual)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dividend per share (HK cents) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Analyst Conclusions
Guidance and consensus
Management guidance: The last guidance came in the FY2022 results (March 2023). Management expected continued volatility from geopolitics and slow domestic demand. It said it would seek diversification, try to enlarge the investment property portfolio and keep strategy flexible. No quantitative guidance was ever issued.
Consensus: None exists.
Bull-case arguments
-
Deep asset discount. At the last price the equity was valued at about 0.13x book, roughly HKD 62M against HKD 492M of attributable net assets. The balance sheet held HKD 508M of investment property and HKD 48M of cash with no bank debt (FY2022). Even a 50% further haircut on property values would leave book value far above the last market value.
-
Lower cost as a private company. Removing listing costs could lift the rental business toward breakeven or profit. In FY2022 the core business produced net rental income of about HKD 24M and had near-positive EBITDA excluding valuation losses (about +HKD 1.8M, derived).
-
Long-dated contracted income. HKD 169.5M of future minimum lease receivables gives multi-year revenue visibility, including HKD 63.4M beyond five years.
Bear-case arguments
-
No liquidity or information. Shares have not traded on HKEX since September 2021, and no financial disclosure has been made since March 2023. Minority holders rely entirely on the controlling family, which owns about 50%.
-
Structural loss-making and capital erosion. Cash fell from HKD 140.8M to HKD 48.1M over FY2018–FY2022. Equity fell 20.6% in two years. Every diversification attempt lost money.
-
Concentration plus property and FX downside. One tenant provides 49% of revenue. The FY2022 valuation loss (13.1% of opening portfolio value) and the RMB translation loss show how exposed equity is to the PRC property and currency cycle.
Catalysts and monitorables (next 12 months)
-
Any Hong Kong Companies Registry filings: annual returns, changes in directors or registered office, or a winding-up or deregistration.
-
Any privatisation, share buy-back or tender offer to minority holders by the controlling shareholder.
-
Revival or abandonment of the January 2023 acquisition target, which required CBIRC, CSRC, MOF and SAFE approvals.
-
PRC commercial property price trends in Shanghai and Liaoning, which drive fair value.
-
Renewal status of the anchor tenant's lease.
-
Availability of the skychinafortune.com website and any shareholder communications.
Analyst verdict
Sky Chinafortune Holdings Group Limited is no longer an investable listed security. HKEX cancelled its listing on 20 April 2023 after the company failed, over more than two years and three levels of review, to show a business of sufficient substance under Rule 13.24. Any assessment must therefore treat it as a private, family-controlled PRC landlord with stranded minority shareholders, not as an equity with a market price.
The record is consistent. Under its current controlling shareholder the group raised about HKD 121M through two 2017 placings. It then spent capital and management attention on a series of unrelated ventures:
-
automobile dealing (2018–2019);
-
a Moutai-led liquor shop and convenience stores (2020–2022);
-
third-party property management (2020–2022);
-
a braised-food concept.
Each venture lost money and was abandoned. Meanwhile the one durable asset base, about HKD 508M of PRC shops, flats and car parks, produced only about HKD 26M of rent. That was not enough to cover a listed-company overhead of about HKD 23M a year. When PRC property prices and the RMB fell in 2022, the group lost about HKD 104M of comprehensive equity in a single year.
The last audited balance sheet was conservatively financed: no borrowings, HKD 48M of cash and a clean KPMG opinion. Net asset value per share of about HKD 1.42 stood far above the HKD 0.18 suspension price. That gap, however, is not a mispricing anyone can arbitrage. No market exists, disclosure has stopped, and value realisation depends wholly on decisions by the controlling Jiang family.
For counterparties, the entity is a small, unlevered landlord whose credit quality depends on one anchor tenant. For former shareholders, the realistic routes to value are a privatisation offer, asset sales with distributions, or a liquidation. None has been announced.
Overall assessment: delisted micro-cap shell-risk property holder. The last reported balance sheet showed adequate assets, but there is no visibility on its condition today. No rating or recommendation can be given.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansExecutive Leadership
Board of Directors
| Name | Role | Director since | Age (as disclosed in AR2020) | Background | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
JIANG Tian (江天) | Executive Director, Chairman, Chairman of Nomination Committee, controlling shareholder | Jun 2017 | 50 | Real estate investment and hotel management in the PRC. Shareholder of Shanghai Chongsheng Investment Management. Legal representative of Shanghai Sky Fortune Hotel Management. Former director of Shenzhen-listed Xinjiang Hejin Holding (000633), Dec 2008–Jun 2009. Chief Executive Aug 2018–Jan 2020. | AR2020 |
HOU Yingxuan | Executive Director, Chief Executive | ED Feb 2017; CEO 6 Jan 2020 | 35 | BSc (Hons) Finance, Lancaster University (2009). CCB International Capital, Nov 2009–Dec 2016 (HK IPO and corporate finance origination). Vice-President Feb 2017–Jan 2020. | AR2020 |
GONG Biao | Executive Director, Vice-President, Remuneration Committee member | Jun 2016 | 50 | Mechanical Engineering and Design, Shanghai Polytechnic University. Shareholder and supervisor of Shanghai Chongsheng. Former vice GM of Xinjiang Hejin (Jan–Jun 2009). Ran the automobile subsidiary in 2018–2020. | AR2020 |
JIANG Jiabao | Executive Director | 6 Jan 2020 | 24 | Bachelor of design, Raffles College of Design and Commerce (2015). Pâtisserie diploma, Le Cordon Bleu Tokyo (2016). Assistant to GM at Shanghai Chongsheng (2017–2019). Daughter of JIANG Tian. | AR2020 |
CHAI Yuet | Non-executive Director | Jun 2016 | 47 | Chairman of China Horae Capital Management (Group) Co., Limited | AR2020 |
TSEUNG Yuk Hei Kenneth | INED, Audit Committee Chairman | Nov 2017 | 55 | Chartered accountant (Australia), Macquarie University. Investment banking roles at Standard Chartered, ABN AMRO, BNP Paribas Peregrine, CIMB (Head of IB China 2012–2017) and Mason Global Capital (2017–2020). Managing director of HeungKong Financial Group from Sep 2020. | AR2020 |
JI Qing | INED; member of Audit, Remuneration and Nomination Committees | May 2018 | 46 | MBA (University of Management and Technology). Partner at Shanghai Shenbei CPAs since May 2013. Internal audit and risk roles at Soochow Life and Tian An Insurance. | AR2020 |
Board of Directors — HU Jianxing
| Name | Role | Tenure end | Reason | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
HU Jianxing | INED; Remuneration Committee chair | Resigned 31 Mar 2022 | Not specified in sources. His departure left the board with only two INEDs. | FY2022 results |
GAO Keqin | Executive Director | Resigned 1 Nov 2019 | To concentrate on other business commitments | AR2019 |
Directors' Remuneration
| Item | Status (last report) |
|---|---|
Board size | 7 (4 ED, 1 NED, 2 INED) |
Independence | 2 of 7 INEDs (28.6%). Below Listing Rule 3.10(1) (minimum 3 INEDs) and Rule 3.10A (at least one-third) after 31 Mar 2022. |
Audit Committee | 2 INEDs (TSEUNG chair, JI). Non-compliant with Rule 3.21. |
Remuneration Committee | Established 2005. Last disclosed chair HU Jianxing (resigned). Post-2022 composition not publicly disclosed. |
Nomination Committee | Established 2005. Chaired by JIANG Tian. |
Chair/CEO separation | Separated since 6 Jan 2020 (JIANG Tian chair, HOU Yingxuan CEO). Combined Aug 2018–Jan 2020. |
Gender diversity | 2 women of 7 directors (HOU Yingxuan, JIANG Jiabao) |
Family relationships | Chairman and ED JIANG Jiabao are father and daughter |
Senior management | The company states that its senior management are the directors |
Directors' Remuneration — Individual director pay
| Item | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|
Individual director pay (salary, bonus, stock, total) | Not publicly disclosed in extracted documents. | — |
Chairman's pay | JIANG Tian agreed to waive all emoluments from 1 Jan 2020, except RMB 10,000 monthly salary and social insurance under his Poppins Properties employment contract | AR2019 Directors' Report |
Group staff costs, excluding NED and INEDs (HKD Mn) | FY2018 11.93; FY2019 12.72; FY2020 13.76; FY2021 23.26; FY2022 15.72 | AR2019, AR2020, FY2022 results |
Equity incentives | Share option scheme adopted 14 May 2010, expired 13 May 2020. No options ever granted. | AR2020 |
Major Shareholders
| Holder | Shares | Stake | Basis | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
JIANG Tian (aggregate) | 173,622,577 | 55.30% of 313,984,910 (Jun 2017). About 50.27% of 345,374,910 after the Nov 2017 placing (analyst-derived, assuming no change in holding). | Form 3A, 6 Jun 2017 | HKEX DI |
– via Hopevision Group Ltd (Seychelles) ← Hong Kong Hopevision International Ltd ← Shanghai Chongsheng Investment Management (99% owned by JIANG Tian) | 172,732,577 | About 55.0% (2017) / 50.0% (derived, post-placing) | Corporate interest | HKEX DI |
– JIANG Tian, beneficial owner | 890,000 | About 0.3% | Personal | HKEX DI |
JIANG Jiabao | At least 1,248,000 bought 25 Jan 2021 | About 0.36% | Personal | AR2020 CG Report |
Institutional holders, top 10 | Not publicly disclosed. No institutional coverage identified. | — | — | — |
Competitive Landscape
Competitors by Segment
| Segment | Named competitors / peers | Relative positioning of Sky Chinafortune |
|---|---|---|
PRC and Hong Kong small-cap property leasing (listed peers) | Silver Grant International Holdings (HKEX 171), property leasing; Hong Kong Shanghai Alliance Holdings (HKEX 1001), building materials plus property; Great China Holdings (Hong Kong) Ltd (HKEX 21), an unrelated company formerly Great China Properties Holdings, not the same entity as 141's former name; Hysan Development (HKEX 14), large-cap landlord, about 4.5M sq ft (scale reference only) | Sub-scale: about HKD 508M of property, HKD 26M rent |
Shanghai street-retail shop leasing | Numerous private landlords; state-owned and listed developers' commercial arms (not quantified) | Price-taker; tenant-concentrated |
PRC convenience stores (Shanghai, Anshan) | Lawson China, FamilyMart China, 7-Eleven China, Bianlifeng (private), Lianhua Supermarket (HKEX 980) | Negligible share; exited 2022 |
Moutai / baijiu specialty retail | Kweichow Moutai's own direct channels (i-Moutai app, flagship stores); JD.com and Tmall; large liquor chains (e.g. 1919) | Single-store operator |
Property management (Anshan) | Country Garden Services, Vanke Services, local operators | One-client operator; exited 2022 |
Key Competitors
| Company | Revenue (HKD Mn) | Net result (HKD Mn) | Market value (HKD Mn) | Data basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Sky Chinafortune (141) | 31.71 | -59.14 | 62.17 (last traded) | FY2022 audited; last price |
Hong Kong Shanghai Alliance (1001) | 2,110 | 89.62 | 257.8 | Simply Wall St TTM, Nov 2025 (aggregator) |
Silver Grant (171) | — | — | 191.30 | Moomoo snapshot (aggregator, date unclear) |
Great China Holdings (HK) (21) | — | Profit (FY2024 positive alert) | 465 to 557 | TipRanks 2025 snapshots (aggregator) |
Recent Developments
This is expected for a delisted, privately held Hong Kong company with no continuing disclosure obligations. The newsflow register below therefore covers the last 25 publicly documented developments**, from January 2021 to April 2023, so the record is complete.



