Zarclear Holdings Limited Overview
Zarclear Holdings is a small South African permanent-capital investment holding company. It was spun out of Peregrine Holdings in 2017 as Sandown Capital. In late 2018 a new management team led by Warren Chapman, an executive linked to the Peresec / Legae Peresec brokerage group, took control and changed its mandate. The company pursues two strategies. The first is a liquid, NAV-focused portfolio, now concentrated in a Peresec-issued equity index basket-linked note referencing Peregrine Capital hedge fund strategies and in a 23.8% stake in the unlisted investment company African Phoenix Investments. The second is a small, earnings-focused cluster of South African financial-market infrastructure and regulatory-technology businesses. The flagship of that cluster is a 60%-owned securities lending intermediary with an R8.8bn loan book. Zarclear has paid back capital, delisted, and is now effectively controlled by a concert group of related holders that owns 91%. Following a 2023 share consolidation and conversion to private-company form, it operates as a closely held vehicle with minimal public disclosure.
Company's own description
In its 2023 response circular, Zarclear describes itself as an investment holding company that uses its status as a permanent capital vehicle to invest in high-quality opportunities, with a focus on financial market infrastructure companies that benefit from liquid, flexible capital, a broad shareholder base, sector expertise and management networks [S5]. Its website headline reads "Focused on financial market infrastructure" [S21].
The FY2022 directors' report sets out a two-leg strategy [S4]:
Leg 1: a portfolio of listed equities, contracts for difference, fixed income and other instruments that provides liquidity, transparency and market-related returns, and whose liquidity supports leg two.
Leg 2: developing, investing in and managing market-infrastructure and regulation-technology operations. Targets include regulated exchanges, trade repositories, clearing houses, securities depositories and investment and technology platforms, mainly in South Africa.
Independent characterisation
In practice Zarclear operates as a closed-end, NAV-driven holding company with three types of exposure:
-
Managed liquid capital. Through FY2021 this was Stenprop / Industrials REIT shares, hedge funds and a directly managed portfolio. By June 2022 it had been consolidated into a single Equity Index Basket Linked Note (EIBL) valued at R438.2m. The note was issued by related party Peresec Prime Brokers and its return is linked mainly to a Peregrine Capital-managed hedge fund portfolio [S4].
-
A strategic cross-holding. Zarclear holds 335,435,546 shares (about 23.8%) in African Phoenix Investments Limited, valued at R300.2m at 30 Jun 2022. African Phoenix in turn holds about 29% of Zarclear (excluding treasury shares) [S4].
-
Operating market-infrastructure subsidiaries and stakes. These are Zarclear Securities Lending (60%), Peresec Technology Solutions (100%; appears to be the renamed Zarclear Proprietary, see §5), African Phoenix A2X Proprietary Limited (100%; holds an effective 6.97% of the A2X exchange, carried at nil), and a 5.47% stake in Equity Express Securities Exchange [S4].
Revenue model. Group "income" has two parts:
Investment income: realised and unrealised fair-value gains, dividends and interest on portfolio investments. This dominates, at R295.7m of R340.0m total income in FY2022 (87%).
Fee income: technology services and securities lending intermediation fees from the infrastructure subsidiaries, R44.3m in FY2022 (13%) [S4].
There is no product sales, subscription or licensing revenue in the conventional sense. The fee business is service- and intermediation-based.
Value-chain position. Zarclear supplies capital (and, through subsidiaries, intermediation and technology services) to South Africa's capital-markets plumbing. Zarclear Securities Lending sits between lenders of scrip (typically banks and large securities holders) and borrowers (typically short sellers). It borrows and on-lends securities under Global Master Securities Lending Agreements (GMSLAs) and does not borrow for its own account [S4].
Customer types. Securities lenders and borrowers, financial services firms buying trading technology and advisory services [S1], and the wider South African institutional market. A material share of activity involves related parties. Peresec Prime Brokers is both service provider and client, and holds the group's stockbroking accounts and the EIBL [S3, S4].
End-markets. South African equity trading and securities financing, alternative exchanges (A2X, Equity Express), and hedge-fund-style equity strategies.
Strategy
Stated strategy (themes from the FY2022 directors' report and 2023 circulars)
-
NAV per share growth is the main key performance indicator and the measure used for trading statements [S4].
-
Two-leg strategy:
-
Liquid market-related portfolio (listed equities, contracts for difference, fixed income), with its liquidity supporting:
-
High-conviction market-infrastructure and regulatory-technology investments in which management actively engages [S4].
-
-
Target sectors: regulated exchanges, trade repositories, clearing houses, securities depositories, investment and technology platforms [S4].
-
Investment approach: low initial investment, technology-led businesses that benefit from new regulation and legislation [S4].
-
Use of cash: the board expects the investment strategy to deploy excess cash resources [S4].
-
Dividends: none declared in FY2022. The board will keep options under review [S4].
Strategic initiatives in the last 24 months (Oct 2024–Oct 2026)
No Zarclear-specific strategic announcements were found in the public record for this period. The last company publication is dated 23 August 2023 [S21]. As a private company after the 2023 scheme, Zarclear has no continuing disclosure obligation.
Most recent disclosed initiatives (2021–2023)
| Initiative | Date | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delisting and R4.60 repurchase offer | Aug–Oct 2021 | Removed listing costs; 2,904,491 shares repurchased | S4, S22 |
| African Phoenix share-for-share scheme | Mar–Jun 2022 | 7 African Phoenix shares per Zarclear share, to remove the cross-holding, cut costs, enlarge the balance sheet and gain African Phoenix's B-BBEE credentials. Approved by shareholders; not implemented. | S4, S10 |
| Portfolio simplification into the EIBL | May 2022 | Directly managed portfolio replaced by a Peresec-issued note referencing Peregrine Capital strategies | S4 |
| Scheme of arrangement | Jul–Aug 2023 | 10,000,000:1 consolidation; R6.00 top-up issue; R6.35 odd-lot repurchase; conversion to a private company | S6, S7, S9 |
ESG and cost programmes
No quantified ESG targets or formal cost programmes have been disclosed. The delisting and the 2023 scheme were justified partly by lower listing, administrative and shareholder-register costs [S2, S6].
Medium-term financial targets and guidance
None publicly disclosed. The 2023 independent expert relied on management forecasts for FY2023–FY2028, but these were not published [S5, S6].
Products & Services
Market infrastructure and regulation-technology
| Offering / entity | Description | Target customer | Launch / acquisition | Pricing model | Status / latest data |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zarclear Securities Lending (Pty) Ltd (60%), formerly Envisionit Stock Lending Solutions (RF) (Pty) Ltd | Intermediary securities lending. Borrows scrip from lenders and on-lends to borrowers under GMSLAs; no proprietary borrowing. Some transactions offered with an indemnity of borrower obligations. Collateral always exceeds the loan value. | Banks and large securities holders (lenders); short sellers and other borrowers | Acquired 1 Mar 2019 for R15.2m [S1] | Intermediation fees (amounts not separately disclosed) | Loan book R8.8bn and collateral R10.5bn at 30 Jun 2022 (FY2021: R6.3bn / R7.8bn) [S4]. No defaults reported to date [S4]. Zarclear Holdings guarantees ZSL's GMSLA obligations [S3, S4]. |
| Peresec Technology Solutions (Pty) Ltd (100%), formerly Zarclear Proprietary Limited | Trading technology, infrastructure, software development, advisory support and implementation services for financial services firms [S1]. Applied for a trade repository licence [S1]. | Financial services companies, including related-party brokers | Subscribed 6 Nov 2018; capitalised 29 Mar 2019 (R15.0m) [S1] | Technology service fees | In FY2022 Zarclear holds 100% of "Peresec Technology Solutions", described as subscribed in FY2019, at a cost of R15.0m [S4]. The same cost and timing as Zarclear Proprietary suggest a rename, though no explicit rename disclosure was found. PTS recharged R15.7m of payroll to the holding company in FY2022 [S4]. |
| Trade repository initiative | Planned OTC-derivatives trade repository under South African regulation; R0.45m licence cost and R2.56m internally developed software capitalised in FY2019 [S1] | Market participants subject to trade-reporting rules | FY2019 | Not launched | Fully impaired at 30 Jun 2020 because of licence uncertainty and further investment needs [S2]. Status since then not disclosed. |
| African Phoenix A2X (Pty) Ltd (100%), formerly Nala A2X | Holding vehicle for an effective 6.97% of A2X Proprietary Limited, the licensed secondary-listing exchange (7.44% in FY2021) [S4] | n/a (investment) | Formed 4 Dec 2017; renamed and 100%-owned from 1 Feb 2021 [S1, S4] | — | Carried at nil since full impairment in FY2020. Directors judged dividends in the near-to-medium term remote [S4]. Also holds the 2,904,491 treasury shares repurchased at delisting [S4]. |
| Equity Express Securities Exchange (Pty) Ltd (5.47%) | South African holding company with financial-services interests, including an exchange [S2, S4] | n/a (investment) | Acquired 25 Mar 2020 for R2.19m [S2] | — | Carried at cost, R2.19m [S4] |
| Catalyst Advisory (Pty) Ltd redeemable preference shares (held by ZSL) | Supplier-development preference shares linked to B-BBEE strategy and compliance [S4] | — | Jun 2020 (R0.48m) [S2] | — | R0.16m at 30 Jun 2022 [S4] |
Portfolio investments
| Holding | Description | Stake | Fair value at 30 Jun 2022 (ZAR Mn) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Equity Index Basket Linked Note (EIBL) | Regulated but unlisted note issued by Peresec Prime Brokers. Return linked to a basket mainly managed by Peregrine Capital as a hedge fund, plus other instruments. | 3,588,183.31 units at R122.13 | 438.2 | Bought May 2022 with proceeds from the directly managed portfolio. Related party. FV gain R77.8m in FY2022 [S4]. |
| African Phoenix Investments Ltd | Unlisted investment holding company (delisted Apr/Jun 2020). Holds about 29% of Zarclear. | 335,435,546 shares (23.84%) | 300.2 | Valued at NAV after the cross-holding: 89.5c per share (FY2021: 50c) [S4] |
| Rinjani Holdings Ltd (BVI) | Property holding company, run off through pro-rata buy-backs | 79.41% | 26.6 | Fair value adjustment -R1.7m in FY2022 [S4] |
| UIVCA – Business Venture Investments No 2137 Ltd | Unlisted position, the remainder of the directly managed portfolio | 383,572 units | 15.5 | [S4] |
| Kropz plc | Offshore-listed equity (5,000,000 shares) | — | 8.2 | FV gain R0.2m [S4] |
| Firefly Investments 61 | Private equity fund partnership | 50% | 0.001 | Main asset sold in FY2019 (R8.2m profit share) [S1] |
| Industrials REIT (formerly Stenprop) | UK multi-let industrial REIT (LSE/JSE) | Exited | 0 | Final 10,000,000 shares sold for R376.6m, with a R62.9m final fair-value gain [S4] |
| Peregrine Capital High Growth Offshore Segregated Portfolio (USD) | Offshore hedge fund (formerly SA Alpha Fund) | Exited | 0 | Redeemed for R61.9m in FY2022 [S4] |
Financial Narrative
Basis. IFRS consolidated. Zarclear applies the IFRS 10 investment-entity exemption: majority-held portfolio companies and associates held for investment are measured at fair value, not consolidated or equity-accounted [S4]. FY2018 and FY2019 [S1]; FY2020 [S2]; FY2021 and FY2022 [S4, S5]. FY2020 covers 15 months.
Income statement
Notes:
-
Gross profit is not a reported line for this investment holding company.
-
FY2022 EPS is not stated in the circular reproduction [S5]. The 105.0c figure is derived: R235.2m divided by about 224.1m weighted shares (226,065,696 less 2,904,491 treasury shares from late October 2021).
-
FY2021 HEPS is 83.48c per ShareData [S11] and 83.49c per the circular [S5]. The source documents conflict.
-
The FY2018 dividend was R2.5m (1.11c) [S1].
-
The FY2021 distribution of 190c was a capital reduction (return of contributed tax capital), paid December 2020 [S3].
-
EBITDA is derived as operating profit plus depreciation. It has limited meaning for a fair-value investment holding company.
Margin analysis (% of total income; blank = not meaningful because total income was negative)
Derived from [S1, S2, S4]. Opex/average equity uses average attributable equity. The FY2020 figure is for 15 months; annualised it is 5.3%.
Revenue (total income) CAGR, FY2019→FY2022: 30.8% a year over the 3.25 years from 31 Mar 2019 to 30 Jun 2022 (R142.1m to R340.0m, derived). The growth comes almost entirely from fair-value investment income, so it should not be read as recurring revenue growth.
NAV per share CAGR, 31 Mar 2018 → 30 Jun 2022: 5.1% a year (487c to 601c). Including the 190c capital return, the total NAV return was about 12.1% a year (derived).
Balance sheet: notes and sources
Sources: [S1, S2, S4]. The FY2018 debt was a loan from Peregrine SA Holdings at one-month JIBAR plus 250bp, fully repaid by 1 June 2018 [S1]. During FY2020 the group borrowed from Legae Peresec to buy the African Phoenix shares, repaid by 30 Jun 2020, with R10.7m interest paid [S2].
Cash flow
Notes:
-
FY2019 operating cash flow is the restated figure. It was originally reported as -R55.5m, with R649.7m in investing activities. The JSE Proactive Monitoring process required investment disposal proceeds to be reclassified into operating activities [S2]. FY2018 is shown as originally reported, before that reclassification [S1].
-
The FY2022 buyback (R13.4m for 2,904,491 shares at R4.60) was executed by unconsolidated subsidiary African Phoenix A2X and funded by a loan from Zarclear. It appears as "loans advanced" in investing activities [S4].
-
Operating cash flow includes portfolio purchases and disposals. For example, FY2022 includes -R390.3m invested in financial instruments and +R465.1m of disposal proceeds [S4].
Ratios (derived; blank = not meaningful)
Notes:
-
Net debt/EBITDA is not meaningful because the group had net cash in FY2019–FY2022.
-
FY2021 interest paid was R2 thousand, so coverage is not meaningful.
-
ROIC and the cash conversion cycle do not apply to a fair-value investment holding company with no inventory or trade debtors in the operating sense.
-
FY2020 ROE and ROA cover 15 months.
-
The low FY2020 current ratio and ROA reflect about R1.07bn of securities-lending collateral grossed up in receivables and payables [S2].
-
Company-reported cash shares of NAV: 46% at 31 Mar 2019 [S1]; 55% at 30 Jun 2020 [S2]; 43% at 30 Sep 2019 [S29].
Commentary on trends, inflections and drivers
FY2018: transition year. The year covers the Peregrine restructure and listing. Total income was -R44.1m, driven by hedge-fund losses (-R34.6m) and listed-equity fair-value losses (-R24.3m). Operating expenses were R23.9m, including R8.9m of one-off listing and restructuring costs and R8.0m of advisory fees to Sandown Management [S1]. Attributable loss was R51.4m and NAV was 487c.
FY2019: governance reset. Hedge-fund returns of R114.7m and a weaker Rand lifted investment income to R133.9m [S1]. That was offset by a R75.0m investment-advisory charge, which included the R63m fee to terminate the external management agreement [S1]. Cash rose from R76m to R558m. The increase came from redeeming hedge funds (Peregrine GreenOak R51.8m, Flexible Opportunities R80m, Stenham R35.2m), Rinjani buy-backs (R126.7m in total) and recovering R92.7m from Capital Step [S1]. The external manager's fee drag was removed, but the rebalancing cost one year of NAV growth.
FY2020 (15 months): diversification into African Phoenix and COVID volatility. Zarclear spent R249.4m (about 22%, August 2019) and then R9.2m on African Phoenix shares. It received a R130.7m capital-reduction distribution from African Phoenix, leaving a net cost of R127.9m [S2]. Investment income of R68.7m included a R46.1m realised foreign-currency gain and a -R124.4m fair-value write-down on African Phoenix, partly offset by the R130.7m distribution [S2]. The full-year infrastructure segment lost R23.7m after impairments [S2]. NAV still reached 600c, mainly because of Rand weakness and cash accumulation (55% of NAV) [S2].
FY2021: realisation and capital return. Investment income of R289.8m was the highest in the five-year period, helped by Stenprop disposals at favourable prices and a recovery in the directly managed portfolio [S3, S4]. The R429.5m capital reduction in December 2020 cut NAV per share to 474c despite record earnings [S3, S4]. The pre-distribution like-for-like NAV increase in H1 FY2021 was 5.2% [S3].
FY2022: concentration into the EIBL and African Phoenix. The group sold its last 10m Industrials REIT shares for R376.6m (a R62.9m realised fair-value gain) and redeemed the offshore segregated portfolio for R61.9m [S4]. It then moved most of its liquid capital into the Peresec-issued EIBL (R438.2m at year end, including a R77.8m fair-value gain) [S4]. African Phoenix was revalued from 50c to 89.5c per share, a R132.5m uplift [S4]. Taxation fell to R20.2m (effective rate 7.8%) because fair-value adjustments on African Phoenix are expected to be recovered tax-free through dividends and group relief [S4].
Structural observations.
-
Earnings quality is low. Over 85% of income is fair-value or realised investment gains, so results depend on market conditions.
-
The operating cost base of R85–93m a year is high for an entity with about R1.3bn NAV. It equals roughly 7% of equity a year, although it includes the securities-lending and technology subsidiaries' costs.
-
By FY2022 the portfolio was heavily concentrated: the EIBL and African Phoenix together were R738m, about 55% of attributable equity, and both are tied to the controlling shareholder group.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansFinancial Detail
Income Statement and Per-Share Data
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Investment income (ZAR Mn) | -44.1 | 133.9 | 68.7 | 289.8 | 295.7 |
Fee income (ZAR Mn) | 0.0 | 8.2 | 52.1 | 35.5 | 44.3 |
Total income / revenue (ZAR Mn) | -44.1 | 142.1 | 120.8 | 325.3 | 340.0 |
Impairment charges (ZAR Mn) | 0.0 | 0.0 | -5.9 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
Operating expenses (ZAR Mn) | -23.9 | -90.8 | -85.4 | -92.5 | -88.6 |
Operating profit (ZAR Mn) | -68.0 | 51.3 | 29.5 | 232.8 | 251.5 |
Depreciation and amortisation (ZAR Mn) | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.3 | 0.3 | 0.3 |
EBITDA, derived (ZAR Mn) | -68.0 | 51.3 | 29.8 | 233.1 | 251.8 |
Interest received (ZAR Mn) | 0.7 | 3.3 | 29.0 | 16.6 | 8.7 |
Interest paid (ZAR Mn) | -6.4 | -2.5 | -10.9 | 0.0 | -0.5 |
Profit before tax (ZAR Mn) | -73.7 | 52.0 | 47.7 | 249.4 | 259.7 |
Taxation (ZAR Mn) | 22.2 | -24.9 | 1.9 | -58.4 | -20.2 |
Profit for the year (ZAR Mn) | -51.4 | 27.2 | 49.6 | 191.0 | 239.4 |
Profit attributable to equity holders (ZAR Mn) | -51.4 | 26.9 | 45.6 | 188.7 | 235.2 |
Total comprehensive income (ZAR Mn) | -86.4 | 112.4 | 147.1 | 146.9 | 273.9 |
Basic and diluted EPS reported (ZAR cents) | -26.56 | 11.91 | 20.18 | 83.48 | — |
Basic EPS derived (ZAR cents) | — | — | — | — | 105.0 |
Headline EPS reported (ZAR cents) | -26.56 | 11.91 | 22.78 | 83.48 | — |
Dividends / distributions per share (ZAR cents) | 1.11 | 0 | 0 | 190 | 0 |
NAV per share (ZAR cents) | 487 | 537 | 600 | 474 | 601 |
Effective tax rate (%) | 30.2 | 47.8 | -4.0 | 23.4 | 7.8 |
Margin Analysis (%)
| Metric | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Operating margin (%) | 36.1 | 24.4 | 71.6 | 74.0 |
EBITDA margin, derived (%) | 36.1 | 24.7 | 71.7 | 74.1 |
Pre-tax margin (%) | 36.6 | 39.5 | 76.7 | 76.4 |
Net margin, attributable (%) | 19.0 | 37.8 | 58.0 | 69.2 |
Opex as % of average equity (%) | 7.8 | 6.6 | 7.6 | 7.3 |
Balance Sheet and Share Count (M)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Total assets (ZAR Mn) | 1,223.1 | 1,275.2 | 2,429.6 | 1,486.9 | 1,437.5 |
Cash and cash equivalents (ZAR Mn) | 76.4 | 558.3 | 745.1 | 541.4 | 552.1 |
Financial investments, total (ZAR Mn) | 1,096.0 | 611.4 | 461.6 | 418.4 | 490.8 |
Investments in associates (ZAR Mn) | 22.9 | 28.5 | 134.2 | 167.7 | 300.2 |
Trade and other receivables (ZAR Mn) | 0.2 | 58.1 | 1,069.8 | 339.0 | 63.1 |
Goodwill and intangibles (ZAR Mn) | 0.0 | 17.9 | 14.9 | 14.9 | 14.9 |
Current assets (ZAR Mn) | 590.4 | 777.6 | 1,894.4 | 969.7 | 629.4 |
Current liabilities (ZAR Mn) | 121.4 | 57.5 | 1,068.2 | 350.3 | 62.9 |
Working capital (ZAR Mn) | 468.9 | 720.1 | 826.1 | 619.4 | 566.5 |
Short-term debt (ZAR Mn) | 120.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
Long-term debt (ZAR Mn) | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
Net debt (ZAR Mn) | 43.6 | -558.3 | -745.1 | -541.4 | -552.1 |
Trade and other payables (ZAR Mn) | 1.4 | 57.3 | 1,067.6 | 350.2 | 62.9 |
Total liabilities (ZAR Mn) | 121.4 | 61.0 | 1,068.3 | 408.2 | 84.9 |
Equity attributable to holders (ZAR Mn) | 1,101.7 | 1,213.8 | 1,356.9 | 1,072.1 | 1,341.8 |
Non-controlling interests (ZAR Mn) | 0.0 | 0.4 | 4.4 | 6.6 | 10.8 |
Total equity (ZAR Mn) | 1,101.7 | 1,214.2 | 1,361.3 | 1,078.7 | 1,352.6 |
Shares in issue (M) | 226.1 | 226.1 | 226.1 | 226.1 | 226.1 |
Shares in issue excluding treasury (M) | 226.1 | 226.1 | 226.1 | 226.1 | 223.2 |
Cash Flow
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Operating cash flow (ZAR Mn) | -15.9 | 612.9 | 177.1 | 233.3 | 7.9 |
Capex: plant, equipment, intangibles (ZAR Mn) | 0.0 | -3.5 | -4.2 | -0.1 | -0.1 |
Free cash flow, derived (ZAR Mn) | -15.9 | 609.4 | 172.9 | 233.2 | 7.8 |
Dividends / capital distributions paid (ZAR Mn) | -2.5 | 0.0 | 0.0 | -429.5 | 0.0 |
Share buybacks (ZAR Mn) | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | -13.4 |
Net change in cash (ZAR Mn) | -79.3 | 474.2 | 172.9 | -196.3 | -5.6 |
Margin Analysis (%) and Financial Ratios (x)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ROE on closing attributable equity (%) | -4.7 | 2.2 | 3.4 | 17.6 | 17.5 |
ROA on closing total assets (%) | -4.2 | 2.1 | 2.0 | 12.8 | 16.7 |
Current ratio (x) | 4.86 | 13.53 | 1.77 | 2.77 | 10.00 |
Debt to equity (x) | 0.11 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
Interest coverage, operating profit / interest paid (x) | — | 20.1 | 2.7 | — | 514.2 |
Asset turnover, total income / total assets (x) | — | 0.11 | 0.05 | 0.22 | 0.24 |
Cash as % of total assets (%) | 6.2 | 43.8 | 30.7 | 36.4 | 38.4 |
Cash as % of NAV, company-reported (%) | — | 46 | 55 | — | — |
Revenue by Region and Revenue by Region (%)
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cash in ZAR (ZAR Mn) | 8.0 | 316.5 | 716.4 | 470.0 | 20.3 |
Cash in USD, GBP and EUR (ZAR Mn) | 68.4 | 241.8 | 28.6 | 71.4 | 531.8 |
Foreign share of cash (%) | 89.5 | 43.3 | 3.8 | 13.2 | 96.3 |
Region Assets & Liabilities
| Metric | FY2021 | FY2022 |
|---|---|---|
USD-denominated assets (ZAR Mn) | 107.9 | 298.0 |
EUR-denominated assets (ZAR Mn) | 0.0 | 27.0 |
GBP-denominated assets (ZAR Mn) | 348.7 | 241.6 |
Total foreign-currency assets (ZAR Mn) | 456.6 | 566.6 |
Margin Analysis (%) and Market Valuation
| Metric | FY2018 | FY2019 | FY2020 | FY2021 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Discount to NAV at year end (%) | 35 | 28 | 32.3 | — |
Market capitalisation at year end (ZAR Mn) | — | — | 926.9 | 949.5 |
Implied share price at year end, derived (ZAR cents) | 317 | 387 | 410 | 420 |
Price to NAV, derived (x) | 0.65 | 0.72 | 0.68 | 0.89 |
P/E, derived (x) | — | 32.5 | 20.3 | 5.0 |
Share Price & Returns
| Date | Event | Price per Zarclear share | Context | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Oct 2017 | Pre-listing intrinsic NAV | R5.60 | R1.265bn NAV | S17 |
Sep 2020 | Legae Peresec general offer | R4.40 | Below Nodus fair value range | S2 |
Oct 2021 | Delisting repurchase offer | R4.60 | Funded from reserves; taxed as a dividend | S12 |
Mar 2022 | African Phoenix scheme | 7 African Phoenix shares (about R6.15 at the 87.9c African Phoenix NAV) | 6% premium to the R5.80 Zarclear NAV | S10 |
Jul–Aug 2023 | TRP-mandated offer | R3.55 | Judged unfair and unreasonable | S5 |
Jul–Aug 2023 | Odd-lot repurchase / top-up | R6.35 / R6.00 | Judged fair and reasonable; 5.8% premium to June 2022 NAV | S6 |
Jun 2023 | Valeo sum-of-the-parts | R5.57–R6.37 (core R5.97) | Uses DCF, multiples and NAV | S5, S6 |
Capital Markets
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
Valuation multiples vs peers (P/E, EV/EBITDA, EV/Sales, P/B) | Not applicable (unlisted). Last listed P/E was 5.5x at 460c [S11]. |
Analyst consensus | None. ShareData provides a forecasts page, but no broker coverage was identified. |
Dividend history | FY2018: R2.5m (1.11c) [S1]; FY2019–FY2020: nil [S1, S2]; Dec 2020: 190c capital reduction (R429.5m) [S3]; FY2022: nil [S4]. Stated policy: reinvest, with options kept under review [S4]. |
Buyback authorisations | Oct 2021 delisting repurchase of 2,904,491 shares for R13.4m [S4]. 2023 odd-lot repurchase at R6.35 [S6]. No standing programme disclosed. |
Debt maturity profile | No borrowings at FY2022 [S4] |
Post-scheme capital structure | 10,000,000:1 consolidation; authorised capital to be consolidated to 50 shares (or 120 shares if increased to 1.2bn before consolidation) [S6]. Final issued share count not published. |
Analyst Conclusions
Management guidance and consensus
There is no public management guidance. No consensus estimates exist. The 2023 independent expert used management forecasts for FY2023–FY2028, which were not published [S5]. Its key value drivers were growth in assets under management, margins on those assets, and the fair value of the underlying portfolio [S5].
Bull case
-
NAV and cash support value. NAV of R6.01 per share (Jun 2022) was mostly liquid or near-liquid: R552m cash plus a redeemable R438m note. Total equity was R1.35bn [S4].
-
The securities-lending franchise is growing. The loan book rose from R6.3bn to R8.8bn in FY2022 with no defaults [S4]. Fee income increased 24.8% [S4, S5].
-
The A2X stake is free optionality. It is carried at nil despite A2X value traded rising more than 100-fold since launch and A2X listing 31 of the JSE Top 40 [S4, S23].
Bear case
-
Governance and related-party risk dominates. The CEO controls about 46% and is on both sides of the African Phoenix, Hampden, Ancilla and Peresec relationships. The TRP found grounds to impose a mandatory offer, and a court challenge is pending [S5, S20].
-
Earnings are mostly market beta and fair-value marks. Over 85% of income is investment income, and Level 3 directors' valuations (R344.7m) drive a large part of NAV [S4].
-
The infrastructure strategy has under-delivered. The trade repository and Nala A2X were impaired. Infrastructure segment profit was negative for FY2020 and only R1.9m in H1 FY2021 against a group cost base of about R89m [S2, S3, S4].
Catalysts and monitorables (next 12 months)
-
Outcome of C Butters v TRP in the High Court [S20].
-
Any CIPC filing confirming conversion to Zarclear Holdings Proprietary Limited [S6].
-
Whether the African Phoenix cross-holding is collapsed through a renewed merger [S10].
-
Signs of performance from A2X or Equity Express that could prompt a revaluation [S4].
-
Changes in Zarclear Securities Lending's book size and collateral cover [S4].
-
Any update to the stale zarclear.com website, or new financial disclosure [S21].
Analyst verdict
Zarclear Holdings is best understood as a controlled, private family-office-style vehicle with a public-company history, not as an investable listed equity. Its listed period (2017–2021) shows reasonable portfolio management: the legacy Stenprop stake was sold for more than R560m in disclosed tranches, R429.5m was returned to shareholders, and NAV per share compounded at about 12% a year including that distribution (March 2018 to June 2022). The 2018 removal of the external manager, though costly at R75m in FY2019 advisory charges, improved the cost structure.
The weaknesses are just as clear. The market-infrastructure thesis, the intended differentiator, has generated small and volatile fee income (R35–52m a year) and two full impairments. By June 2022 more than half of equity sat in two instruments linked to the controlling group: a Peresec-issued note and the circular African Phoenix holding valued on directors' NAV estimates. The TRP's 2022–2023 investigation into undisclosed concert-party conduct, and the continuing court challenge to its settlement, are material governance concerns for any counterparty or minority holder.
For research and competitive-intelligence purposes, the most current reliable facts are as follows:
-
The last audited NAV was R1,341.8m (601c per share, June 2022).
-
An independent fair value range of R5.57–R6.37 per share was set in June 2023.
-
A concert group led by Warren Chapman holds 91.17%.
-
In August 2023 the company approved a share consolidation and conversion to private-company form.
-
No financial disclosure exists after FY2022.
The data should be treated as historical, and any later figure should be confirmed directly with the company or through CIPC filings. On the evidence available, Zarclear's value lies in its net cash and securities-lending book, while its risks lie in governance, related-party concentration and opacity. It is a monitoring case, not an actionable investment case.
Unlock Company Financials
Unlock this company profile to view its financial data.
View Subscription PlansExecutive Leadership
Board of Directors
| Name | Role | Tenure / notes |
|---|---|---|
Kgosie (Zolani "ZK") Matthews | Chairman; independent non-executive director; chair of 2023 independent board | Appears in the director list by Sept 2020 [S2]; FY2022 audit committee member [S4] |
Warren Chapman | Chief Executive Officer; executive director | Appointed 5 Sep 2018 [S1]. Director of Legae Peresec Holdings [S2]. Indirect 46.0% of Zarclear, 40.4% of African Phoenix and 33.1% of Zolospan; sole director of Hampden Capital and Ancilla Capital [S5]. Also executive director of African Phoenix [S5]. |
Linda Maqoma | Independent non-executive director | Appointment date not disclosed (after Nov 2022) |
Jeffrey Goudvis | Independent non-executive director | Appointment date not disclosed (after Nov 2022) |
K de Almeida, CA(SA) | Group Chief Financial Officer (not a director) | Supervised preparation of the FY2022 AFS [S4] |
Board & Management Changes
| Period | Directors | Source |
|---|---|---|
Listing, Nov 2017 | Lawrie Brozin (independent non-executive chair), Sean Melnick (CEO), Sean Jelley (CFO; former CFO of Media24, Pioneer Foods and Sea Harvest), Duncan Randall, Cindy Hess, Andrew Hannington (non-executive). Mandy Yachad resigned 29 Nov 2017. | S1, S14, S16 |
5 Sep 2018 reconstitution | Brozin, Melnick, Jelley, Randall and Hess resigned. Warren Chapman (CEO), Paul Baloyi (Chair), Mandy (Amanda) Munro-Smith and Fatima Vawda appointed. Hannington became executive CFO. | S1 |
FY2020–FY2021 | Paul Baloyi (Chair), Warren Chapman (CEO), Andrew Hannington (CFO), Fatima Vawda, Amanda Munro-Smith, Kgosie Matthews | S2, S3 |
FY2022 | W Chapman (CEO), P Baloyi, A Munro-Smith (executive), F Vawda, Z Matthews. A Hannington resigned 30 Jun 2022. | S4 |
Jul 2023 | Matthews (Chair), Chapman (CEO), Maqoma, Goudvis | S5 |
Directors' Remuneration
| Director | FY2021 salary | FY2021 bonus | FY2021 total | FY2022 salary | FY2022 allowances | FY2022 bonus | FY2022 total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
W Chapman (CEO) | 900 | 0 | 909 | 900 | 41 | 3,000 | 3,941 |
A Munro-Smith | 1,913 | 400 | 2,622 | 1,300 | 13 | 0 | 1,313 |
A Hannington (CFO; resigned Jun 2022) | 1,500 | 500 | 2,021 | 1,375 | 16 | 0 | 1,391 |
Total executive | — | — | 5,552 | — | — | — | 6,645 |
Directors' Remuneration — P Baloyi
| Director | Director fees | Committee fees | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
P Baloyi | 440 | 198 | 638 |
F Vawda | 176 | 231 | 407 |
Z Matthews | 176 | 187 | 363 |
Total | 792 | 616 | 1,408 |
Major Shareholders
| Holder | Shares | % of issued |
|---|---|---|
African Phoenix Investments Ltd | 64,846,265 | 28.68 |
Hampden Capital (Pty) Ltd (Chapman-controlled) | 56,442,751 | 24.97 |
Zolospan (Pty) Ltd | 46,500,000 | 20.57 |
SBSA ITF Sui Generis LPFP H4 QHF | 31,809,984 | 14.07 |
Sui Generis Opportunities Segregated Fund | 13,750,000 | 6.08 |
Total | 213,349,000 | 94.37 |
Competitive Landscape
Competitors by Segment
| Segment | Competitor | Type | Relative positioning (qualitative) |
|---|---|---|---|
Investment holding | African Phoenix Investments | Unlisted holdco (cross-holder) | Both competitor and related party. NAV about R1.2bn per its 2022 statement [S10]. |
Investment holding | Sabvest Capital | JSE-listed investment holding company | — |
Investment holding | Hosken Consolidated Investments (HCI) | JSE-listed conglomerate holdco | — |
Investment holding | Brait | JSE/LuxSE-listed investment holding company | — |
Investment holding | Trematon Capital Investments | JSE-listed investment holding company | — |
Investment holding | Astoria Investments | Listed investment holding company | — |
Securities lending | Bank securities-lending desks (e.g., Standard Bank, Absa, RMB, Nedbank, Investec) | Bank principals and agents | Larger balance sheets and lender relationships; Zarclear Securities Lending acts as an indemnifying intermediary |
Securities lending / prime | Peresec | Broker / prime broker | Related party. Most active trader on A2X in March 2023 [S23]. |
Market infrastructure | JSE Limited | Incumbent exchange group | Dominant venue; A2X value traded was about 2% of JSE's in 2023 [S23] |
Market infrastructure | A2X Markets | Secondary-listing exchange | Zarclear investee (6.97% effective). Co-founded by Sean Melnick (former Sandown CEO), Ashley Mendelowitz and Kevin Brady [S23]. |
Market infrastructure | Cape Town Stock Exchange; Integrated Exchange (I-EX) | Alternative exchanges | Competing venues profiled in 2025 industry coverage [S23 context] |
Market infrastructure | Equity Express Securities Exchange | Exchange / holding company | Zarclear investee (5.47%) |
Regulatory technology / trade repository | Incumbent South African market-infrastructure operators | Licensed infrastructure | — |
Competitor Detail
| Metric (FY2022) | Zarclear |
|---|---|
Total income (ZAR Mn) | 340.0 |
Growth in total income YoY (%) | 4.5 |
Operating margin (%) | 74.0 |
NAV per share growth YoY (%) | 26.8 |
Recent Developments
Disclosure note: * Zarclear has published nothing since 23 August 2023 [S21]. Within the 18-month window (April 2025–October 2026), the only related public reference found is enX Group's disclosure of continuing litigation over the TRP settlement [S20].



